9 ms·
Nine writers on their Adderall use and experiences
- rsstack 3y agoWhat's amazing, to me, about Adderall is how much of a magic solution it is to some people who have real ADD (and not self-diagnosed similar symptoms). My girlfriend didn't get diagnosed until the age of 30 but clearly has ADD. I assumed she knew when we met each other, my therapist "diagnosed" her from my stories, and yet one day she asked me "Do you think I have ADD?" and I answered "I assumed you knew.". She then got diagnosed and started taking Adderall once a day on week days. It totally changed the way she's able to complete uninteresting work. She no longer works until 2-3am and is able to end her day while the sun is still up. Total game changer, and no negative side effects for her. I know many people abuse it, and maybe people suffer from side effects, but as a medication it truly has a reason to be prescribed (by doctors).
- 2four2 3y agoCompletely agreed. It was a miracle for me. I felt like I was significantly less irritating and could concentrate on normal tasks. It's important to talk about Adderall abuse, but at the same time, acknowledge its benefit for those who need it. It's such an embarrassing drug to admit to taking because it has so much stigma connected to it. I usually avoid talking about it because people's reactions can get very judgemental and uncomfortable.
- p1esk 3y agoI’ve never heard any stigma attached to adderall.
- krispyfi 3y agoAdderall is a brand name of amphetamine / "speed". Enantiomers and purity notwithstanding, it's the same substance whether you acquire it from a pharmacy or a dealer, so any stigma applied to speed also applies to Adderall.
- kerkeslager 3y agoThere's a lot of things you said in this one post which just aren't true. 1. "Speed" refers to a variety of amphetamine salts, not just the four in Adderall. 2. "Enantiomers notwithstanding" is an absurd aside: one enantiomer, levoamphetamine, has significantly less euphoric effect and as such isn't sold as a street or party drug, except incidentally as an impurity. Which enantiomers you're receiving is extremely relevant in this group of chemicals. 3. "Smoking meth" and "taking Adderall" have very different social stigmas. I'm certainly not saying there's no social stigma around Adderall, but there's definitely a lot more social stigma against non-pharmaceutical amphetamines.
- krispyfi 3y agoHaven't you ever seen "they're giving our kids speed!" posts on social media? Everything in your post is true, but stigma isn't based on reality. Stigma against speed and Adderall are both fruit of the same poisoned tree. Trying to offset Adderall stigma by drawing (a correct!) distinction from speed is just furthering the problem.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Haven't you ever seen "they're giving our kids speed!" posts on social media? Yes, I have seen those posts. Have you seen the post you're responding to? I made it very clear that I'm aware there is some social stigma around Adderall. I'm saying there is a much more severe social stigma around illegally-obtained amphetamines.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoDesoxyn (methamphetamine) has been used for ADHD treatment also. If I had to guess, it's somewhat less effective than other blends with a higher potential for addiction. I have flirted with the idea of trying to get (pure) meth on the black market as an ADHD treatment during times where I was having trouble getting Adderall. I would only use it for this if I also had access to testing and could determine purity, so I could dose appropriate. Fortunately I've never been that desperate and unmedicated that I needed to take this risk. I was also prescribed 3 different amphetamine blends over the last 26 years (Vyvanse, Adderall, and Dexedrine) as well as taken a 14-year break from all ADHD meds over the same period. I do somewhat wonder if the size of the black market for amphetamines is so large in countries which outright ban amphetamines for ADHD treatment is in part due to people with ADHD self medicating (Yaba in Thailand for example, which now appears to be on the path to decriminalization)
- Solvency 3y agoyou must exist in a very narrow sect of society.
- p1esk 3y agoThe sect of those who know what adderall is, is very narrow indeed.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoThe most interesting thing I learned is that it works only if you have ADHD. For normal folks, it gives the illusion of it being useful with lout objectively improving anything. If you don’t have ADHD and are using Adderall, you are hurting yourself and society.
- Xcelerate 3y ago> is that it works only if you have ADHD My understanding is that this is mostly a myth. Predictors of ADHD (and consider that a diagnosis can be highly inconsistent depending on the practitioner) don’t have a strong correlation with measures of productivity increase that compare treatment groups with/without Adderall.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agohttps://www.nationalgeographic.com/premium/article/adhd-adderall-ritalin-focus-work#:~:text=When%20given%20these%20medications%20in,don't%20have%20the%20disorder https://www.nationalgeographic.com/premium/article/adhd-adde.... https://www.verywellhealth.com/taking-adderall-ritalin-without-adhd-8546956 https://www.verywellhealth.com/taking-adderall-ritalin-witho...
- idlewords 3y agoThat's an online meme unsupported by evidence.
