4 ms·
> avoid saving info so you can't ever leak it I think that this is a good idea. It's similar to the principle of least privilege: keep only what you need to of
by mooreds 3y ago
> avoid saving info so you can't ever leak it
I think that this is a good idea. It's similar to the principle of least privilege: keep only what you need to offer the service you are providing. Less risk for the provider, less risk for the consumer.
However, at least in the USA, I've noticed an increasing number of companies who have determined that personal data is worth good money. This is why most stores have rewards programs, where they capture what you've bought and when you have bought it.
If it was just about repeat business, they'd still be using punch cards, like they did a decade ago.
I don't have any insight into how they use the data, but why would they offer free things (restaurants offer appetizers, grocery stores offer discounts, etc) unless the value they received was more than the cost of the incentive?
- Affric 3y agoI am still waiting for digital identity. Not sure why I can’t authenticate myself with these companies based on a private key and any details they want be disclosed to them for whatever reason don’t just come ephemerally from my server. Obviously, you could also have a third party acting in this space for the non-tech savvy. Right now all my data is held by corporate types who don’t give a shit.
- mooreds 3y agoPasskeys are a start. They have their issues (I wrote about some here: https://ciamweekly.substack.com/p/on-webauthn-and-passkeys https://ciamweekly.substack.com/p/on-webauthn-and-passkeys ) but at least it is widespread, well supported, standardized, (possibly) anonymous public private key cryptography.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoIt seems likely that you know passkeys better than I do (you wrote a blog about them after all), so I've got a question. My impression is that there's a server side component. It's not just a key in your device, it's a key in your device that's blessed by someone who maintains a server. My further impression is that the people who manage the servers (either the authenticating-you server or the supporting-auth-for-you server) will be able to configure allow/deny lists for each other. They can say: > sorry passkeys.jimbobsmomsbasement.com, you're not on the list of servers that I trust, so I'm not going to accept this key Quoting GP here: > Right now all my data is held by corporate types who don’t give a shit. Is it true that passkey providers will be able to use this feature band together and prevent passkey providers that they don't like from being useful? It was something about attestations--I didn't fully get it the first time it was explained to me. If so, doesn't that make the "corporate types who don't give a shit" problem worse? At least with a password the corporate types couldn't deny you the right to authenticate because in their estimation your password provider isn't corporate enough.
- hirsin 3y agoIt's not a server-side component but something integral to the passkey itself. Everything is on the key and there's no third party - just the key, and the site you're authing to. So when you auth with a passkey, it includes some details around "this came from a Feitian model x or yubico model y or bitwarden or...". That's blank, IIRC, if it's Apple. And then if a corporate type has said "well we only gave our employees Yubikey 3s", they can instruct their idp to only accept passkeys for Yubikey 3s. This is a tradeoff - their employees can't register legitimate, useful personal passkeys like their phone, but an arbitrary (not dedicated nationstate) attacker is a bit less likely to somehow takeover the account and add a Feitian key. That mismatch is a nice signal to block the user. But in general, outside of corporate identities, no one has any interest in caring what kind of passkey you use. GitHub doesn't, certainly, outside of resident key requirements, a different bundle of fish. (and yes, Dan is definitely great at this stuff, read his blog on this stuff).
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI see, thank you. I suppose it also lets you reject keys from hardware platforms that are later determined to be insecure. The tinfoilhattery which I heard (and regret tangentially supporting on occasion) was that it was a slippery slope towards something like SSO, where some company (1Password, say) is your identity provider. And then other companies might reject your identity because hypothetically 1Password only collects a retinal scan, not also DNA, or somesuch, and now we're in a race to the bottom re: just how authenticated one can be.
- juped 3y agoIt's hardly tinfoil hattery. If it isn't that (and I'm still not convinced by all the above that it isn't) then it needs to explain exactly how it isn't loudly, repeatedly, clearly, and very prominently.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoThe messaging around it sure has been heavy on the "you should do this it's better" and light on the "and here are the implications".
- yau8edq12i 3y agoPasskeys simply authenticate a device + maybe a PIN. Not a person.
- shicholas 3y agoThe Schluss project out of the Netherlands is trying to do just that, really cool stuff! (Schluss.org)
- canadiantim 3y agoFor a third party acting in this space who could provide a server for the non-tech savvy, what do you think the ideal setup is, infrastructure and architecture wise?
- ahaseeb 3y agosome of it has to be with regulations where data retention is required by the law ( Fintech/Telco). Other than that it's to learn more about client and use the data to reach more clients. In a perfect world, we should have the right to revoke our data access anytime we want, specially when there is a material change in management ( Exit/Acquired/CoFounder left) etc.
- eddd-ddde 3y agoEven without reward programs, couldn't they just associate purchases with a given credit card or similar?
