5 ms·
Fewer U.S. scientists are pursuing postdoc positions, new data show
- alephnerd 3y agoUnsurprising. The pay sucks, hours are long, and the largest industry to hire postdocs (Biomedical) is going through a fairly severe recession that has impacted lab developers in Boston and SF as well. Edit: My analysis of the second order effect is wrong. From the article - "Much of the shift can be attributed to employment numbers in the biological and biomedical sciences, which saw a 3% drop in the total number of postdocs from 2021 to 2022 and a 10% drop in the number who were U.S. citizens and permanent residents. It’s not clear from the recent data release what’s driving the trends. But the declines coincide with a boom in hiring at biotech companies. And data from a separate survey released by NSF last year indicated fewer U.S. Ph.D. graduates in the life sciences are pursuing postdocs than ever before, with an increasing number heading to industry" Basically, it looks like you don't need to have a postdoc anymore to work as a researcher in the Biotech industry now. That said, PE/VC funding has dried up in Biotech compared to a couple years ago Paying postdocs private sector hourly salaries will probably resolve the issue, but that effort needs to come from the NSF, NIH, DHHS, and other grantmakers.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Paying postdocs private sector hourly salaries will probably resolve the issue What's the actual issue, though? Is there something bad that this effect is causing?
- alephnerd 3y agoSalaries are basically limited to $50-70k a year with 50-60 hour workweeks. If you did a PhD in Biochemistry, you could make $100-200k a year plus stock working 40-50 hours a week at most working for Pfizer in Cambridge MA instead of earning around $60k working 50-60 hours as a Postdoc at a regional Boston based program like BU or Northeastern - you have to pay the same amount for rent and groceries, but you earn half as much and work much longer hours. At that point, the only reason to be a postdoc is to get your foot in the door if you went to a less recruited program or are from abroad. For example, in the article - “My personal experience is that Americans were always less willing to put up with conditions that foreigners like myself had to put up with,” says McDowell, who moved from the United Kingdom to the United States for a postdoc in biomedicine.
- robertlagrant 3y agoBut what's the actual problem that fewer postdocs causes?
- alephnerd 3y agoMuch less experimental and fundamental research. Companies aren't going to invest in experimental research in the biotech space as the costs are so high. Most compounds end up getting validated in some way shape or form by researchers, then productionized by the private sector. This has a pipeline effect on development in the industry. For example, mRNA Vaccine research was purely experimental research done by postdocs and junior researchers at UPenn in the 1990s, before being commercialized by BioNtech and Moderna in the mid-2000s.
- el_cujo 3y agoThere really isn't one in my opinion. Academic postdoc positions in many fields are pitched as a stepping stone to professorship, but professor positions are very few so you end up with PHDs continuing the low-pay grind after graduation to prop up academia for a dream that doesn't come true. I think it's good more are recognizing this and just going to industry, maybe eventually this will cause problems and academia can be motivated to fix itself instead of viewing post docs as disposable. Or maybe there's no problem to fix and this is academia just getting correctly recognized as the grind option for people who are actually ok with that
- alephnerd 3y ago> academia can be motivated to fix itself The fundamental issues with postdoc salaries and grantmaking lies with the US Government. It is the grantmakers like the CDC, NIH, CMS, DARPA, etc that essentially set postdoc salaries for grants. And these agencies are completely averse to change. Furthermore, us in industry are NOT going to fund fundamental or experimental research due to relatively low margins.
- etrautmann 3y agoThe professor positions themselves aren't particularly cushy at the end of that road. Some postdocs take a look at the prospects of 60-70 hour weeks, very little time to focus on anything scientific or technical, and huge piles of administrative work, and relatively low pay and choose to industry options not out of a lack of the ability to land a professorship.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoLack of research. Most academic research is done by postdocs through grants from e.g. NSF. NSF and other grantors cap postdoc pay at below living wage in expensive cities like Boston. (The professor and university who hire the postdoc have very little flexibility to pay them more.) Add that it's a temp job with no security and fewer people want to sign up. So a lot of cutting-edge research can't get done.
