7 ms·
Senator proposes 30% anti-Eduardo-Saverin tax
- sp332 15y ago"Tax avoidance"? He doesn't even live here anymore. Remind me again why he's paying any taxes?
- ahelwer 15y agoThe U.S. has a citizenship-based taxation system, so citizens must pay taxes regardless of residence. The U.S. shares this policy with exactly one other country in the world, Eritrea. You can critique this policy (and many do), but this new Schumer proposal is an extension of it, not a change in direction.
- recursive 15y agoWe're not talking about citizens paying taxes. We're talking about ex-citizens. I seem to recall hearing something about "no taxation without representation" somewhere before.
- sp332 15y agoWell I don't think that resigning your citizenship means that you don't have to pay any taxes for that year. And if he didn't pay any taxes on the stocks he owns, that would be a much larger dodge of >$600 million. So people who have left the country within the last year still have to pay taxes on their earnings.
- roc 15y agoWasn't he a US citizen when he sued in US court for proper recognition and partial ownership? It seems only fair to pay American tax on the fruit of that windfall. How far would his case against Zuckerberg have gone if he'd filed it in Singapore?
- sp332 15y agoHe's already paying the 15% capital gains tax on the stock that he owns, which comes to about $500MM. The $170MM must be referring to something else.
- beagle3 15y agoYou can file in a US court even if you are not a US citizen, you know -- it's not like US people are given a carte blanche to cheat other nations.
- onetwothreefour 15y agoDude, you wouldn't want to bring logic and facts into this debate, let alone questioning THE GREATEST NATION ON EARTH. :) What the hell happened to HN?
- roc 15y agoI'll be the first to admit that I don't know how jurisdiction would work in a case like that. But it seems to me that paying taxes on money recovered for you by a legal system is a fair price for the service. If the legal system was corrupt or inefficient, he'd never have gotten his money. It only seems fair to pay to support it. Particularly given the fairly low tax rate. There are precious few places and ways you can earn hundreds of millions of dollars and only pay 15% on them. That said, it sounds like he has paid tax once and is possibly trying to avoid paying tax on the appreciation of that property, which I will also admit muddies the waters quite a bit.
- beagle3 15y ago> But it seems to me that paying taxes on money recovered for you by a legal system is a fair price for the service. Basically, you can use the US court system even if you never once set foot in the US, and never had a US passport - as long as the party you are suing is bound by US law. Theoretically, the outcome should be the same. I'm not sure what the tax consequences are, but in general, if you get a remedy from the court, the tax is the same as the original transaction (possibly none).
- jonknee 15y agoHe doesn't live here and isn't a citizen. The number of non-native, former citizens who end up to be instant billionaires has to be a very small group (likely a party of 1)... To make any law that addresses it is inane.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoOf course it is, but it plays well with the 'tax the rich' folks. Schumer isn't really proposing legitimate legislation, he's campaigning for votes. One technique he uses is to propose legislation that can't pass the full senate, much less the whole process of getting into law, so that the big headlines like these will get folks who want to 'stick it to the rich' to vote for him. Sadly, this is an effective technique. A number of California state representatives use it as well.
- jlcx 15y agoMy interpretation of that would be that if we already have one of the world's harshest tax policies in that regard, why would we want to have a reputation for being even worse? Do we want to make productive foreigners even more wary of acquiring US citizenship?
- to3m 15y agoYES SIR WEE DO,,, THEIR STEELING ARE JOBBS
- sethg 15y agoBefore Eduardo Savarin was a US citizen, he wasn’t a productive foreigner; he was a teenager who had been targeted for kidnapping in his native Brazil. (http://pandodaily.com/2012/05/12/what-eduardo-saverin-owes-america-hint-nearly-everything/ http://pandodaily.com/2012/05/12/what-eduardo-saverin-owes-a...) His father was a wealthy businessman (which is why Eduardo had been kidnap-worthy), but I don’t know if he was wealthy enough to qualify for immigration to Singapore.