- mooreds 3y agoAbsolutely. And I am sure they do. But rewards programs might make matching easier (across different credit cards and household members). They also are owned by the service provider and don't reveal anything to credit card companies. Again, I'm speculating here.
- jmward01 3y agoThis has been my thinking too. When I make any purchase I am giving everything about myself away now. A long time ago I had the idea to create an 'accountability' e-mail server/credential generator that generated emails/credentials with unique ids along with a note about what it was used for so that you could see exactly who sold your info when you saw junk mail come in. There are now ways to do this but it is still a bit manual. It would be great to have this tied in with auto opt-out and auto reporting of abusers. Of course creating a personal e-mail server now is almost impossible.
- caddy 3y agoNot really, I rented a box from hetzner and have ran mail-in-a-box for over a year now. The IP I was assigned was on the microsoft shitlist for a little bit, but I sent them an email explaining why I was using the server and they took me off the list. Also took a few emails to GMail to get off their spam filter, but a few emails to family and asking them to report not spam (around 3 emails) was all it took. The only server I've ever been rejected by is a corporate email server with very strict settings, but every other corporate email has been fine.
- trimethylpurine 3y agoWe don't actually care. We're interested in how the product is doing so we know how little we can get away with ordering (to the warehouse). I think the rewards are for sharing with other brands or stores that are owned by the same parent. I doubt they would sell to a competitor. That would directly reduce their own sales. Selling to another industry doesn't make sense either. No one wants more liability for retaining irrelevant data.
- m-p-3 3y ago> personal data is worth good money Then let's make the penalties substantially higher with the risk it incurs.
- mooreds 3y agoIsn't that what the CCPA and other laws are trying to do? https://www.burr.com/newsroom/articles/summary-and-comparison-of-u-s-data-privacy-laws https://www.burr.com/newsroom/articles/summary-and-compariso... is an outline of some of the US efforts.
- _yb2s 3y agoYep... I think already companies have a profit incentive to not keep data they don't think will provide them value. They are keeping the data not because they are not thinking about security, but because the data is valuable to them, either to sell to a 3rd party or to better target/market to specific customers.
- RajT88 3y agoA lot of companies seem to pay to keep data they are not using. Some because they forgot, some because they have not figured out how to monetize it yet.
- alpaca128 3y agoReal hacks and leaks have shown that even if there is an incentive to not keep data and minimize damage, it is negligible. If the consequences don't go beyond slightly higher DB sizes nobody cares. The potential cost needs to be much higher than potential profits from selling the data.
- ryan_lane 3y ago> I don't have any insight into how they use the data, but why would they offer free things (restaurants offer appetizers, grocery stores offer discounts, etc) unless the value they received was more than the cost of the incentive? Ignoring selling the data to brokers, it's not hard to think of some ways to use the data that's beneficial to both you and them: - Inventory management: You buy something low demand, but you do it consistently. If they can match up all the purchases of that item to specific folks, and they know the general frequency at which people buy that item, they can ensure it's stocked when you need it, without the need to greatly overstock it. If you stop coming, they also know they may be able to reduce that stock safely. - Price sensitivity: They do a price increase. Which customers have stopped purchasing the product? Do they need to do a sale on the item for you to purchase it again? Do they need to drop the price? This is more of a benefit on their side than yours, but knowing the most frequent purchasers stopped purchasing it due to an increase could lead to a decrease, where this is harder to determine without good data. - How effective are their sales? Are they targeting them correctly? The discount they offer isn't really a discount. It's a price hike for folks without the loyalty program.
- mooreds 3y agoThanks. Are these benefits based on your experience/direct knowledge or supposition? They definitely seem reasonable to me, though I'm not sure they need individually identifiable info for most of them. > The discount they offer isn't really a discount. It's a price hike for folks without the loyalty program. Sure, that's just messaging. But as a consumer it feels like a discount when I get 0.50/lb off chicken I buy when I use my card.
- Nullabillity 3y agoNone of those need to track individuals, they're all really just SKU sales metrics dressed up in different ways.
- jghn 3y agoEven before the Great Sell Off, there was a growing notion of "we may need this some day so let's store and/or log it". And it makes sense. If you store it and don't need it, it's relatively cheap, at least in the last couple decades. But if you *don't* store it and need it, you're screwed.
- pc86 3y agoDo you mean 3-4 decades ago? I've been grocery shopping for myself since the 00s and have never seen a physical punch card being used in a grocery store.
- berniedurfee 3y agoOur local convenience stores still use them for various items. Milk card and ice cream scoops! But no, supermarket chains are all heavily data driven now.
- pc86 3y agoOh man I would love to go somewhere where they just gave you a physical card.