- robertlagrant 3y agoBut is that because a lot of value can be found in these same people producing in industry at the moment? I wonder if there could be a cycle of sometimes discovery being more valuable, because biotech is fairly commoditised, and a cycle of implementation sometimes being more valuable, because we haven't made the most of discoveries.
- _1 3y agoNo shit. Who wants to still be treated like a grad student after defending. I didn't even consider looking for a post doc, and I graduated more than 10 years ago. Stayed on as a staff scientist for about five years then went to industry.
- betaby 3y agoIn the replication crisis era it's a good thing I suppose. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis
- alephnerd 3y agoThe researchers who would replicate studies would be postdocs themselves.
- betaby 3y ago..and having a lot of them didn't improve the situation.
- alephnerd 3y agoThere was a shortage of them already. The shortage only got worse
- betaby 3y agoShortage should lead to a better pay and(or) a higher vacancy. However those are not the case.
- MattGaiser 3y agoIsn’t the vacancy rate quite high?
- betaby 3y agoQuick google search says no?
- alephnerd 3y agoThe wages are set by the US Government (who tend to be the largest grantmakers). > a higher vacancy This absolutely IS the case. The US used to fix this through immigration, but Chinese researchers are de facto blacklisted now and Indian researchers are increasingly deciding to return to India instead of waiting 15-20 years for naturalization.
- jihadjihad 3y ago> According to the latest data release, 62,750 postdocs were employed at U.S. institutions in the fall of 2022, a 1% drop compared with the year before. But the trend diverges sharply by citizenship. From 2021 to 2022, the number of U.S. citizens and permanent residents working as postdocs dropped from 29,755 to 27,289. > The 8% change is the largest year-to-year percentage-wise drop in the history of the survey, which has collected data since 1980. Meanwhile, the number of postdocs with temporary visas increased by 6%, from 33,573 to 35,461, about the same number as in 2020. It doesn't seem like a completely drastic drop but definitely not insignificant.
- sct202 3y agoPostdocs are such a scam role. These are PHD educated scientists who have spent 4+ years on PHD getting paid like $50k-$70k/year with basically dead end jobs where they must leave to another place to get a tenure track role since they're already considered 2nd class at the institution the postdoc is at.
- nextworddev 3y agoI’m guessing one big driver is fewer professor jobs open
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoYeah the competition for those professor jobs is pretty fierce. Don’t you basically have to do a postdoc to be considered for a tenure track position in the States these days (unless you are some prodigy)?
- nextworddev 3y agoYeah, a major reason that people do post docs is to pad their research credentials and network, but that’s pointless if there are no academic jobs open. The main problem is tenure model.
- aiisjustanif 3y ago> getting paid like $50k-$70k/year with basically dead end jobs $50 - 70k would be nice, but we’ve seen lower in some states
- etrautmann 3y agoThis has been going up a bunch in the last few years thankfully, but not by enough to make it livable for people with children or in high cost of living areas.
- raverbashing 3y agoReally Search on YT (as an example) what's the outlook on postdocs for most people on the academic world (some notable Exceptions can be Found though)
- COGlory 3y agoI made $16,800 a year while getting my PhD. Sometimes that required me to teach, when we had funding, it was just research. Grueling hours, abusive PI, for 6 years of my life. I helped bring in over 4 million dollars in grants to my university. After about two years, I was highly skilled and founded a new core facility that I kept running for the next 4 years while finishing my PhD. When I graduated, I had someone offer me $42,000/yr for a postdoc. At age 30. I politely declined and took an industry job for $125k instead. We don't need H1Bs. We need better PhD student and postdoc wages.
