3 ms·
The big problem with precise weather simulations is that we don't have the sensors in 3D. They are all pretty much sitting on the surface, apart from some weath
by bufferoverflow 3y ago
The big problem with precise weather simulations is that we don't have the sensors in 3D. They are all pretty much sitting on the surface, apart from some weather balloons. So we don't have precise data for wind, temperature, pressure apart from the surface. And all of these factors change A LOT with altitude.
- akie 3y agoWe have weather satellites observing everything from above though. Combined with the ground based sensors we have a pretty decent clue.
- tempaccount420 3y agoYeah, this seems like the perfect problem for AI to solve. Combine different data and find hidden relations.
- bufferoverflow 3y agoWrong. Satellites only look at the surface and maybe clouds when available. We have almost no data from above the surface. Very few weather balloons.
- woopsn 3y agoNo, over a million meteorological observations are collected each day by commercial airplanes, and these are a principle source of data for weather models. Weather balloons and other sounding instruments (satellites are capable of this) also make significant contributions, of course. It's been proven for decades, the big problem with weather simulation is that the dynamics are chaotic. They continue to be, even as we collect more data from the surface and above. Our forecasts improve, slowly (by a day per decade or so, historically), but simulation cannot be accurate and precise in the same sense. A good introduction is "Weather Prediction: What everyone needs to know"
- Semionilo 3y agoAre you stating this because you are a weather researcher or because you think that? Because we do have weather balloons and weather satellites and weather stations in variant heights and situations.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoBut at a ridiculously sparse density. At anything above 10km, it’s not even 1 data source per hundred thousand square km of area at any given time. Countries the size of Poland go without for at least a decent chunk of the 8760 hours in a year.
- bufferoverflow 3y agoSatellites only look at the surface (and maybe clouds). Weather balloons are extremely sparce.
- blovescoffee 3y agoI see this pretty often here unfortunately. Very confidently wrong statements from people who aren’t actual experts. For historical reasons there’s a sort of guise of expert on HN that can be abused.
- sharts 3y agoThis is how the tech nerds operate. Read a wikipedia paragraph, and become expert.
- feitingen 3y agoThe Aeolus mission: https://earth.esa.int/eogateway/missions/aeolus https://earth.esa.int/eogateway/missions/aeolus > The Aeolus mission objectives were to provide accurate global measurements of winds from the surface up to 30 km