3 ms·
> We don't need H1Bs. We need better PhD student and postdoc wages. You need both. Your PhD classmates from abroad (most likely Russia, China, Korea, and Indi
by alephnerd 3y ago
> We don't need H1Bs. We need better PhD student and postdoc wages.
You need both.
Your PhD classmates from abroad (most likely Russia, China, Korea, and India) would have gotten an H1B after they graduated from the PhD program, and their (edit: post-) postdoc employment would have been on an H1B.
I'm assuming this was the late 1990s or early 2000s based on the numbers provided
One of my friends who did their PhD and postdoc at Stanford has been facing the J1 to H1B hellhole because employers increasingly make the applicant pay for the entire O-1 process now. They decided to screw the whole process and return to China.
- ta988 3y agoUntrue the vast majority of foreign postdocs are on J1
- alephnerd 3y agoAnd until the late 2000s, if those postdocs wanted a private sector job in the US they needed an employer to sponsor their H1-B. Also, the J-1 didn't become the primary route for postdocs until the early 2000s
- BobaFloutist 3y agoOr maybe people who have dedicated half a decade to getting an education and/or working in the US in highly skilled, advanced knowledge positions should have a path to residency so they're not the mercy at their employer for the rest of their life. Just a thought.
- alephnerd 3y agoAgreed, but that kind of reform ain't happening. It's been stalled since the 2010s.
- COGlory 3y agoI stuck my own narrative in here, perhaps I should have been clearer. One thing I see over and over again are people saying that there aren't enough highly educated Americans, hence why we have to import non-Americans. I'm trying to point out why that is - we've made it economic suicide to go into advanced science as an American. At my university, the vast majority of the incoming PhD class in Chemistry and Biochemistry were American when I joined. When I left, it was closer to 50%, the other 50% being mostly Nigerian and Ghanan (no idea why those two countries specifically). The Americans had just been priced out.
- hedora 3y agoI’ve heard the path to getting a professorship in China after getting a PhD in the US was basically a sure thing, and could be used as a backup plan if the cushy US industry job path didn’t work out (or as a zero-risk plan if you wanted to move back home). Now, it’s the opposite; people with hard-to-obtain visas get stranded in the US because the job market back home is too competitive for them. This is great for China, but terrible for the US. We need to bring the US education system back up to modern standards so that more Americans succeed in industry, and we also need to again make it a no-brainer for skilled workers to stay here.
- 11101010001100 3y agoThis is compensated by immigrants from other countries choosing to stay in the US.
- alephnerd 3y agoLots of Chinese (like my friends) who studied in the US would have preferred to stay in the US, but began facing hurdles around employment, visas, and background checks. The headaches became to much so they "decided" to move back to China because at least they could earn a US level salary, or move to Chinese adjacent countries like Singapore. My friend did research in condensed matter physics with semiconductor applications, but no lab in the US would hire him due to National Security reasons. Now he works for an organization "supposedly" part of the Chinese MIC.