7 ms·
Aphantasia and hyperphantasia: exploring imagery vividness extremes
- s_m_t 3y agoI'm still not entirely convinced the spectrum between aphantasia and hyperphantasia truly exists as distinct existential phenomena. I suppose I would self report as someone with hyperphantasia and I strongly suspect I would score highly on the objective correlates but if I really drill down into my mental imagery they seem to be very illusory (even compared to the other things floating around in my mind) and it is very difficult to say definitively that I am really experiencing those images in a fundamentally different way from someone with aphantasia. The objective correlates mentioned in the article to me aren't very convincing and it seems that they could simply point to another confounding factor that changes the way people self report their internal experiences. Of course on the other hand I can't think of any way to build a stronger case for or against so I'm excited for more research into the subject
- FumblingBear 3y agoIn response to your statement that it's difficult to say definitively that you're experiencing those images in a fundamentally different way from someone with aphantasia, I can share my experience as someone on the complete opposite of the spectrum. I do have imagery when I dream, but in my waking hours, I __cannot__ picture things in my head. I can reason about objects based on experiences I have with them (i.e. describe them), but there is no "illusory" reference image. There's just nothing. It's difficult to articulate my method of internal processing, other than saying I have a constant internal monologue that is used to bring to mind whatever it is I'm trying to imagine, but imagery is completely non-existent. Additionally, I've never heard these described as possible symptoms of aphantasia until this article, but "Aphantasia is associated variably with a reduction in both autobiographical memory and face recognition" really resonates with my experience. I don't have many memories from childhood, my adult memories are often vague and more based on feelings that I have of a period in my life rather than concrete details, and I have a difficult time with recognizing actors even if I've seen them in a lot of films. I also have an exceptionally strong musical memory (borderline encyclopedic). I can quickly memorize music and have near perfect recall even when years go by without listening to it. I'm with you in excitement towards further studies of these phenomena, but just wanted to chip in with my personal experiences with aphantasia! Thanks for sharing your thoughts :)
- quantumwoke 3y agoCan you describe your expectation vs reality? What do you think a “normal” person experiences?
- SirRoderic 3y agoMy understanding is that most people remember past events in the context of their own experience of those events — when they remember, they recall into their minds some version of what they felt/saw/heard at the time, re-experienced from their own perspective. I've heard some people describe it like replaying a film, and they may even get a portion of the original emotional or sensory experience with it. I have none of that at all.
- foota 3y agoNo way... really? I think I fall under aphantasia, but I never realized people could potentially relive memories like that.
- Kubuxu 3y agoWelcome in the SDAM (Severely Deficient Autobiographical Memory) club. It is highly correlated with Aphantasia.
- andrelaszlo 3y agoI'm thinking of a happy childhood memory. I'm with my grandmother down by the lake. We're getting into a boat. I can see the way the sunlight reflects on the sand in the shallow water and off the oars in the boat (and what their flaking varnish feels like in my hands). The smell of the reeds, grass, and lake water is very clear to me, as is the voice of my grandmother telling me to be careful to not fall into the water. I can also hear a lawnmower somewhere in the distance, kids splashing around by the beach, and rustling of the reeds as they're caught by the wind. It makes me happy, but also nostalgic. Most of the things from this memory are gone now. I believe the English word that best describes this is "wistful". I know memories are peculiar and that parts of this memory are probably borrowed from other memories, or even made up, but it doesn't make it feel less vivid to me.
- stephen_g 3y agoI’m pretty convinced there is a spectrum just on my own experience - apart from having an internal monologue (which I think is just the ability to imagine speech) I can also imagine sounds, different accents and music almost to the same level of perception as hearing them, to the point where even though I love music, I don’t usually listen to it most of the time (in the car, while working etc.) unless there’s something I really want to listen to, because I am just imagining stuff in my head. Yet I usually can’t imagine imagery very well. I can do it (I wouldn’t say it’s to the point of aphantasia), but it feels more abstract and illusory than my auditory imaging. My experience with auditory imagination is definitely different to most people I have talked to about it, and on the other hand many people seem to be able to visualise images far more vividly than I can. If it were all basically the same, why would one be so massively different to me?
- s_m_t 3y agoSounds to me like you are more trained in one style of thought than another. That doesn't seem so strange to me. Personally I'm not very good with accents or music but I also don't have very much background at all with those things. On the other hand I consciously trained my skills in visualization from a young age.
