3 ms·
To add to what my sibling commentator said - PFAS compounds were originally considered awesome and safe exactly because of the same attributes - relative chemi
by lazide 3y ago
To add to what my sibling commentator said -
PFAS compounds were originally considered awesome and safe exactly because of the same attributes - relative chemical inertness. Fluorine grabs so strongly onto other atoms, that it essentially makes the resulting compounds invulnerable and non reactive under normal circumstances. Just like sio2/silica/sand, actually.
In many cases, this is actually fine because the molecules don’t happen to be shaped in a problematic way, or block some pathway due to them building up.
In other cases, they are a huge problem because they are problematically shaped, or can bioaccumulate to problematic levels.
Silicon dioxide happens to have such strong binding energy, it plays a similar type of role - and unlike PFAS compounds, which were very novel when first created and don’t exist in nature, we know it is carcinogenic in certain forms, since it is so prevalent in nature and we’ve had time to learn.
Though we’re still learning a lot about these hazards. They are often not obvious or quickly apparent.
Like, as the sibling poster noted, fine crystals (silicosis) and long thin nanoscale rods (mesothelioma from asbestos), albeit those are more complex silicates and not pure.
So while cool that there is an antibiotic property coming from long thin pure silicon rods applied to surfaces, maybe don’t start applying it to everything until we’re sure it won’t cause cancer and accumulate in the environment?
Since unlike iron, copper, etc. and more similar to PFAS compounds, it won’t just biodegrade or oxidize to a different form either.