- nickburns 3y agoand an urban legend (did we use to call them?) before online memes were a thing.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agohttps://www.nationalgeographic.com/premium/article/adhd-adderall-ritalin-focus-work#:~:text=When%20given%20these%20medications%20in,don't%20have%20the%20disorder https://www.nationalgeographic.com/premium/article/adhd-adde.... https://www.verywellhealth.com/taking-adderall-ritalin-without-adhd-8546956 https://www.verywellhealth.com/taking-adderall-ritalin-witho... We no longer live in the 90s.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoLet your girlfriend know that she deserves treatment on weekends, too. ADHD doesn't take days off. Medication helps with much more than work and chores.
- nickburns 3y agothis is unsolicited, non-medical healthcare advice. yikes.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoWell obviously they would have to talk to their psychiatrist, who would make the final decision. That is already legally guaranteed! I just wanted to share the context that it is very common for people to approach ADHD treatment from the perspective of work, and not life. I've talked to many people who have had to advocate for their own healthcare in this context, and greatly benefitted by doing so.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Well obviously they would have to talk to their psychiatrist, who would make the final decision. That is already legally guaranteed! Good thing psychologists are totally unmanipulable and nobody ever breaks laws. > I just wanted to share the context that it is very common for people to approach ADHD treatment from the perspective of work, and not life. Then perhaps you should have shared what you wanted to share instead of sharing an unqualified medical opinion.
- kerkeslager 3y agoAs someone with ADHD who has been on stimulants... yes, ADHD doesn't take time off, but it's not that simple, and you should be more careful with making confident assertions about what other people should do with their health. Stimulants slowly stopped working for me at low-moderate doses, and at higher doses I started having bad anxiety from them. One potential solution to this was to take time off from stimulants at regular intervals (such as weekends) to reduce buildup of tolerance and stay at the lower dose while getting the effects when I needed them. I ended up not going that route (taking Strattera now) but it's something I've heard from a few people. I'll also add that ADHD symptoms aren't always experienced as all bad by everyone. Some people experience it as more creative, or adjacent to flow, and only want "treatment" when they need to buckle down and do more "boring" work. I'm not in that camp, but a friend of mine is.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoSame for me, but took me even longer. I got where I am because I would spend whatever time it took to complete it, even when that meant neglecting family or sleep. Now I can do the same quality and quantity of work and learning, without all those hours wasting my time waiting for stress of the deadline to finally kick in to push out the ADD and just do the damn work. I can't help but wonder what the opportunity coat was for all that time.
- vwoolf 3y agoModafinil needs to be better represented.
- jclulow 3y agoAs a person with ADHD whose executive function is markedly improved by stimulant medication, and who knows a lot of people in the same boat, the whole thrust of the introduction to this article is pretty amazingly tone-deaf and specious.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoI have ADHD and am recently back on Adderall after a 14-15 year break. Honestly, it's pretty necessary for me at this point in my life, but there was a reason I went off it also, and a lot of the perhaps unexpected qualities mentioned in the stories here sound familiar to me. I never "liked" it though, I can't imagine taking it if I didn't also need to get shit done.
- sheepscreek 3y agoI echo this sentiment. I wish there was something less habit-forming that could help me function well. There isn’t. At least not yet.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoInterestingly I don't think it became a "habit" for me. I'd want to not take it as much as possible, so would avoid it on days I didn't need to cram or finish a big project. It has some undesireable side effects for me and I think does make me a bit more distant from emotions and empathy in a way that I think is reflected in my interactions. I feel like my communication is a bit more wooden if that makes sense.
- gcr 3y agoWhat do you think of modafinil, which is sometimes prescribed for some ADHD varieties?
- schneems 3y agoUgh. Same. I hate the “speed” narrative…It’s so addictive I need a cap on my medicine with a timer to know if I took it or not…
- jamesredd 3y agoToo many ups and downs causes instability. People don't like to admit it but many of the current problems are a consequence of drug use.
- lawlessone 3y agoYours maybe.
- nickburns 3y agowe all know why you've apparently taken offense to a non-confrontational personal opinion.
