8 ms·
First Council of Nicaea
- losvedir 3y agoI suppose this is relevant on account of it being Easter. Growing up Catholic, we always said the Nicene Creed during Mass, which kind of enumerates the standard Catholic beliefs. I never thought much about it, but a non-Christian friend who joined me one time said thought it was creepy and cult like, us all standing there saying it in unison. I appreciated a universal, orthodox set of beliefs determined to be "correct" by experts, rather than the Wild West of Protestantism where it seemed every church was more unique and centered around its pastor. I was pretty surprised to learn the Council of Nicaea wasn't until a few hundred years after the ostensible start of the church, and remember thinking it was strange how it was all topsy turvy right after the supposed events around Jesus, and went several generations when no one original was still around before it settled down. The history of the early Church is pretty interesting from a political / anthropological perspective.
- tomrod 3y ago[flagged]
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoProtestants still recite the nicean creed assuming they have a high church setting. With modern worship , all bets are off.
- tialaramex 3y agoThe creed recited in both a Catholic and various non-Catholic churches as the "Nicene creed" isn't actually the one agreed at the First Council, there's a Wikipedia page explaining the substantial differences. The creed does explicitly say it's about believing in "one holy catholic and apostolic church" but by that it doesn't mean the Roman Catholic church specifically. It's talking about a hypothetical church (in the sense of a group of Christians, not a building) which is united. Christian Churches which don't claim there's a hypothetical united Christian church in which it just happens they got all the details right and everybody else didn't are outliers. Ecumenical discussions (typically between Roman Catholics and other large Christian sects) tend to carefully avoid trying to figure out who is right, instead trying to find matters on which they can agree. So e.g. exactly what's going on with Transubstantiation? Point of disagreement, best to not mention it. Do people sin? Yes. Is this old church building nice? Yes. Should we get a tax break? Yes. Easy stuff. The Nicene Creed is thus in this easy category.
- mjburgess 3y agoThought the article says the council 'settled' christology, it still took hundreds of years before it was popularly resolved: for, at least, the first 500 years of christianity jesus was widely regarded as something more like a demigod. This fairly clearly what Paul thought; with Luke likely believing just in a messianic role. Early christianity is perhaps best seen as greeking of judaism: god the father is zeus, the angles are demigods, jesus is a half-human offspring of zeus, jesus has been sent to destroy the demonic forces and end the process of death (whereby we're sent to the underworld, etc.). Satan as something more like a peer of God (this indeed, was the original OT role: santan was an angle appointed by god to test people). The whole thing starts to make less-and-less sense the more this greek frame is dropped: if jesus ends up being god himself, and there is no hell, etc. it becomes basically incoherent. Why would god send god to resurrect people which is something god can already do?
- panick21_ 3y agoThere is no clear 'early Christianity'. By the first time we have any evidence, there are already many different interpretations.
- mjburgess 3y agoThen you agree with me. My phrasing is for an audience who is unaware that the gospels already disagree on Christology. I was retrospectively talking about the pauline-johnian views which won and what they were like
- imadierich 3y ago[dead]
- tomrod 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- enw 3y agoYes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Casseres 3y agoSince I can't reply to a dead comment: As long as people are respectful and follow the guidelines, sure. Edit: your other replies are not respectful and seem to violate the guidelines. Edit 2: Anyone can be respectful to anyone else regardless of beliefs. Choosing not to be respectful doesn't say anything about the beliefs, it speaks as to the person being disrespectful. This will be my last edit/reply.
- tomrod 3y ago[flagged]
- pvg 3y agoBoth 'why is this on HN' (right in the site guidelines) and 'let's start a religious flamewar' are things to avoid here. If you don't like the topic, read another post. If you think it doesn't belong on HN, flag it or email hn@ycombinator.com with your concerns.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tomrod 3y ago
- larry_mulgrave 3y ago[flagged]
- tomrod 3y agoHear hear!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- panick21_ 3y agoNot sure why this is on HN. Council of Nicaea is a favorite flashpoint for conspiracy theory people. But in reality it wasn't all that special. It was just one event in many that shaped Christianity. Basically its like a ISO Standards meeting. Lots of old guys making obscure arguments based on interpretations of obscure text about things that essentially don't matter outside of a bunch of nerds. The connection between their arguments and the actual resulting Christian practice is tenuous at best or more likely irrelevant. And all things considered its pretty late in the formation of Christianity of the Church. By 325 the church was pretty unified on the most important things. Its just more famous because we have slightly better documentation for this history. We have almost nothing for the first century. In the second century our records are incredibly spotty and fragmented. It gets a bit better in the 3rd and 4rd century. There is so much interesting 'Christian' history of the early 2 centuries that people are totally unaware off. If you want to see into some of that strange history, you might want to read something like: "Found Christianities: Remaking the World of the Second Century CE"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- seydor 3y agoElon musk tweeted it
- BrandoElFollito 3y ago> Council of Nicaea is a favorite flashpoint for conspiracy theory people Could you please elaborate on that a bit? I do not know much about conspiracy theories, but I am curious why an event so ancient can fuel contemporary conspiracies
- panick21_ 3y agoObviously Christianity is important and thus loved by many but that also means its hated by many. The Council of Nicaea is when 'the state' gets very directly involved with 'the religion'. So if you want to claim some ancient conspiracy exists where state and religion conspire, Council of Nicaea is a nice starting point.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoArianism is easily in my top 3 heterodoxies. (Along with Pelagianism and Lollardism, though the moment Charismatic Catholicism is officially condemned Wycliffe gets bumped to an ignoble 4). Not catholic, just an enjoyer of church history.
- 082349872349872 3y agoThe "pantheism" ascribed to Spinoza (as alluded to by Einstein) is my favourite. (and Dirk Willems my favourite martyr, although I do find it highly apropos that Barbara is the patron saint of the РВСН)
- knightoffaith 3y agoSpinoza was Jewish though.
- 082349872349872 3y ago(a) if my theology be accurate, at least jews, christians, muslims, and mormons all believe they believe in the same god (their differences lying in beliefs as to which prophets had commit bits), so it's not surprising that Rome would have declared their impression of his philosophy an official heresy, eg https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-x/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-x_enc_19070908_pascendi-dominici-gregis.html https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-x/en/encyclicals/documen... (b) although he said he was being misinterpreted, his congregation* also threw him out for what they saw as heresy. * reform is XIX, and haredim are XX, so it's probably safe to say his XVII congregation was orthodox?
- knightoffaith 3y agoWell, I just meant that Spinoza was a Jewish heretic, not a Christian heretic (at least, no more than say, Mohammad), since the discussion was about Christian heresies specifically. The encyclical only discusses pantheism rather than Spinoza---I don't know that pantheism is specifically Spinoza's invention. Of course, no doubt that Spinoza wouldn't be considered a conforming Christian by any Christian church, but not just because he wrote "Deus sive Natura" (the extent to which Spinoza's thought on the relationship between God and creation is incompatible with classical theism is up for debate, it seems to me. See the interesting comments by /u/wokeupabug here - https://old.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/nar433/how_did_spinozas_ideas_about_god_challenge_the/ https://old.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/nar433/how_d...).
- 48864w6ui 3y agoFrom the article it sounds like it all went down differently, but I had originally thought, as someone who's served on standards committees, that Easter as a mobile feast would be an excellent compromise position if there were multiple fixed candidates, for one could then guarantee celebration would coincide with each faction's proposal infinitely often (with only a finite number of non coincidences in between). (For all f, always eventually Easter sub f?)