- kordlessagain 3y agoPeople with Aphantasia don’t see images in mind, typically. The condition is technically that we don’t do willful visualizations and don’t usually see things in mind unless we dream or we are having hypnogogic visuals. That said, some self reported aphants say that they can visualize on psychedelics. Having talked to people about this for almost ten years it’s hard for visualizers to understand what it means to have a lack of what appears to be a common phenomenon.
- thayne 3y ago> and it is very difficult to say definitively that I am really experiencing those images in a fundamentally different way from someone with aphantasia The fact that you experience them at all is different than people with aphantasia. I don't have complete aphantasia, but it is extremely difficult for me to visualize anything or have any mental imagery. And even then, such imagery is very vague, and colorless. Mostly my thoughts are just words. Recently someone asked what kind of tree I think of when I see the word tree. This was a very strange question for me, because I when I read or hear the word tree, I don't have any mental picture of a tree, just an idea of what a tree is.
- phaedrus 3y agoI would self-report as having hyperphantasia, but I also have face blindness. I looked up the vividness of visual imagery questionnaire (VVIQ) test, and the first few questions involved picturing a person - starting with the head and shoulders! Well fuck me. That part in my mind's eye is somewhere between blurry and Picasso. (The features don't hold still.)
- s_m_t 3y agoThis is a complicated topic. To me the ability to hold a coherent (not necessarily still for reasons I won't elaborate on fully to keep this message somewhat short but essentially there is a large kinesthetic component that I suspect a very large percentage of people, myself included, rely on to visualize) 'image' in the minds eye is the measure of hyperphantasia. But 'image' is the wrong word because the 'image' we see in our mind is probably more of a rational reconstruction in our mind spurred by some sort of impression that first formed the memory that the image is reconstructed from. Aristotle wrote about this and more in "On Memory and Reminiscence", I am not correctly conveying the idea. If you could accurately form an image of a realistic face in your mind then barring some sort of motor issue you would I argue by definition be able to draw it on paper by using the image in your mind as a reference (obviously the technical skill of using a pencil to dutifully create lines which entirely match what is attempted might be lacking and it might be a poor picture in a technical sense but I think it would still be recognizable as a realistic face). The difficulty in drawing a realistic face is that you don't actually know what one looks like, or, more accurately, you have the ability to recognize what a realistic face in general should look like (perhaps due to some inbuilt neural circuitry) but you don't have the ability to recall it in all of its detail. Because you can't recall it you can't form that image in your mind. Anyone who can't draw a realistic face doesn't actually know what a realistic face actually looks like, they can only recognize it. I don't think this would be a controversial view among talented artists for instance because many well regarded treatises on the subject of drawing essentially put forward this idea. I guess what I am trying to say is that your ability to visualize a face is probably not much better or worse than your ability to visualize any other object of similar complexity except that you would be much better at recognizing that the face you visualize isn't very accurate. If you weren't able to recognize that it wasn't accurate you wouldn't have critiqued it and if you did you wouldn't have remembered the critique anyways. To close by detracting from everything I have just written: You can also draw a very convincing face by memorizing a complex set of rules that doesn't rely at all on visualizing anything so who is to say that isn't the thing that happens when someone draws a realistic face which puts this whole business of visualization into some doubt
- ajb 3y agoThis is a classic, because Galton wrote "Statistics of Mental Imagery" in 1880, inventing survey research in the process, precisely because he found that the people he talked to about it strongly resisted believing that the spectrum between aphantasia and hyperphantasia truly exists. The original paper is quite readable: https://galton.org/essays/1880-1889/galton-1880-mind-statistics-mental-imagery.pdf https://galton.org/essays/1880-1889/galton-1880-mind-statist...
- s_m_t 3y agoAll this tells me is that people report a wide range of levels of ability pertaining to some skill. You could find similar ranges of abilities in any skill but that doesn't necessarily mean there is anything fundamentally different about the people in that spectrum of ability except insofar as developing that skill has changed them. There could of course be a fundamental difference but I haven't seen anything to convince me of that.
- ajb 3y agoWell, that's a different proposition: I think that if you were to query you'd find that people who experience strong mental imagery have done so as long as they can remember, and don't have the experience of needing to develop it as a skill. It's true that such data isn't in Galton's study; perhaps it's in others, but more simply, we can ask: Anyone reading this who has strong mental imagery (video like): Do you remember ever not having it? consciously or unconsciously, did you ever have to work to develop it?
