4 ms·
> the constant refrain that LLM hallucinations are precisely equivalent to common human behavior You sure it's "precisely" and not "analogously"? Ironically,
by ben_w 3y ago
> the constant refrain that LLM hallucinations are precisely equivalent to common human behavior
You sure it's "precisely" and not "analogously"?
Ironically, one common human failing is to use binary classification.
> or had severe mental deficiency
It seems I have worked with more human idiots than you. And at least one time where I was the idiot, despite literally scoring "off the charts" on a cognitive abilities test at school.
I'd agree that LLMs are not as smart as humans — they had to read 10% of the internet just to be as competent as an intern — but to me they're more like newspapers and the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect than "severely deficient", even when indeed unacceptable.
- daveguy 3y ago> It seems I have worked with more human idiots than you. This is completely unnecessary.
- ben_w 3y agoThat sounds like you think I'm calling @krapp a member of the set "idiots"; I'm not — ironic that at least one of the two of us is misunderstanding the other, given the question of LLMs not understanding things — rather I'm saying there are many temporarily-idiotic in the world (myself included :P) and I have worked with enough of them to not dismiss the mistakes that LLMs make as a dramatic departure from this.
- daveguy 3y agoAh, you're right. I misread your intent.