3 ms·
Do we know why they went with a system based strictly on a zone instead of based on the congestion level in that zone? It seems a fee based on congestion levels
by xnx 3y ago
Do we know why they went with a system based strictly on a zone instead of based on the congestion level in that zone? It seems a fee based on congestion levels would maximize use of the roads by encouraging more use at off hours.
- lxgr 3y ago> a fee based on congestion levels would maximize use of the roads by encouraging more use at off hours. Assuming that's the goal, which I don't think it is (at least not by itself). Changing people's habits in favor of public transit and other options would be the real long-term win, not them doing their car-based trips in the middle of the night.
- goodSteveramos 3y ago>Changing people's habits in favor of public transit If that is what this is about then why dont they spend money making the public transit options better? There are dozens of unbuilt subway lines, areas with poor or no public transit and large amounts of crime all of which making a car a far superior choice. Taxing the car until people put up with an inferior transit service is not an improvement.
- arcticbull 3y agoMore ridership demand and more taxes on car owners means more money to build transit. Also a more vocal group of people demanding it.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoWhy should the people who have been underserved for decades be the ones to bear a disproportionate amount of the cost of building new services?
- arcticbull 3y agoThey're dramatically over-served. Cars are a luxury. They've been afforded free roads, free parking and free externalities for like a hundred years. Free ride's over.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoLiving in a poor or lower middle class outer suburb and commuting by car is slower and hundreds of dollars a month more expensive than living in the urban core and taking public transportation. I have no idea what on Earth you are talking about. Do you think everyone lives in a low density suburban sprawl where public transportation is completely impractical?
- arcticbull 3y ago> Living in a poor or lower middle class outer suburb and commuting by car is slower and hundreds of dollars a month more expensive than living in the urban core and taking public transportation. Totally. Because it's wildly inefficient for everyone to own an average 0.8 $35,000 blocks of metal that are in motion an average of 1.02 hours per day (idle almost 96% of the time). That requires roads, lights, signs, police, fire trucks, ambulances, gas stations/charging ports, insurance, parking, registration and tracking, maintenance, etc. That's before we get to externalities. Yes it's hundreds of dollars more expensive to have a car, but it should be thousands. It's incredibly subsidized. Car owners have been massively over-served, and it's time they directly paid the actual cost of their choices. Car ownership should be a luxury, not a requirement to exist. Especially in lower-middle-class suburbs. All our investments into roads and highways should be redirected towards avoiding it. All parking should be for-pay. Road costs should be born by road users. And yeah, people who make inefficient choices about their transportation should be penalized by usage charges. What makes you think road users have been underserved relative to the literally zero investment in transit made in the US since Eisenhower? Why shouldn't the cost of a dramatically less efficient transportation choice be much higher than a much more efficient transportation choice?
- occz 3y ago
- shmatt 3y agoyou mean finding out the price 45 minutes after you left the house?
- nix0n 3y ago> encouraging more use at off hours NYC is "the city that never sleeps". Deliveries have been happening overnight for decades already, due to the traffic congestion.
- asoneth 3y agoI think it's meant to approximate that sort of dynamic pricing while making it simpler for drivers (and voters) to understand. Sort of like how dynamic electricity pricing for retail consumers takes the form of binary peak/off-peak pricing whereas industrial users can buy from wholesale markets with wild price swings.