- ben_w 3y agoDo you have the same level of imagination for all sensory modalities? I don't. I can imagine sounds so intensely that it has on at least one occasion become indistinguishable from real. I can also easily do this overriding of real sensation with imagination, with my sense of which way down is. I can't imagine a smell at all, even though I can recognise them upon experience — if I want to decide which herb or spice to add when cooking, I need to open the container and sample some in order to decide.
- blackoil 3y agoI have some degree of Aphantasia. One of the definitive property for me is that when visualizing an object, it will only have properties explicitly defined. e.g. if visualizing ball on table, the concept is visualized but ball won't have any color until it is defined.
- dr_kiszonka 3y agoI can't visualize colors, outside of dreams, so I'd say our experience is fundamentally different.
- novariation 3y agoAmazing. I have Aphantasia, and I also happen to have a STEM college degree, have no autobiographical memory, and not remember people well. Oh and I also have an autism diagnosis. In my opinion it's quite logical that someone who's not able to visualize things instead uses numbers and logical/mathematical constructs to describe them. It's one way to describe items by their core properties and attributes when image isn't available.
- munchler 3y ago> no autobiographical memory Can you clarify what that means? It seems like that would be an extreme amnesia, but perhaps I'm not understanding.
- SirRoderic 3y agoNot parent, but it sounds like I have a very similar neurotype — I am also autistic, aphantasic (I scored <1st percentile on the spatial-manipulation-in-your-head part of an IQ test at one point!), and have no autobiographical memory. The best way I can explain the latter, at least in my own experience, is that I have no first-person memory of events I've experienced, but I still know the "bullet points" of what happened: the raw facts, if you will. It's like if another person experienced my life on my behalf and gave me a daily summary; I know that a set of events happened, but I feel no personal connection to them and don't recall them in any more detail than e.g. information I've read out of a textbook (often less). I can easily recall other information, not associated with time/place/experience, with higher-than-average accuracy, but accessing personal-history-type memories takes a lot of conscious thought. There seem to be some rare exceptions for memories that are tied to extremely intense emotional or physical experiences, both positive and negative, but even then the memories are fairly weak/fuzzy. This has some funny side effects, for instance, innocuous small-talk questions like "what did you have for dinner yesterday" basically cause me to segfault because recalling information like that (plus the autistic compulsion to answer accurately) requires extreme cognitive effort. I also lack the ability to "miss" people because I have little to no personal memory of what it was like to have them around. In short, it can be socially inconvenient, but doesn't affect daily functioning.
- satokema 3y agoThere is an ex-pro FPS player that has aphantasia (reports no visualizations either intentional or intrusive) and I would really like to see one of these studies talk to him one time. It seems like an interesting extreme case to poke at.
- romanows 3y agoSpatial imagery (map knowledge) is unaffected, so I can't see what effect aphantasia would have here?
- srcreigh 3y agoI believe crosshair placement would be harder to memorize/reflect on. Coaches also often say “see yourself from your opponents POV and be in an unexpected place”. eg royalG valorant guide. That’s just a figure of speech for aphant folks.
- romanows 3y agoI have aphantasia and wasn't seeing how it'd have a particular effect on FPS games, at least the ones I've played. Crosshair placement for things like leading shots? Or more for building a mental map of where the enemy is likely to poke their head up? I would think these things involve spatial imagery/memory. I do remember putting a tiny piece of post-it note on my monitor to act as a red dot sight in Killing Floor, but my guess is that'd help anyone headshot zombies better, not just us aphantasics.
- srcreigh 3y agoCrosshair placement as in positioning your aim at head level when peeking corners or holding an angle. I'm decent at it. Struggle more when there's verticality (im sure everybody does though.) In Valorant, there's often objects to use as guides. But when there's not, I imagine someone with good visual memory could pull up the post-it note of their last fight and reposition off of it. Whereas I'd have to reason my way through it or use muscle memory through lots of practice.
- spxneo 3y agoi definitely have hyperphantasia. as a young lad i used to sit at my desk for hours just day dreaming. it was like being addicted to the movies i created in my head. as a result i never forget a face. in fact one time a person mistook me for somebody else and when it hit him that I wasn't that person but that I recognized him from 15 years ago on a train once astounded him. it gets to the point where i have to constantly pretend to not recognize the person because it freaks them out.
- sandspar 3y agoDo you draw and or paint?