- cafard 15y agoHow about a 5% anti-Chuck-Schumer tax, whereby any elected representative would be charged a 5% higher marginal rate if it could be shown that he had been proposing bills for show rather than for use.
- eli 15y agoThe most dangerous place in Washington is between Chuck Schumer and a camera. (I got that joke from one of his Hill staffers.) But yeah, this seems like something that is both extremely rare and Not A Problem.
- hkmurakami 15y agoExpatriating upon IPO may be somewhat uncommon, but renouncing citizenship for various money-saving reasons is more common than we may expect. One prominent example would be George Soros, similarly moving to Singapore a few years ago. (I believe his excuse was that Asia will be the center of the world in the future, and he wanted his children to be educated there, or something along those lines). As Federal Income Tax, Capital Gains Tax, and Qualified Dividend Taxes increase, we will most likely see more of these flight-from-tax acts, not fewer.
- eugenejen 15y agoNo, Your example is wrong factually. It is not George Soros, but his cofounder in original Quantum Fund, Jim Rogers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Rogers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Rogers. We need to do fact checking before we write down anything. George Soros is alive and kicking living in Upper East Side, Manhattan; Bedford, Westchester county; and East Hampton, Suffolk county. If you are lucky you can bump into him very often in Bloomberg Headquarter. And George Soros is also a proponent for Buffett Rules.
- hkmurakami 15y agoApologies, I stand corrected. (I'm actually rather embarrassed to have made this mistake)
- DanBC 15y agoMuch more troublesome, to me, are companies that operate in some country (with staff and buildings) but which are registered in some other tax haven, thus avoiding the need to pay taxes. While legal it's sleazy.
- toyg 15y agoAnd that's where the real money is, so you'll never hear anyone proposing bills to address that. Enforcing decency is left to understaffed and underfunded national collection agencies. Repeat after me: the problem is not personal income tax, but rather corporate tax, especially when abused to mask personal income.
- raverbashing 15y agoYeah Because Eduardo is not paying any exit tax based on capital gains he would have by selling his stock at the moment. Oh wait he is! "Oh but the value of the stock may increase!" Yes, but it can also decrease.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoHe'll get a refund if it decreases. I'm sure of it.
- beagle3 15y agoDo you have any basis for being so sure? I know of tens of people who owed capital gain taxes on IPO shares they couldn't even sell (due to SEC rule 144, look it up), the shares tanked, and they were still on the hook for taxes even though their best realizable profit ended up less than what they owed in taxes. Yes, the US tax system is f*cked up in multiple ways. I'm not aware of any other country in which you can strike gold in an IPO as a founder, investor, or employee, and -- due to a market event outside of your control -- face a tax bill strictly larger than you could ever have legally derived. (again, look up SEC rule 144) No, this is not fiction - I was luckily saved from such a fate by virtue of the "exit" event (an acquisition) happening before July; had it happened a few days later (July 1st or later), I would have lost money on an investment with a nice 3x-8x return (depending on how you measure). In the end, I didn't lose money, but hardly profited. I know others who weren't so lucky, and if you (or someone you know) were in the tech scene/bubble in San Francisco in 2000-2001, you probably do too.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoI was making a joke that probably was not as obvious as it could have been. :-)
- beagle3 15y agoyour <sarcasm> tags were missing ....
- vibrunazo 15y agoIsn't he renouncing US citizenship because Singapore doesn't allow dual citizenship? Was keeping US citizenship while living there even an option for him?
- mhartl 15y agoThat's not why. You can live in Singapore as a permanent resident for the price of starting a corporation ($150), which then simply hires you as an employee. Or you can have $20m and qualify for an investor exception—for which I'm pretty sure Saverin qualifies. (Note: The above numbers are from memory and may not be exact, but they're in the right ballpark.)
