11 ms·
> Still no clear way to have a civilised discussion around this kind of subject I guess. You don't seem to understand that civilized public discussion begins w
by kazinator 3y ago
> Still no clear way to have a civilised discussion around this kind of subject I guess.
You don't seem to understand that civilized public discussion begins with identifying a forum where the material is topical; that is part of the civility. Not only being civil in tone and choice of words.
An issue being important to everyone doesn't overrule topicality.
Look, here you are, under a story about the origin of "pencil lead", going on about something entirely different, using the commenting system for private messaging.
If this were Usenet, you'd be plonked into my killfile.
- kazinator 3y agoSuppose there is a violent conflict going in in which innocent people are killed. (Oh look, I can pick from a number of them.) I feel strongly about it! I'm also interested in stamp collecting; let's log in to a forum about stamp collecting where I like to hang out and, and post about the conflict. What, my posts are being deleted? God, I hate other stamp collectors; all they care about is stamp collecting and not tens of thousands of people dying! I really need a different hobby; everyone in stamp collecting is so hostile! Could it actually be that the forum mods support the Murderous Evil Side in the conflict? Yeah, that must be it. It's like the dozens of excellent posts I made in the past about stamp collecting suddenly don't matter, you know? You're only as good as your last post in this goddamned forum, and if it wasn't about stamp collecting, you're garbage.
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agoAs I pointed out in another comment the HN guidelines say: On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. I find it interesting that I'm paid less than my male colleagues for the same amount of work (I am). You're welcome to argue I'm not a good hacker. >> Look, here you are, under a story about the origin of "pencil lead", going on about something entirely different, using the commenting system for private messaging. Yep, and here you are ranting that I violated the rule that the commenting system can't be used for private messaging; a rule that you invented on the spot just so you could rant at me. Btw, I do consider this thing we're having right now "civilised debate". One can argue robustly, speak frankly as you just did, and still be civilised. But one needs to be an adult to handle that.
- kazinator 3y agoWhat that means is topics that hackers in particular would find interesting compared to non-hackers. If 90% of the hackers find something interesting, but 90% non-hackers also find it interesting, then it's not a hackerly topic. I.e. "... that good hackers (in particular, in contrast to the general population) would find interesting". That's the non-strawman interpretation. I'm positive I didn't just invent the idea that public forums are not for private messaging, let alone invent it today. In any case, that usually runs afoul of basic topicality. If you have to grasp at strawman, literal interpretations of the written guidelines to justify your behavior, some people who don't take those interpretations will probably find that behavior against the guidelines. I'm only articulating some possible reasons why your submission might be being flagged. (What it means for me to be wrong here is that, no those are not the reasons; it's something else.) In my opinion, possibly wrong, to avoid being flagged under a crowdsourced moderation model, your interpretation of the guidelines has to be similar to that of the crowd. The crowd is not going to take a literal, strawman interpretation of the rules. Maybe some of the crowd will but not all of it, and only a small fraction of the crowd is needed to flag you. If you're straining at the boundaries of the guidelines, the odds are heavily stacked against you.
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agoI agree with your last paragraph but that some subjects may not be popular is not a reason to not post them. The worst that can happen is that the articles keep getting flagged, and I give up, or there is some intervention from dang. The most likely outcome is that they're just ignored, as is the case with most stuff I post (controversial or not). In the meantime I feel free to continue contributing just as I do.
- kazinator 3y agoWell, the worst that could happen is that you get banned. But then you can make new accounts and so it goes. Basically the same approach as that of any crypto scam promoter. Except, the content is different. The content justifies the approach, right? So whatever. No content is ever inappropriate for any site no matter what the feedback from the community; as the saying goes, "if you just throw enough shit at a wall, some of it will stick".