3 ms·
> You're not talking about forests, you're talking about tree farms. I think this is the main issue here. They redefined "tree farms" as "forests" a long time
by hulitu 3y ago
> You're not talking about forests, you're talking about tree farms.
I think this is the main issue here. They redefined "tree farms" as "forests" a long time ago, so they can put an equal sign between them.
A forest is an ecosystem. A tree farm is not.
You cannot regrow a forest.
- Jensson 3y agoYou can grow a forest, you just do that in a different way than you grow a tree farm. And there isn't a lack of insects and other things to move in once you laid down the foundation for that ecosystem, they are still everywhere in Europe.
- skeeter2020 3y agoIn much of Canada the line is a little blurry. You can usually tell when you're in a replanted block but it could be 50 or more years since they cut it, and it doesn't look like an orchard or christmas tree farm. It really depends where in the country you are; secondary growth in BC can seem far more natural than untouched Northern Saskatchewan, for example.
- seadan83 3y agoTree farm is basically a solid brick of brown matter with some bushes on the top. The trees are sick, light starved, growing too closely together, and generally a mess. The things that live in tree farms are not nice, rats, it's too thick for anything bigger. This type of environment does not support a food chain. Overall, the trees grow like a group of sickly cotton swabs. Now that I recognize tree farms, I no longer feel quite as bad when I see then clear-cut. They were sick trees that were destined to be cut down.
- seadan83 3y agoFound the pictures, compare the tree farm to the red wood forest: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/07/the-wrong-kind-of-trees-irelands-afforestation-meets-resistance https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/07/the-wrong-kind... (all the trees you see in the guardian article are tree-farm trees, not just the ones that are clear-cut) https://www.savetheredwoods.org/wp-content/uploads/cr-understory-7001.jpg https://www.savetheredwoods.org/wp-content/uploads/cr-unders... The clear-cut gives a nice cross view into the trees. It's a mess in there.. not much green. It's pretty clear the total available surface area in a natural forest is larger. The forest/nature/plants all optimize themselves to have as much surface area as possible. Loggers optimize for the greatest number of tree trunks and fewest number branches.