- spxneo 3y agoI do not. But I have been musically inclined in the past. Just wish I had more free days to get back into virtuoso
- hinkley 3y agoOnce upon a time I used to be so good at remembering faces that the first two times I encountered someone who knew me but I didn’t recognize, it freaked me out -for days- afterward. The first time it was someone a year or two behind me in high school who I never recalled interacted with but must have known of me through someone else in school. The second time my first year chem lab partner said hi to me while I was at work. She had gone through a complete makeover. Lost weight, switched to contacts, clothes that actually fit and complemented her, bleached and straightened her hair. It took me half an hour to figure that one out. I am still the guy who can point out the boyfriend in the movie was so and so who hasn’t been in a major dip for twenty years, but in last few years I’ve started to confuse actors with each other, and suspecting family connections between people that have none. Which is both bothering me and giving me some sympathy for old people saying “they all look the same”. Maybe it’s not being racist it’s just having an old brain. I can still pick out voices accurately though. Molly Ringwald was in season 2 of The Bear. After 40 years (yes, 40 years this summer!) she looks completely different from The Breakfast Club, but her voice, while much older now, is exactly the same tempo.
- treme 3y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/CureAphantasia/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CureAphantasia/ founder of this sub (also a dev) claims to have self-cured his aphantasia. documented his process / exercise suggestions. Not sure if anyone successfully cured themselves after his steps but I think they are worth checking out.
- sandspar 3y agoMental visualization discussions very quickly get into woo territory.
- notRobot 3y agoI have partial aphantasia. I went through a few of the mod's posts and surprisingly... they actually make a lot of sense, given the context of how my brain functions. I understand why this is getting downvotes, but I'd like to float the possibility that perhaps the author is on the right track. Would be interested in knowing what other folks with or without aphantasia think. I think this is where you're supposed to start: https://www.reddit.com/r/CureAphantasia/comments/z0clpt/how_to_develop_prophantasic_visualization_part/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CureAphantasia/comments/z0clpt/how_...
- ozim 3y agoIsn’t hyperphantasia just schizophrenia? Is it possible to have hyperphantasia separately?
- dr_kiszonka 3y agoPeople with schizophrenia have involuntary hallucinations and often don't know that the hallucinations are not real. I am curious whether individuals with both schizophrenia and severe aphantasia experience hallucinations.
- BizarroLand 3y agoHyperphantasia is not schizophrenia. There is only a single point of similarity between them. I am not schizophrenic, but if I meditate and hover on the edge of sleep, I can visualize scenery so real that my brain reacts as though I am actually seeing it with my physical eyes. My favorites are a flame floating the the dark, a beautiful red apple rotating in space, and an endless green field of tall grass to run through. I can also intentionally hallucinate audible sounds, but that is less fun and more creepy because every time I do it I immediately follow up with, "My God, I am hearing sounds that don't exist. Am I going crazy?" Either way, both of these things freaked me out, because I went from being in the headspace of wondering if I could do it to actually doing in within minutes. There's a certain sensation that comes along with it for me, very hard to describe, but it's almost like my head is buzzing or my ears pop, and a small wave of euphoria hits as well. After looking into it, apparently, the right kinds of meditation and thoughtful practice can induce realistic hallucinations and simultaneously release DMT, a powerful psychoactive agent that your brain can produce on its own, but is also a substance found in ritual hallucinogens like ayahuasca, and I am already very visually/spatially facile and have excellent sonic memory, so much so that I have figured out the words in a song by replaying it in my mind. Thinking back on it, this is ironic because I had an audio processing disorder as a kid, I could never tell most of the words singers were saying and had difficulty with the letter R. I specifically remember not being able to spell "iron" from being told the word because it is pronounced "i earn" instead of "i ron", and according to my evil grandmother I pronounced "car" in a funny way, but I don't remember this and she was unable to explain to me exactly how I used to mispronounce it or why she thought it was funny.
- foota 3y agoHas anyone that identifies as having aphantasia here been able to improve their ability to visualize imagery?
- FumblingBear 3y agoI've tried various exercises over the years, but to no success. Funnily enough, I'm alright at drawing. I just can't plan things out in advance until I pencil in an outline of a thing. It's a firmly iterative process (not that all art isn't) where I don't tend to have much of an idea of where the art will take me until it's actually drawn.
