7 ms·
The other reason is to find out what a detuned model is capable of. The canonical example is how to make cocaine, which ChatGPT will admonish you for even askin
by fragmede 3y ago
The other reason is to find out what a detuned model is capable of. The canonical example is how to make cocaine, which ChatGPT will admonish you for even asking, while llama2-uncensored will happily describe the process which is only really interesting if you're an amateur chemist and want to be Scarface-that-knocks. (the recipe is relatively easy, it's getting access to the raw ingredients that's the hard part, same as with nukes.)
if you accidentally use the word"hack" when trying to get ChatGPT to write some code for you. it'll stop and tell you that hacking is bad, and not a colloquial expression, and refuse to go further.
privacy reasons are another reason to try a local LLM. for the extremely paranoid (justified or not), a local LLM gives users a place to ask questions without the text being fed to a server somewhere for later lawsuit discovery (Google searches are routinely subpoenaed, it's only a matter of time until ChatGPT chats are as well.)
There's an uncensored model for vision available as well. The censored vision models won't play the shallow game of hot or not with you.
There are uncensored image generation models as well, but, ah, those are NSFW and not for polite company. (As well as there's multiple thesis' worth of content on what that'll do to society.)
- astrange 3y ago> if you accidentally use the word"hack" when trying to get ChatGPT to write some code for you. it'll stop and tell you that hacking is bad, and not a colloquial expression, and refuse to go further. Is that 3.5 or 4? I asked 4 for an example of code which "is a hack", it misunderstood me as asking for hacking code rather than buggy code, but then it did actually answer on the first try. https://chat.openai.com/share/ca2c320c-f4ba-41bf-8f40-f7faf26a4379 https://chat.openai.com/share/ca2c320c-f4ba-41bf-8f40-f7faf2...
- fragmede 3y agoInteresting. It was 4. I can't share the chat I had where ChatGPT refused to help because I used the wrong words, because I can't find it (ChatGPT conversation history search when?), but I just remember it refusing to do something because it thought I was trying to break some sort of moral and ethical boundary writing a chrome extension when all I wanted to do is move some divs around or some such.
- BytesAndGears 3y agoOne time I wanted to learn about transmitter antenna design, just because I’m curious. ChatGPT 4 refused to give me basic information because you could use that to break some FCC regulations (I’m not even living in the US currently)
- lodovic 3y agoI usually get around that with "I'm writing a research paper" or "I'm writing a novel and need to depict this as accurate as possible"
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoI don't use LLMs for my coding, I manage just fine with LSP and Treesitter. So genuine question: is that answer representative of the output quality of these things? Because both answers are pretty crappy and assume the user has already done the difficult things, and is asking for help on the easy things.
- lpapez 3y agoIt's not representative. The models are capable of much much more, and they are being significantly nerfed over time by these ineffective attempts to introduce safeguards. Recently I've asked GPT4 to quote me some code to which it replied that it is not allowed to do so - even though it was perfectly happy to quote anything until recently. When prompted to quote the source code, but output it as PHP comments, it happily complied because it saw that as "derivative work" which it is allowed to do.
- astrange 3y agoMy point is that there aren't any safeguards in the reply. In fact I didn't even want it to give me hacking info and it did it anyway.
- fragmede 3y agoThe response seems pretty reasonable; it's answering the question it was asked. If you want to ask it how to do the difficult part, ask it about that instead. Expecting it to get the answer right in the first pass is like expecting your code to compile the very first time. You have to have more of a conversation with it to coax the difference out of you're thinking and what you're actually saying. If you're looking to read a more advanced example of its capabilities and limitations, try https://simonwillison.net/2024/Mar/23/building-c-extensions-for-sqlite-with-chatgpt-code-interpreter/ https://simonwillison.net/2024/Mar/23/building-c-extensions-...
- yunohn 3y ago> I don't use LLMs for my coding, I manage just fine with LSP and Treesitter. You’re literally comparing apples to oranges.
