4 ms·
As a parent of four children (but living in a different state), I had to think for a minute about what the real problem is here. If I knew that a particular tea
by tokenadult 15y ago
As a parent of four children (but living in a different state), I had to think for a minute about what the real problem is here. If I knew that a particular teacher was teaching well in advance of the meager United States curriculum, perhaps even coming close to east Asian standards, I would (as a parent) take that into account when looking at teacher ratings based on a slower curriculum pace. My question might be, "How do I sign up?" rather than "What is the matter with this teacher?" (By the way, the school's answer about how to sign up is found on its website:
http://www.ps334school.org/admissions/anderson-school-7th-grade-admissions http://www.ps334school.org/admissions/anderson-school-7th-gr...
The school accepts new applicants for sixth grade or seventh grade, but not for eighth grade.)
But, really, the problem with the system is not mostly about how teachers are rated, but how little power most parents have to shop. If a teacher is doing a good job for a particular learner, most parents will be glad to seek that teacher's instruction. And if the parents are shopping, the hard-to-measure things in the aggregate that are crucially important at the individual level, for example whether or not a teacher encourages a child to do his or her personal best, will be given proper weight among all the trade-offs involved in choosing one teacher over another. But right now the great majority of pupils, in New York City and elsewhere, are mostly assigned to teachers without parental power to shop, and teacher advancement in the profession is based mostly on seniority and degrees attained
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/19/us/19gates.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/19/us/19gates.html
rather than on the basis of the teachers meeting learner needs better than other teachers. The best way to promote system reform is to let the parents have more power to shop. They will ask for the information they need and weigh it in appropriate ways.
- redthrowaway 15y agoThe 'let's give parents the ability to shop' ethos is what directly led to the current clusterfuck that is the US public education system, through NCLB and its state equivalents. I'm not opposed in principle to the idea of statistically ranking teachers and giving the power of choice to parents, but you guys have royally fucked it up in practice. Signed, A victim of the evil socialist Canadian public school system.
- ShabbyDoo 15y agoIf I think I need a new suit and the only information available to me is the colors of various suits and their thread counts, I might be forced to make a selection solely based on these attributes. But, because I can touch the suits, try them on, and examine their quality in whatever ways I deem fit, I don't have to rely upon price as a measure of quality. Without exchanging experiences with other kids' parents, aren't these "shoppers" forced to make do with the available data? Perhaps a parents' "shopping night" where each teacher gives a short talk on his/her education philosophy and then sticks around for Q/A would allow use of better selection criteria?
- rapala 15y agoI think you misunderstood the grandparent. In many countries, and I think in Canada too, you cannot choose the school your kids go to.
- 3pt14159 15y agoMy parents did. It's called private school and then you can choose any place you want. But in all seriousness, while there are exceptions for arts schools, you generally cannot choose where to send your kids except by moving. Some people "rent a room" in a desirable district so their kids can go to a better school, but really all that happens is that housing prices skyrocket in the "right" areas.
- rmckayfleming 15y agoHi, Canadian here. There is a bit of leg room when it comes to what school you go to (at least in the region where I went to school). Most high schools in the region have some sort of magnet program that allow for students to attend without living in the school's defined area. Both my sister and I went to different schools than where we were 'supposed' to go. So it's not a hard line, but these magnet programs only accept so many students. So for the most part it is true. Just giving some clarification.
- losvedir 15y ago> The 'let's give parents the ability to shop' ethos There's no way to avoid it, even in principle. What if you move? In the US, home prices are elevated in certain areas because people who live at that address get to go to a good school. So there's still school shopping, when it comes to deciding where to live (it's often a key factor in that decision). I think that's how it is most places, actually. At least where I grew up in California, I was assigned to a certain high school based on where I live. We could have applied for a transfer, but those aren't often granted. This is all for the public school system, of course. There are private schools as well, which operate differently, but I think for the most part people go to public schools.
- mcherm 15y agoIf you give the parents the ability to "shop", what happens when everyone thinks that teacher X is the best English teacher for 7th grade and they ALL want their kids in her class? Or what about the kids whose parents aren't as involved (maybe they both work full time or it's a single-parent household) and therefore don't get a chance to hear about which teachers are best... do those kids just get the less-capable teachers?