3 ms·
Something that's missing from all of these discussions is that transactions on Apple Pay (and all similar wallets like Google Pay, Samsung Pay etc.) are now jus
by lxgr 3y ago
Something that's missing from all of these discussions is that transactions on Apple Pay (and all similar wallets like Google Pay, Samsung Pay etc.) are now just as trackable as those done using the underlying card number.
While the DPAN is unique to a given device, the merchant's payment service provider these days can receive a unique identifier called PAR in the authorization response from the card network. That identifier is consistent across all DPANs for the same card (and aspirationally even across card number changes on the same underlying account).
The PAR can't be charged by any merchant, so this is not a security problem, but don't expect your digital wallet payments to be any more private than those done using your regular card or card number.
https://wcapra.com/payment-account-reference-capraplus-your-source-for-insight/ https://wcapra.com/payment-account-reference-capraplus-your-...
https://www.securetechalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/EMVCo-PAR-WP-FINAL-April-2018.pdf https://www.securetechalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/EMVCo-...
- mattmaroon 3y agoI would never expect anything to get more private ever again short of acts of government.
- ljlolel 3y agoTry reading the book Seeing like a State
- worthless-trash 3y ago> (and aspirationally even across card number changes on the same underlying account). My local Australian bank (NAB) does this. I imagine it's pretty normal across most credit cards here.
- astrange 3y agoNot true in Japan, Apple Pay uses anonymous ICOCA (aka Suica) cards which you can delete and recreate if you want.
- klausa 3y agoThis is a very weird understanding of what IC cards are in Japan. Yes, Apple Pay supports them, and they're ephemeral and easily recreated, and semi-anonymous; but Apple Pay over here absolutely still supports "regular" cards here. And you can't use your IC card for online purchases, which is most of the article was about anyway.
- astrange 3y ago> Yes, Apple Pay supports them, and they're ephemeral and easily recreated, and semi-anonymous …so what I said, yes. > but Apple Pay over here absolutely still supports "regular" cards here But you don't have to use em. Strange interaction here: you can refill Suica with a foreign credit card, there is no transaction fee for it, and it means you can turn anything you can purchase via IC card into 5x travel spending with the right card.
- klausa 3y agoMaybe it's a non-native speaker thing; but for me when you says "Apple Pay uses XYZ here"; it implies exclusivity, that it underpins the whole system; not that it's one of the available option. I can see now that's not what you meant. > But you don't have to use em. You do, if you want to use it over the internet. You and I might have a good grasp of what IC cards here are; but your comment without that knowledge can be misleading. > it means you can turn anything you can purchase via IC card into 5x travel spending with the right card. As long as nothing you buy costs more than 20000 JPY ;)
- lxgr 3y agoSure, you can also add some anonymous prepaid/gift cards to Apple Pay, but my point is that Apple Pay does not add any privacy/anonymity beyond that of the underlying card, contrary to what some people seem to still believe. The PAR was introduced after Apple Pay (and in a way in response to it and other wallets), and some people might have missed it.