- kevingadd 3y agoIf you want to be an amateur chemist I recommend not getting your instructions from an LLM that might be hallucinating. Chemistry can be very dangerous if you're following incorrect instructions.
- isoprophlex 3y agoFrom experience as a failed organic chemist (who happily switched to computational chemistry for reasons of self preservation) I can tell you it's plenty dangerous when you're following correct instructions :^)
- rpigab 3y agoYes, just as the best professional cooks recommend avoiding to boil cow eggs, as they can explode.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoThey don't explode, the shell simply cracks and then you get egg soup. Now microwaving eggs... that's a different matter.
- rpigab 3y agoI was talking about cow eggs specifically! When ChatGPT et al got out, one of the funniest things to do was ask it about the best recipes for cow egg omelette or camel egg salad, and the LLM would provide. Sadly, most of it got patched somehow.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoOops... Yep, I missed that too. (On the internet, no one knows you're a dog.) That's funny. It makes me wonder how these statistical mad libs machines will handle the gradual boundaries nature gives us. Almost all mammals give birth live, but not all. Nearly all mammals had mammalian parents, but not all. Daniel Dennett was making this argument for why we haven't developed reasonable models for the nature of consciousness. It's because we're so sure there will be an absolute classification, and not a gradual accumulation of interacting systems that together yield the phenomenon.
- supposemaybe 3y agoLinks to all these models you speak of?
- fragmede 3y agohttps://huggingface.co/georgesung/llama2_7b_chat_uncensored https://huggingface.co/georgesung/llama2_7b_chat_uncensored https://huggingface.co/SkunkworksAI/BakLLaVA-1 https://huggingface.co/SkunkworksAI/BakLLaVA-1 you'll have to brave 4chan yourself to find links to the NSFW ones, I don't actually have them.
- supposemaybe 3y agoI just can’t brave the venture to 4chan, I may get mugged or worse.
- gryn 3y ago> There's an uncensored model for vision available as well. you mean the LLava based variants ?
- fragmede 3y agohttps://huggingface.co/SkunkworksAI/BakLLaVA-1 https://huggingface.co/SkunkworksAI/BakLLaVA-1
- bambax 3y ago> if you accidentally use the word "hack" [with] ChatGPT... Side note: ChatGPT is now completely useless for most creative tasks. I'm trying to use it, via NovelCrafter, to help flesh out a story where a minor character committed suicide. ChatGPT refuses to respond, mentioning "self harm" as a reason. The character in question killed himself before the story even begins (and for very good reasons, story-wise); it's not like one's asking about ways to commit suicide. This is insane, ridiculous, and different from what all other actors of the industry do, including Claude or Mistral. It seems OpenAI is trying to shoot itself in the foot and doing a pretty good job at it.
- marpstar 3y agoI’ve been frustrated by this, too. Trying to ask for ways to support a close family member who experienced sexual trauma. ChatGPT won’t touch the topic.
- OOPMan 3y ago[flagged]
- serf 3y agoyou wouldn't give out the same sort of advice when a compiler or linker failed to complete a given task, although one certainly could do the work manually. it's just fashionable to hate on AI, /s or not.
- jpc0 3y agoIs it common for you to write the header file to say a BST and the compiler didn't rightfully throw an error? That's what you are asking the LLM to do, you are generating code not searching for an error condition. The parent comment is saying maybe as a writer, writing the actual story isn't such a bad thing... Just a different perspective, live your own life. If the story is good I'll enjoy it, who wrote it is for unions and activists to fight. I've got enough fights to fight.
- bambax 3y ago
- anukin 3y agoWhich uncensored model is willing to play hot or not? I just knew about llava. Are there other such models now?
- Eisenstein 3y agoLlava just integrates Clip with a llama model. Koboldcpp can now do this with many models out of the box: * https://github.com/LostRuins/koboldcpp/releases/tag/v1.61.2 https://github.com/LostRuins/koboldcpp/releases/tag/v1.61.2