- alephnerd 3y ago> We don't need H1Bs. We need better PhD student and postdoc wages. You need both. Your PhD classmates from abroad (most likely Russia, China, Korea, and India) would have gotten an H1B after they graduated from the PhD program, and their (edit: post-) postdoc employment would have been on an H1B. I'm assuming this was the late 1990s or early 2000s based on the numbers provided One of my friends who did their PhD and postdoc at Stanford has been facing the J1 to H1B hellhole because employers increasingly make the applicant pay for the entire O-1 process now. They decided to screw the whole process and return to China.
- ta988 3y agoUntrue the vast majority of foreign postdocs are on J1
- alephnerd 3y agoAnd until the late 2000s, if those postdocs wanted a private sector job in the US they needed an employer to sponsor their H1-B. Also, the J-1 didn't become the primary route for postdocs until the early 2000s
- BobaFloutist 3y agoOr maybe people who have dedicated half a decade to getting an education and/or working in the US in highly skilled, advanced knowledge positions should have a path to residency so they're not the mercy at their employer for the rest of their life. Just a thought.
- jyu 3y agoit's like individuals are choosing based on market incentives or something.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoHere's an excellent video about this problem from a first-person perspective. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mExlPihH3jk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mExlPihH3jk
- humansareok1 3y agoCompletely unsurprising. Why get a postdoc position with wages near minimum wage, long working hours, high stress all for a small chance at a vanishing number of Tenure Track jobs when Industry pays literally 10x more in some cases with vastly better work life balance and work that is often frankly more impactful and interesting. Someone working as a postdoc sends a significant anti-signal in my opinion.
- gnfedhjmm 3y ago[dead]
- Zandikar 3y agoI used to want to be an astrophysicist or something similar in pursuit of understanding high energy/quantum/cosmic phenomenon and generally trying to do my small part in furthering our understanding of spacetime and the universe. However, The horror stories of getting a PhD and general complaints regarding the nature of academic research are a significant part of what lead me to change course and take an early exit from academia, and generally dissuaded me from that pursuit. The PhD's (Students and graduates) I talked to were all saying the same thing about terrible pay, terrible treatment, terrible grueling grinding hours, begging for funding that could fall through and sink your project no matter your merits or efforts or attempts to prevent it, the publish or perish culture, etc etc etc At first I thought they were just jaded or cynical and I was just talking to the wrong people, or perhaps the local uni was just atypically bad in someway, but as I branched out and asked more people from more institutions I kept hearing the same thing pretty much universally. I heard it then (over a decade ago) and I hear it still now. I'm sure there are exceptions, but of the many I've talked to, few feel it was worth it, and every single one agree it was a grueling grind regardless. And I fully understand that few things worth doing come easy, and that discipline and persistence can be valuable "rewards" in their own right (started my own business, more than once), but on the same token, that doesn't mean things need be so difficult or detrimental, nor does it mean that the process can't be improved or modified in some way so that it doesn't so mercilessly beat people down. Guess that's a long winded way of me saying: yeah, no shit. It can and should be better, and am not the least bit surprised it's on the decline. How bad does it have to get before there's a serious, genuine effort to fix it? Additionally, if there is such an effort underway, what is it and how can I contribute?
- madsbuch 3y agoIt always gives me a bad taste when large institutions problematisize their recruitment efforts. the is equally the case for nurses, teaches and the military. This is a very conscience decision by the democracy that has funnelled money elsewhere. if nothing else, you can be surprised that these effects have been so slow. power to the people is, in this case, taking the better deal. work in the industry for double the salary (and still get to publish). People will move back to academia when the deal is on par (eg. more freedom to research the subject you find interesting?)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- __loam 3y agoWell yeah they're a scam.
- game_the0ry 3y agoEric Weinstein has been complaining about this for a long time. [1] Probably a result of the monopoly + monoculture of the higher education system. Universities love taking advantage of their postdoc and phd candidates. Thankfully, industry sometimes compensates the ones who justify higher market value. [1] Listen to almost any bog podcast he has done.