- kerkeslager 3y agoThe statement was definitely confrontational, and it being a personal opinion does not put it above criticism. Personal opinions can be bad, abhorrent, etc. And before you launch another ad hominem argument: I do not take stimulants of any kind for my ADHD, so no, I am not defending amphetamines for ADHD because I am addicted to them. Maybe keep your nose out of other people's medical business?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _fs 3y agoAs someone in their 40s who only received a diagnosis in their 40s, I found Adderall to be transformative. I only recognized the symptoms when my son was diagnosed ADHD and I started researching. It was through various videos and articles that I saw reflections of my own experiences. So I spoke to a doctor about it. My experience with Adderall is characterized by its stability. I don’t experience the highs and lows often associated with medication. I'm on a pretty low dose and I do not take the medication every day. Instead of feeling energized or high, Adderall brings me a sense of calm, which was somewhat unexpected, considering its use as a party drug. But for me, it silences the constant noise in my head and allows me to just think and speak. I can actually speak to people without my mind rushing ahead of my voice, tangling up all my words. I'm effective at work and my job performance has improved significantly. My wife noticed a change pretty quick in the day to day life around the home as well.
- lawlessone 3y agoIs Adderall significantly different the Ritalin? Prescribed the latter and I would not call it addictive. If I don't take it I don't crave it... ..unlike Nicotine which seems impossible to stop.
- sudosysgen 3y agoDepends on the person, but pharmacologically they are pretty similar.
- phyzome 3y agoI was on Ritalin as a kid and eventually it seemed to lessen in effectiveness, so we switched to a low initial dose of Adderall. Didn't do much, so we went to a higher dose a week later, and then the next higher a week after that. And then I was manic for a couple days. So we switched back to Ritalin, or found something else. Statistically they're probably pretty similar, but individual bodies and weird and variable. (Neither was addictive for me.)
- ShamelessC 3y agoIt is psychologically addictive as opposed to an addiction which would create a physical dependency in your system. Nicotine for instance doesn't really induce much of a "high" or "euphoria" (many report essentially no effect after prolonged usage). The reason stimulants like adderal can be addictive is that for many they induce an objective euphoria that upon self-conditioning can be incredibly difficult to stop taking the drug even though it doesn't technically have negative effects after stopping for a few days. Anyone who has suffered from depression or similar and taken an adderal for the first time will understand. It takes many bad feelings and replaces them with an almost manic productivity. There are downsides, but they commonly outweigh the negatives one was experiencing without the drug.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> It is psychologically addictive as opposed to an addiction which would create a physical dependency in your system. This is just flatly wrong. Amphetamines do have symptoms of physical (not psychological) withdrawal such as ataxia and diarrhea. These more severe symptoms only typically happen when withdrawing from higher doses than are prescribed, but those withdrawing from lower doses can expect to experience milder symptoms such as fatigue.
- illusive4080 3y agoI think I have ADHD but I am successful at work and have spurts of productivity (and laziness). I feel like I should just keep being the imperfect me.
- jclulow 3y agoI was diagnosed in my 30s. In retrospect, it explains a lot of difficulties I have had for my entire life. I wasn't hyperactive, so they mostly went unnoticed by other people -- it's really hard to know whether your struggles are unusual or not from the vantage point of your own head. I would say that if you feel good and life is working for you, then you don't need to do anything. If your life circumstances change (e.g., for me, our having a child definitely exhausted my ability to grit my teeth and push through my focus issues with all nighters, followed by sleeping all day to recover) then help is generally not far away!
- viciousvoxel 3y agoThat's absolutely fine and your choice, and great that you don't feel that you need it, but just for anyone who could benefit from medication and is seeing your comment, it doesn't make you any less "you". Just like wearing glasses won't fundamentally change you but can be pretty helpful if you need them.
- nickburns 3y agothat's truly a terrible metaphor. an ADD/ADHD diagnosis is not physiological. and neither myopia nor hyperopia are psychological.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoIt’s caused by the structure of the brain.
- nickburns 3y agocite?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoI remember being a kid during peak ADD hype. I was "diagnosed" by a teacher, who recommended drugs, which my father unapologetically told to go fuck herself. When I have taken aderall as an adult, I find that it is not conducive to mental work. It's fantastic if I need to hammer out a bunch of rote, physical tasks. I can't think about anything complex on it, I can't program on it, because my mind is everwyere. I do believe wholeheartedly that this new trend in software where everything is constantly broken, overcomplicated, well thought out decisions thrown out for no reason without a second thought (looking at you, side scrolling "open with..." dialog in android) is largely due to people tweaking behind their keyboards. To get a little woo woo, I remember reading a study about spiders on different drugs and how they spun their webs, and I came to the conclusion our form follows our function, we are what we do, and drugs modify our expression of our very being, and the feedback mechanisms by which we assess that expression. This can be good, bad, there can be tradeoffs, we may understand those or not, but the effect is evident in what we do, in the world we build around us.
- 7thaccount 3y agoWasn't the spider thing just a YouTube joke or was that from an actual legit study?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoYeah it was real. Conducted in 1948 by Peter N Witt, the experiment was funded by NASA.
