2 ms·
It is really shocking that X has been on life support for like a decade, but it is still necessary to write essays to try and convince people to switch away fro
by bee_rider 3y ago
It is really shocking that X has been on life support for like a decade, but it is still necessary to write essays to try and convince people to switch away from it.
Maybe it is just a really good design.
I like i3, so I can switch to Sway easily, there’s just no reason to.
- orthecreedence 3y agoThe ONLY reason I switched from i3 -> Sway is because I'm using monitors with different resolutions and dealing with dual monitor setups in X approaches impossible. Sway is mostly OK but i3 and all the supporting X stuff I had was incredibly solid and all just worked together. Enter Sway/Wayland, and some things are in XWayland some things are native so they can't talk to each other, there are constant display bugs, Waybar is glitchy, screen sharing is a nightmare, fullscreen mode doesn't work for floating windows, fullscreen windows aren't transparent and show black instead of my background photo (because "security"). I just kind of hate it. I recently updated Sway and my dropdown terminal no longer focused when I opened it...I'd have to click to focus. I ended up reverting. It's probably some perfect storm of lagging support from apps, bugs in Sway, bad AMD drivers, and a protocol that's, sure, more "correct" but kind of gimps the overall experience. If you're happy on X, stay on X. It all worked fine before my laptop died and I got a new one with a different resolution than my monitor. I will say though...multi-monitor support in Sway/Wayland, with scaling and all that, is excellent.
- pjmlp 3y agoNot really, it is a design for 1990's UNIX hardware, it is only kept alive thanks to the endless extensions developed for GNU/Linux and BSDs, mostly on x86 graphics hardware.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoGNU/Linux and the BSDs are also designed for 1990s hardware except for all the extensions; how far do you want to take that argument?
- pjmlp 3y agoOopsie a sore point. There is a reason why they basically only dominate in traditional UNIX headless workloads and nothing else. After successfully cloning Bell Labs UNIX, that was it. Hardly anything new on the Desktop space, that isn't being rebuilt or forked every couple of years.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> There is a reason why they basically only dominate in traditional UNIX headless workloads and nothing else. Well then it's a non-issue; neither X11 nor Wayland are needed for that. > After successfully cloning Bell Labs UNIX, that was it. Hardly anything new on the Desktop space, that isn't being rebuilt or forked every couple of years. So... it it nothing new, or is it constant change? Because those seem contradictory.
- pjmlp 3y agoNothing new, because GNU/Linux is a follower from what proprietary OSes do in the GUI space, hardly doing any innovation, and even copy cat of those proprietary OSes approaches isn't good enough, gets rebuild and forked every couple of years. While the proprietary OSes do rebuild their stacks, there is an amount of tooling put in place to ease those transitions. So yeah, in the end it is all about UNIX servers, which aren't even a thing on container and serverless workloads, or headless POSIX compatibility on some IoT device, if they aren't using other FOSS OS like Zephyr/FreeRTOS/NutXX/Tock/mBed, both cases with a WebUI as management interface and that will be it.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> Nothing new, because GNU/Linux is a follower from what proprietary OSes do in the GUI space, hardly doing any innovation, and even copy cat of those proprietary OSes approaches isn't good enough, gets rebuild and forked every couple of years. That's not actually true, but more to the point, the proprietary OSs are also from the 90s and just keep extending themselves.