3 ms·
I’m guessing because silicon is longer lasting? Essentially forever except for mechanical weathering. Diatomaceous earth, for example. Asbestos for another. St
by lazide 3y ago
I’m guessing because silicon is longer lasting? Essentially forever except for mechanical weathering. Diatomaceous earth, for example. Asbestos for another.
Steel and even copper degrade much quicker.
- ben_w 3y agoDiatomaceous earth and asbestos are categorised as silicates, which is the oxide of silicon rather than the pure metal. Metallic silicon is different from silicon oxide in the way that water is different from hydrogen gas or that charcoal is different from carbon dioxide… or that steel is different from rust and copper different from verdigris. Also notable: some of the common forms of asbestos have almost as many iron atoms as silicon in the chemical formula, and all the ones I looked at have far more oxygen.
- lazide 3y agoGood points! I guess the big question would be if the oxidized form (the silicon oxide structure) would be safer (similar to rust) or dangerous. At least silicosis shouldn’t be a real risk at the quantity used I would hope?
- ben_w 3y agoThe safety of whatever it decays into is a concern I'd share, and is worth investigating. On the plus side, as a surface treatment there's less material in total vs. the use of asbestos as fireproofing.
- lazide 3y agoTrue, though if nanoscale form on surfaces we care about having bacteria on (probably due to being surface contact?) it would be high risk of breaking off and becoming airborne. Fire protection tiles and the like seem like lower risk, though older uses like fire protection fabric and general floor tiles are of course a huge problem. My understanding of why asbestos is so dangerous is due to the length of the fibers exceeding the ability of macrophages to fully engulf them, and their chemical inertness. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7082251/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7082251/] They’re essentially unclearable, long lasting, anti-cellular weapons. Just like what is being proposed for this new material.
- thsksbd 3y agoBut metalic Si will quickly grow a layer of passivating SiO2 whose lattice constant just happens to match Si's ensuring it doesn't flake off. Either way metallic Si is, essentially, a forever "chemical"
- ben_w 3y ago> metalic Si will quickly grow a layer of passivating SiO2 whose lattice constant just happens to match Si's ensuring it doesn't flake off This sounds like the exact opposite of a problem. > Either way metallic Si is, essentially, a forever "chemical" Silicon dioxide: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Beach_at_Fort_Lauderdale.jpg#mw-jump-to-license https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Beach_at_Fort_Laud... Iron oxide: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hull%E2%80%93Rust%E2%80%93Mahoning_Open_Pit_Iron_Mine.jpg#mw-jump-to-license https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hull%E2%80%93Rust%...
- adrian_b 3y agoEven an extremely thin layer of SiO2 is impenetrable for oxygen, so the rest of the elemental silicon is not oxidized any more, exactly like aluminum, titanium or stainless steel. All these 4 common materials can persist in the environment essentially forever, despite the fact that their base material would react easily with oxygen, even burning in certain conditions.
- ben_w 3y agoI don't know how I can be more clear about how much this sounds like the exact opposite of a problem, about how this completely fails to elucidate why silicon is being singled out and demonised — especially as you're now putting steel (which one of the things the other commenter was preferring) into the same bucket as silicon.
- thsksbd 3y agoOP here. Believe it or not, Im aware what rust and sand are made of. Iron oxide is an essential nutrient your body craves and has billions of years of evolution to process. Sand has no biological use and is completely inaccessible to biological systems. While chemically inert, it is chemically active through its ability to provide a surface for catalysis and biologically active by being able to cut bio membranes. Furthermore, nanoscale "ceramics" (is SiO2 a ceramic? I think so) are far more catalytically active than their bulk counterpart due to the sharp vertices and edges. Nano scale rods of SiO2 is not sand. It only shares chemical formula, which is a sophomoric understanding of chemistry. Anyway steel and SiO2 are not even close to the same category in terms of chemical resistance. For starters the person you replied to said stainless steel, not steel which corrodes like crazy. But even if it were stainless steel, stainless steel isn't stainless and will corrode. Especially at the nanoscale. By comparison SiO2 will never degrade. AFAIK only HF attacks SiO2, and I know of no biological systems that use F. "Si is not SiO2!" you protest. So? SiO2's lattice habit and constant matches Si's almost exactly. This means that SiO2 will adhere to Si very well protecting it. Since O is everywhere, SiO2 will form. Since the material we're talking about here is a nanoscale and narrow aspect ratio, it's likely to fully oxide the Si turning this into nanoscale asbestos. This despite the reduced diffusion from the low T since: - there isn't much length to diffuse at the nanoscale - narrow, nanoscale structures have different bond, surface and volume energetics which favor passivation rxn by the O. In short, these researchers have to prove this isn't going to stay forever in the environment piercing bio membranes until evolution incorporates HF into our gene pool. Btw, I propose novel ways to make nanoscale thermite for a living. Im hardly an innocent party.
- XorNot 3y agoDiatomaceous earth is made out silicates, not crystalline silicon, which is what this is made out of.