3 ms·
You’re confusing state governments with the federal government. State governments are not governments of enumerated powers. They inherited the plenary authority
by rayiner 3y ago
You’re confusing state governments with the federal government. State governments are not governments of enumerated powers. They inherited the plenary authority of the British parliament, and have general police powers to regulate the health, welfare, and morals of citizens. That includes regulating medical procedures and defining various types of homicide. They could make laws banning eating meat on odd numbered days.
Those powers are only limited if there’s a state or federal constitutional right that prohibits that exercise of general police powers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 3y agoSo the people have the right -- the incorporated right -- to be secure in their persons and papers, but not their uteruses. Got it.
- rayiner 3y agoYou should try quoting the whole thing: > The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. Yes, the government can’t conduct warrantless searches of any part of your body. It takes either very poor reading comprehension or affirmative bad faith to pretend that has anything to do with the government regulating medical procedures, or defining the parameters of homicide.
- CamperBob2 3y agoOne of several drawbacks to having something "seized" is that you lose control over it. So if (as you say) I don't control my own uterus, which certainly falls under the domain of my "person" under 4A law, and if the government can't assert control over its contents without a warrant, also according to 4A, then who does control it?
- tptacek 3y agoYou don't believe the argument you've made here, and have spent years making the opposite argument vis a vis incorporation. If you were right, I'd get to take your guns away.
- rayiner 3y agoI pretty sure I’ve never said that state governments have any inherent limits to their police powers. I think banning guns undoubtedly is within the states’ police powers. So is banning adultery, or gambling, or eating dinner after 8 pm. But as I said above: “Those powers are only limited if there’s a state or federal constitutional right that prohibits that exercise of general police powers.” Vis-a-vis the comment I was responding to above, if I want to say the government can’t take my guns, I have to affirmatively point to somewhere in the federal constitution or the state constitution that says that. (Luckily for me there’s a whole amendment about guns; guns don’t even have to share an amendment with other rights, like free speech which has a bunch of roommates in the first amendment.) I also agree that if incorporation didn’t exist, states could ban guns notwithstanding the second amendment. And incorporation may well not exist, but that’s an argument for a different day.
- dctoedt 3y ago> State governments are not governments of enumerated powers. They inherited the plenary authority of the British parliament, and have general police powers to regulate the health, welfare, and morals of citizens. How fortunate then that we have the 14th Amendment to prevent state governments from "abridg[ing] the privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States" — which textualists and originalists presumably would say can be authoritatively defined by the Congress using its enforcement power under section 5 of 14A. So if the Dems retake the House and keep the Senate in 2024, then we can expect federal legislation reinstating women's Roe rights as "privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States," no matter what the Taliban wing of "Christianity" in Texas, Missouri, etc., might prefer.
- rayiner 3y agoCan Congress define new “privileges and immunities” under Section 5? I think you might have a federalism problem, insofar as both medical procedures and The definition of homicide are traditionally regulated by the states. But if you can get around that, sure. My point is simply that state governments get to regulate both morality and medical procedures unless some higher law says they can’t. Notions of individual choice and personal autonomy don’t by themselves constrain state power in any way.
- dctoedt 3y ago> I think you might have a federalism problem I don't recall seeing the word federalism in the Constitution. Yeah, there's the Tenth Amendment. But one could make a compelling textualist argument — and perhaps even a historical one — that the Civil War Amendments were explicitly and broadly intended to trump (pardon the expression) the Tenth, and not just concerning the liberation of formerly-enslaved blacks. Then again, some of the SCOTUS conservatives seem to move the goalposts whenever it seems good to them. And in any case, Breyer-style "traditionalism" doesn't seem to be part of their toolkit.