- tombert 3y agoI think it's particularly bad in the US. When I was looking to get a PhD here, I emailed a ton of professors asking if it was possible to do the PhD part time so I could keep my job, and most of them just didn't get back to me, and the ones that did acted like what I suggested was a completely ridiculous proposition. On the other hand, when I looked at UK universities, every professor I emailed got back to me, and while not all of them were amenable to part time remote PhDs, all of them did know someone who was and was happy to forward my request over and they actually did! I'm not 100% sure why the UK seems to be a little less horrible on this front, because eventually I was able to get into a a PhD program with the express understanding that it's part time, and I have a regular job.
- sneed_chucker 3y agoObviously the solution is to pay them competitively. But universities seem to reserve the good salaries for superfluous administrative staff and other dead weight business school positions. But then again, who gets to write the budget and set salaries.
- tombert 3y agoI am a bit weird, because I have a regular software engineering job while also doing a part time PhD. I love my advisors, and I think the work I'm doing is pretty cool, but when my advisors asked if I was considering doing a postdoc after I finish the the PhD, I had to figure out a polite way to tell them "absolutely not". I know not everything is about money, but fundamentally a regular industry job is just going to pay categorically better than nearly anything in academia. It's one thing for me to do the PhD for nights and weekends while taking home a yuppie software engineering salary because I want to formalize my "learning for fun", it's another for me to dedicate myself full-time to continuing the research for peanuts. It honestly kind of feels like a scam from universities; by definition, nearly anyone with a technical PhD is qualified for decent-paying work in industry, so the fact that universities pay so little for post-docs is borderline-insulting. Bit of a personal anecdote on this: I've not done a post-doc, but I used to work for a relatively prestigious private university in NYC as a "research scientist" [1]. I put "research scientist" in quotes, because that was my official title, but my work largely boiled down to software engineering, mostly JavaScript and a bit of Haskell. In 2015, I was being paid $90,000/year, which may seem like a lot of money until you realize that it's NYC; taxes and cost of living are pretty high. The university refused to pay any of my moving expenses, and they barely paid any of my health insurance (basically the bare minimum they were allowed to with the ACA). For perspective, most entry-level software engineering jobs in NYC at the time were paying at least $120,000 even at startups, and big organizations were paying more like $130,000, and I wasn't entry level. I had been a senior-level engineer at my previous job in Dallas. Upon moving to NYC, and starting my job, and having a fiance (now wife) that wasn't able to work at the time due to some visa issues, I was having a lot of trouble making ends meet, and I was having trouble paying rent [2] and medical bills. After three straight months of having to borrow money from my parents to cover my bills, I talked to the management team for the project I was working on, trying to explain to them that I was having a lot of trouble holding my head above water, I had maxed out my credit card moving to NYC and that they were paying well below market rates, so I would really just like an advance to at least avoid paying huge amounts of interest since they hadn't covered any relocation expenses. Instead, I got a long, indignant response explaining how important the work they were doing was, and then told me that I should be grateful for even having the job, and that I was already being paid higher than [other person on team] who had been there longer, so I'll just need to figure things out myself. It really rubbed me the wrong way, because they acted like I was living this life of luxury when I felt like I was barely surviving, and they treated me like I was fucking Gordon Gecko for simply Googling "market rate for software engineers in NYC". I eventually got laid off from that job (really fired, long story), and sort of swore an oath that I would never rely on academia as my primary source of income ever again. I've still done work for universites since then (I was an adjunct lecturer for a public university for about a year), but I always made it clear to them that I will be doing work for a private employer as my primary income. A part of me loves academia, but they can be the embodiment of the "this is more than a job, it's a family" employer red flag. [1] It's not hard to find my work history, so feel free to figure out which university with some clever searching, but I politely ask that you don't post it here. [2] Before you give me a lecture, I wasn't trying to rent a luxury apartment in Greenwich Village, it was a pretty crappy apartment in Washington Heights infested with mold and mice. It cost me $2100/month in 2015.