- IAmGraydon 3y agoI'll never understand making a post instead of running a quick Google search. https://www.miragenews.com/nasas-experiment-with-spiders-mind-altering-996703/ https://www.miragenews.com/nasas-experiment-with-spiders-min...
- 7thaccount 3y agoHonestly? Usually because 1.) there are tons of folks on HN FAR more knowledgeable than I on many subjects, 2.) it's more annoying on my phone, and 3.) frequently it's not just a simple search. My apologies for being lazy though and thanks for the link.
- drewbug01 3y agoA far more accurate title would be “Nine writers on their drug addictions and experiences,” because very little of this article has anything to do with ADHD or the legitimate therapeutic uses of Adderall. Also telling that none of the writers reflected on how their behavior contributes to the absurd hoops people like me have to jump through to actually access the drug (when we can get it at all, anyways). If you’ve got ADHD, don’t bother reading it. It’s just infuriating.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoNo kidding, part six literally opens with: > I do not believe ADHD is an inherent thing. They just put those cards right on the table, lol. No hesitation! What I think a lot of people don't realize is that ADHD is classified as a neurodevelopmental disorder alongside stuff like autism. Which means attention and executive function are only a piece of the larger puzzle; ADHD's biggest impacts on me as a kid were (1) difficulty regulating emotions and (2) general social stunted-ness. I still struggle with the former, I thankfully caught up on the latter (mostly :P), and "attention" issues have remained an undercurrent throughout. Various medications, and not just stimulants(!) have helped on all fronts.
- giblfiz 3y agoSlate Star Codex did a great write-up of risks and rewards of adderall from their perspective as a "gatekeeping psychiatrist" It's a super informative, and kind of technical read. https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-mo...
- moneycantbuy 3y agoBe careful getting too excited about an amphetamine addiction. Delusions of grandeur etc. Maybe your body doesn't want to do homework for good reasons? I see the legal speed industry as just another shameless means to get people to continue working at soulless jobs. Cruel to drug so many kids. Might as well not reproduce in the first place if you insist they must sit still. Not to mention the side effects on heart, brain, sleep and tendency to become almost as insufferable as cokeheads. Way too many parents giving it a pass because it's sold as "medication". How about we stop creating fucked societies instead?
- kerkeslager 3y agoJust so you're aware, this sort of rambling in half-sentences generally comes across as a little unhinged, and doesn't generally persuade people. Maybe if you took Adderall you could write full sentences. ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- moneycantbuy 3y agoAttacking my style of prose doesn't change the facts. Amphetamines can harm the body in many ways, and lead to: •Appetite decrease and weight loss •Heart problems such as fast heart rate, irregular heartbeat, increased blood pressure, and heart attack •High body temperature and skin flushing •Memory loss, problems thinking clearly, and stroke •Mood and emotional problems such as aggressive or violent behavior, depression, and suicide •Ongoing hallucinations and inability to tell what is real •Restlessness and tremors •Skin sores •Sleep problems •Tooth decay (meth mouth) •Death
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Attacking my style of prose doesn't change the facts. True! I agree with everything you've said in this second post. However: 1. What you're describing as "the facts" has changed pretty significantly between your first and second posts. As it turns out, being more careful about how you communicate seems to make you more careful about actually stating the facts instead of your opinions. 2. Even if your first post were all facts (which it was not), I would prefer that the facts be presented persuasively so that people believe the facts--making the facts sound like the crazed ramblings of a stoned person is counterproductive to spreading facts.
- reilly3000 3y agoI recently underwent a voluntary general psychological evaluation as I was trying to get a professional opinion on autism. I have been with an ADHD diagnosis for about 10 years and medicated about half that time. A series of tests reaffirmed ADHD with quantitative data. For example I was asked to put on a set of headphones and press the space bar on a laptop when I heard certain tones, or was flashed particular letters. I performed terribly at these tasks, even as I was regarded otherwise as healthy and with above average intelligence. I medicated ADHD was for me about getting in car accidents a lot and general aimlessness. Productivity wasn’t a primary concern for me, but I exhausted myself to reach average levels of output. I’ve never ‘popped pills’ that weren’t prescribed to me, and always take mine with consistent timing. Reading these essays was infuriating and painful, to bear witness to a stigma I wasn’t really aware of. I don’t use adderall as a cheat code. I take it because it is what my doctors recommend and because I’m unsafe and unmoored without it.
- 2devnull 3y agoFrom the anecdotes I hear, it seems dubious from an ethical standpoint because the assertion is almost always that a person cannot think clearly due to add, so they need meds. But how can they consent to taking those meds if they can’t think clearly? Surely researching the cost/benefit and long term health outcomes of a drug like that requires the ability to focus and think clearly. It seems hard to defend, ethically.