4 ms·
Good question. Does the "defense spending" category include the trillion dollar wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? George W. Bush's administration conveniently swept
by cpeterso 15y ago
Good question. Does the "defense spending" category include the trillion dollar wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? George W. Bush's administration conveniently swept the wars' costs into a "supplemental" budget separate from the DoD budget.
- waterlesscloud 15y ago"The figures in the graph include veterans' benefits as well as funding for current operations."
- gruseom 15y agoThat suggests that the off-budget wars were not included. Edit: never mind. I was referring to what they call the "unfunded" wars under GWB but the graph obviously doesn't include those years.
- nnnnnnnn 15y agoNo, the graph clearly does not include the supplementary spending. I ran the numbers for this a while back, and the supplementary extra-budget DoD spending in the Bush years raised the DoD expenses from 22% to nearly 40% in some cases. Military expenditures are much higher than 22%, even in 2011. These budget numbers hide much military spending in other budgetary components -- for example, veteran's benefits or military scholarships will fit into another category (Medicare, everything else, etc). Statistics that put military spending at a quarter of our budget never include these costs. A big part of this "change" comes from a budgeting game which hides military costs in other budgets. Contrary to claims in the article, VA benefits and medical claims did exist as an expense 50 years ago -- but they were directly part of the Defense budget at that time.
- streptomycin 15y agoNone of the graphs are from the Bush era, so your question is irrelevant.
- cpeterso 15y agoNone of the graphs are from the Bush era, but the Iraq war was still active in 2011. I was asking whether the cost of the war's operation omitted from this graph's "Defense spending".
- streptomycin 15y agoI thought, by how you phrased your question, you knew that Obama had reversed Bush's funny accounting policy. If not, http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/20/us/politics/20budget.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/20/us/politics/20budget.html Either way, the wars are very cheap these days.