3 ms·
Not only are those terms overreaching, they are copied from elsewhere. Search with Google for "a non-exclusive, perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free, fully pai
by Animats 3y ago
Not only are those terms overreaching, they are copied from elsewhere. Search with Google for "a non-exclusive, perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free, fully paid-up, worldwide license (including the right to sublicense through multiple tiers)" and you get quite a few hits. Mostly from small businesses.
Primrose Schools, Rita's Ice, Small's Sliders, Transom Capital, and quite a few other small companies use exactly those words. The first three are franchisors, and the last one is a private equity company. None are in the social media business, for which that clause is clearly intended.
Do all those companies use the same low-budget legal drafting service?
- weikju 3y ago> Do all those companies use the same low-budget legal drafting service? Yes. Boilerplate rules the legal world as far as I can see. As well as always sneaking in things in the hopes that people will fail to notice and not notice.
- _petronius 3y agoPart of the reason for legal boilerplate, however, is that in case of litigation specifics do matter. A "known good" phrasing, therefore, will always be preferred by a lawyer giving you good advice, rather than an original and untested one. In some juristictions (such as Germany), the courts even _require a specific phrasing_ (even if it is bad/confusing for the lay person) in order for something to be legally effective. This is not laziness on the lawyers' part, it is them doing what is correct, given the priorities they have been given.
- Animats 3y agoThere's nothing wrong with using standard clauses. Lawyers who use the wrong standard clauses, though, didn't do their job.
- fmajid 3y agoOr lazy lawyers using ChatGPT and hoping no one will notice. I think it’s clear Vultr noticed now.
- amarcheschi 3y agoI had a professor who founded a few startups, one of which was funded by Microsoft after he had the opportunity to speak with Bill gates. Regarding ToS and similar things, he told us that especially for startups, they were heavily "inspired" by other startups and other companies and made minor adjustments, so yeah, I don't find it hard to believe it's all a game of copy pasting