3 ms·
Can Congress define new “privileges and immunities” under Section 5? I think you might have a federalism problem, insofar as both medical procedures and The def
by rayiner 3y ago
Can Congress define new “privileges and immunities” under Section 5? I think you might have a federalism problem, insofar as both medical procedures and The definition of homicide are traditionally regulated by the states. But if you can get around that, sure.
My point is simply that state governments get to regulate both morality and medical procedures unless some higher law says they can’t. Notions of individual choice and personal autonomy don’t by themselves constrain state power in any way.
- dctoedt 3y ago> I think you might have a federalism problem I don't recall seeing the word federalism in the Constitution. Yeah, there's the Tenth Amendment. But one could make a compelling textualist argument — and perhaps even a historical one — that the Civil War Amendments were explicitly and broadly intended to trump (pardon the expression) the Tenth, and not just concerning the liberation of formerly-enslaved blacks. Then again, some of the SCOTUS conservatives seem to move the goalposts whenever it seems good to them. And in any case, Breyer-style "traditionalism" doesn't seem to be part of their toolkit.