- dr_kiszonka 3y agoI dabbled in CAD to design an ergonomic keyboard (a hobby). CAD, especially parametric CAD, can be a bit challenging to learn. Even when I was away from the keyboard, I would try to prototype or solve problems in my head. One good thing about CAD is that I could quickly check whether what I visualized was correct or not. I feel it really improved my visualization skills as long as I did it regularly. To generalize, it may be useful to find a hobby that makes you visualize things frequently and allows for a quick feedback loop. (I also tried different games, but didn't derive any benefit from them.)
- foota 3y agoSo... for what it's worth I think I have a fairly good spatial reasoning ability (probably from playing lots of games that involve building things, math, and building things as a kid), but I don't have any imagery that comes with it, it's more like I'm thinking about the relative position of things in my head (e.g., this is to the left of that, which is behind that, etc.,)
- dr_kiszonka 3y agoBelow is a video of a simple CAD project. See if you can do it in your head. I think my spatial reasoning is decent, but I needed to learn how to visualize objects to help me reason about, e.g., what a specific extrusion would result in. If you find it easy, then great! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muq7YUH8tao https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muq7YUH8tao
- mihainov 3y agoI was probably around 23, when I accidentally heard during a podcast that one of the hosts had aphantasia. Then I looked into it, and found that I'm part of the minority. I researched further into it, and it now makes sense why I have difficulty finding directions, reading fiction, remembering faces, remembering events, etc. The problem with aphantasia/hyperpahantasia is that you are born with it, and in your mind things have always worked the same way. Many people might never found out that there are people on the opposite end of the spectrum. I have reached a simple way to test if people have aphantasia. I ask them to imagine a car. Then I ask them what color it was. In my mind there is no car, so the question what color it was makes no sense. People who can imagine things, immediately reply with a color.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smokel 3y agoI don't think this test is adequate. By that standard I would have aphantasia as well. This seems to use the same misguided approach as dream researchers who thought that dreams were in black and white, even though it is trivial to find someone who reports dreaming in or about color. People can perfectly well remember a dream without coloring it in. The simple resolution is: dreams and internal images are not necessarily associated with color. Memories most likely have (or even are) strong associations with other parts of the brain. For some, it is impossible to separate one part from the other. So some people hear sounds when they remember something, some people have visual images, others have emotions, yet others have fear and anxiety, all associated with a trigger or memory. This differs from memory to memory, from person to person, and even over time in the same individual. Yes, there probably are some people with aphantasia, but it is most definitely not the 50% of Hacker News who self-reports it every time this comes up. Edit: anecdotal evidence that may require people who think they have aphantasia to reconsider: I once had a dream about a close friend. When I woke up, I remember seeing the friend in my dream, standing. However, I could not remember from the dream whether I could see my friend's face, or whether I viewed him from the back. Those specific details were simply not filled in at dream-time. My hypothesis is: dreams fire concepts, not actual pixel imagery. Makes perfect sense from a neurological point of view. Same probably goes for internal phantasia.
- inbetween 3y agoFunnily, before the "aphantasia" was a thing, I always thought that "not seeing things in my mind" and instead having just "vague geometrical images" was my superpower and maybe explained why it looks like I could think faster and more effortlessly than many of my peers during college and phd years. I thought maybe my brain didn't spend cycles on pictures and used them elsewhere. That idea was maybe influenced by vaguely recollecting (perhaps wrongly) an Einstein interview where he mentioned also having only vague geometrical images in his mind. When the term "aphantasia" was coined, I was really surprised that people with aphantasia started writing as if it was a handicap they had, as if they were diminished by lacked something that others have. Nowadays, it still trips me up a little to see it described as a 'condition', though I understand it and feel that it is probably a give and take - it is probably an enabler in some domains and a drag in others.
- prismatix 3y agoI, too, never really saw it as a handicap. However, looking back on my education I think I could argue that it was slightly a disadvantage. I constantly got feedback on essays, "show -- don't tell". I remember a unit in school where they made us close our eyes while they told us a story and we had to visualize being in the story. I didn't realize that other kids didn't think the same way as me, so I just remember feeling like these exercises were pointless. In a recent interview, I was collaborating with my interviewer who was visually imagining things in his head and explaining them to me. The interview was going rarher poorly and, once I explained that I didnt have the ability to visualize things and needed to write it down on paper, our conversation shifted and the interview went phenomenally better. Being more open about my aphantasia has actually helped significantly, and I wish I had known about it as a kid.
- 99catmaster 3y agoIs hyperphantasia the same as maladaptive daydreaming or does the former enable the latter?