- hazov 15y agoHe still is a Brazilian citizen[1], non-resident Brazilians don't pay any income tax as far as I know. [1]: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-05-12/facebook-co-founder-may-gain-choosing-singapore-over-u-s-.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-05-12/facebook-co-founder... EDIT: added "tax".
- rbn 15y agoHe was born in Brazil and has Brazilian citizenship. So that's not the case
- patrickgzill 15y agoBe interesting to go through Chuckie's list of Top 100 corporate donors and figure out which ones are using "Double Irish" and similar schemes to avoid taxes. Maybe he should refuse money from such companies? (will not happen of course!)
- debacle 15y agoIf someone renounces citizenship, the loss of freedom in the nation they were once a citizen of should be loss enough.
- snorkel 15y agoToday's bandaid to a small problem is tomorrow's income tax nightmare. See AMT tax.
- mhartl 15y agoThe tax revenues we're talking about here are roundoff errors to USG. This is just pure spite.
- crazygringo 15y agoThe three most important points to me: 1) Saverin doesn't live here any more. So why does Schumer care?? The guy already paid his exit taxes. 2) Saverin was never even originally a US citizen in the first place -- he's Brazilian. 3) "enforcing Schumer’s proposal might run up against the “perpetual problem of trying to figure out what’s in a person’s mind” when he or she give up U.S. citizenship." This is key -- using motivation to determine the punishment for a crime seems OK (i.e. degrees of murder). But using motivation to determine whether or not something is a crime, just feels ridiculous.
- Kuiper 15y ago"But using motivation to determine whether or not something is a crime, just feels ridiculous." But there are crimes that are determined by intent. For example, providing incorrect information is not inherently criminal, but knowingly providing incorrect information with the intent of personal gain is considered fraud, which is a crime.
- rsanchez1 15y agoPoint 3 is the most dangerous. The language you chose is telling, "crime". Schumer seems to want to use Saverin's motivation to determine that giving up citizenship to avoid paying taxes is a crime. Besides it being unconstitutional to legislate against a specific person, what kind of message is Schumer sending? Once you venture into the maw that is the United States tax code, you can't leave without heavy personal losses? That sends the message that your business is not welcome here at best, and is draconian at worse, setting a dangerous precedent for even more oppressive legislation later. But in an era of occupy, Schumer can use all the class warfare arguments he wants to get his proposed legislation passed easily. People will foam at the mouth in anger against this millionaire not paying his fair share, and they'll be completely oblivious of government infringing on civil rights until it's their own civil rights that are taken away, and by then it will be too late to do anything about it.
- joelrunyon 15y ago“It always bothers me when somebody renounces his citizenship in the greatest country on Earth just to save money, save taxes,” Hatch said in an interview. “I was really upset at Eduardo Saverin for doing that, and there are others who are doing it too.” And, he added, “they’re going to rue the day that they did that.” 1) He talks about Eduardo like he knows him - really? Is there any way for him to know why Eduardo really did this (maybe he actually does like Signapore more than the USA). 2) He acts like he personally just got ripped off by Eduardo - I'm not sure laws are best created out of spite. 3) The arrogance that people outside the US have a terrible quality of life is incredibly disconcerting. It leads to a sort of insulated security that comes from telling ourselves we're so great and maintaing the status quo because it's easier instead of looking at other countries that are legitimately competing with us, learning from them and improving.
- rprasad 15y agoIt's not a matter of spite--it's the fact that Eduardo's primary claim to life and wealth is due to America: coming to America saved Eduardo's life as a youth after he became the target of Brazilian kidnappers, getting an American education led to the opportunity to be Facebook's angel investor, and the American justice system is the sole reason that Eduardo has any claim to Facebook stock today. Note: I am not opining in this comment whether Eduardo should be taxed more than he already has been or already will be, I am merely stating the prevailing justification expressed for why people think he's a freeloader.
- pan69 15y agoSo, you're saying; Saverin owes us. Is that correct?
