2 ms·
> SSH pre-auth RCE: root access to most servers on the planet, impacting everyone from hobbyist self-hosters (that's me) to large businesses (of every type imag
by kelnos 3y ago
> SSH pre-auth RCE: root access to most servers on the planet, impacting everyone from hobbyist self-hosters (that's me) to large businesses (of every type imaginable) to probably even some of the security agencies around the world.
No, absolutely not; that didn't actually happen. Most servers on the planet that are running x86_64 Linux are probably not running a rolling-release distro based on .deb or .rpm. Rolling-release (or a beta version of the next OS release) is required because I can't imagine one of them updating to a new version of a library like this until the next major release of their OS, and .deb/.rpm because those are the only build environments where the backdoor would get built into the library. (And on top of that, only systems where sshd is patched to link to libsystemd.)
Also: while I will admit that there are many businesses with abysmal security practices, most will not have ssh exposed to the public internet; that'll require access to the corporate VPN as well. You note this, but fail to recognize the impact.
Even hobbyists probably aren't hit by this in large numbers. I run a VPS for a variety of things, and it runs Debian stable. Assuming this backdoor attempt was never found, it wouldn't get installed on it until mid-/late-2025, when Debian trixie is likely to be released (plus some time for me to get around to upgrading it).
I did have the affected package on my laptop, which runs Debian testing. But I don't have sshd enabled on it all the time, and even if I did, my laptop is rarely on a network without NAT (and I usually opt to tether to my phone when in public rather than use public WiFi). All the other machines on my home network are also running Debian stable, and were unaffected.
I suspect that precious few systems even had the backdoor installed on them, and of those, even fewer were accessible directly on the public internet.
Now this could have been bigger than Stuxnet, if the backdoor had remained secret for -- and I think I'm being generous here -- another year or so.
- lucb1e 3y ago> that didn't actually happen See modulating factors at the bottom. In this case, it didn't because it was caught before making it into a stable release, but only due to sheer luck. The story is still so much bigger than Stuxnet to me because its aim was an actually tangible impact on millions of people's lives > Now this could have been bigger than Stuxnet, if the backdoor had remained secret for -- and I think I'm being generous here -- another year or so. Agreed on that! (To be clear, I still think it's already bigger, not because of the impact it concretely had but because I perceive it to having been very close; but I can understand this/your point of view very well)