- rprasad 15y agoI'm saying he owed us in both the legal and moral sense. I do not know whether (or if so, when) Eduardo has paid taxes on his Facebook shares, so I cannot opine on whether he still owes us under the laws currently in effect. Morally...I think he's a freeloading bastard, and I look forward to the day he goes to jail in Singapore for violating one of their numerous and extremely punitive criminal laws. But I do not think he has a moral obligation to pay additional taxes if he has satisfied his legal obligations.
- orbitingpluto 15y agoUN Declaration of Human Rights Article 13. (1) Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each state. (2) Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country. Article 15. (1) Everyone has the right to a nationality. (2) No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his nationality nor denied the right to change his nationality.
- Hyena 15y agoWell... there's also a right to asylum (14), group rights for families, to some form of social maintenance (22), limitation of working hours and minimum wage (24), full and free education (26), to copyright (27). Lastly there are vague duties to your "community" and it has power to determine what justly fulfills a grab-bag of ethical and legal concepts (29). So... Not the best document in the world to quote on this front.
- orbitingpluto 15y agoYes and article 16 doesn't explicitly give the rights for same sex marriage. Viewing the UNDHR as anything more than what should be minimally aspired to strikes me as... well... evil.
- Turing_Machine 15y agoWow, a modern-day Bill of Attainder/ex post facto law. Someone should acquaint Schumer with Article I, Section 9 of the Constitution of the United States.
- Turing_Machine 15y agoThat said, I'm okay with not allowing people who renounce their citizenship back in to the country.
- rprasad 15y agoLol. I just realized why people aren't understanding my other comments about why this debate matters. Here's an explanation: Capital gains on the sale of capital assets (i.e., stock) by foreign persons are not taxable by the U.S. Only certain types of capital investment (i.e., real property or income that is connected to a U.S. business activity) is taxable by the US. See generally Section 871 and its accompanying regulations. Capital gains by foreign persons are generally taxed by the foreign person's country of residence unless the foreign person has a tax nexus to the U.S. Generally, the tax nexus is provided by citizenship, actual residence, or deemed residence. Id. Eduardo is not an actual or deemed resident of the U.S., thus his only tax nexus was via his citizenship. By renouncing his citizenship, he severs that last bit of tax nexus. Consequently, the sale of the Facebook stock is now taxable only by the foreign jursidiction in which he is a citizen/resident. In this case, Singapore does not impose a capital gains tax, so he would effectively not be subject to any tax at all on the sale of his Facebook stock. This matters because Singapore is one of the few non-tax haven jurisdictions that provides for no capital gain taxation. It's also unusual that he did so around the same time that Facebook began publicly indicating it would move toward an IPO, despite Eduardo having been eligible for Singaporean citizenship for some time before he actually renounced his U.S. citzenship. Note also that Eduardo "resides" in Singapore but spends significant amounts of time outside of the country. This is why so many people (including myself) think Eduardo renounced his citizenship to avoid paying taxes. It's the circumstances surrounding his renunciation which are suspicious. If he'd chosen to move to Europe, or China, or Hong Kong, or some other place, it wouldn't be an issue. But based on the totality of the circumstances, it looks like tax avoidance was his primary motive. Hope this helps.
- beagle3 15y ago> In this case, Singapore does not impose a capital gains tax, so he would effectively not be subject to any tax at all on the sale of his Facebook stock. This is blatantly wrong. The US, since 2008, has an exit tax. For the purposes of US taxation, what happens is that on the day that he loses his US citizenship, US-Eduardo sells all his things to Singapore-Eduardo at fair market price. Thus, he pays capital gain taxes up until that day. After that day, it is up to the new jurisdiction: Singapore won't tax him for any further gains, most other countries would. Either way, if facebook goes down between the day he loses citizenship and the day he actually sells, he has lost money. He's saved some taxes already, but that's a result of a bet. Another way to make the same bet would have been to buy a call option (or sell a put option, or go long a forward or future) on Facebook stock. Schumer is just looking for votes and publicity. And the media are happy to distort the story to make villains and heros, because they sell more ads that way.