5 ms·
Younger Generations Have Larger Brains. Is That Healthier?
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoIt's not healthier, but that's the selective pressure, and if AI doesn't cause some catastrophic shift in society where we become its mindless appendages, the trend will continue. Evolution is almost never graceful. You gain more in one department and you suffer in the rest. It's like pets. They're fluffy, come in all colors, shapes and moods, but they very, very sick, especially compared to any wild animal out there. We have the ability to guide our evolutionary process (again much like we do with the plants and animals we interact with) but it's considered a taboo. When we refuse explicit control, there's still an implicit control. Someone always selects. If we reject an intelligent system, then an unintelligent system does the selection. If all else fails, it's random chance.
- bglazer 3y ago“The study imaged the brains of more than 3,000 Americans, between the ages of 55 and 65, and found that those born in the 1970s have a 6.6 percent greater overall brain volume than those born in the 1930s.“ 40 years is not a relevant timescale for evolution. Like it’s simply not possible for population scale changes to occur at a genetic level in one generation.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThat is true. But it also can be faster than people realize. Everyone says "it takes millions of years". When really, you can start seeing genetic differences in just 5 generations.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoYou can measure changes from one gen to next. Selection occurs with EVERY generation. Small or big depends on the selection.
- bglazer 3y agoThere are two explanations here: 1. We got richer and thus got better medical care, better food, cleaner conditions. Education got better and longer. Thus, brains grew slightly bigger. 2. Some other phenomena (?) occurred that caused a one-generation selective pressure event that culled the lower end of the brain size distribution from the population, or increased the number of high brain size individuals. I know which of these theories seems plausible and grounded in observable facts, and which one sounds like a just-so story designed to justify eugenics.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoYou started very well listing two theories. Where you went wrong is being immediately sure one is wrong and one is right (maybe both are wrong or both are right), being sure which is right, and excluding the possibility for more explanations, by delving into the study and how it controls for variables you hinted at. All in all, good start, but be less certain, more open-minded and pay more attention to details. I have no opinion about eugenics, other than obviously it's extremely likely it'll go wrong in the current political and cultural climate. But genes are genes, and they define us and they're constantly in flux. To reject that is basically cult-like thinking that wants to reject basic scientific knowledge in favor of some theory of morality that sets taboo on topics that are beyond discussion. I'm not a big fan of cults. They make us stupid and strive to keep us stupid. Smart is better.
- bglazer 3y agoYeah ok, open mindedness is lovely. Cults bad, got it. Which genetic variants were selected out of the population (in one generation), and how did they lead to decreased brain size?
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoYou said "got it" but your response clearly suggests otherwise. I have no conclusions about how the particular study was concluded and what exactly it found (although there have been many studies and throughout history we've lost and gained and lost again brain mass, depending on circumstances). I said selection forcing a bigger brain would come with compromises for our health. And that noticeable changes from one generation to the next are quite plausible with strong selection bias. I said technology is cornering us and we'll be struggling to provide value unless we can compete. That's all I said. And it's all scientifically sound. Unfortunately you keep coming back to fight, seemingly, a Nazi eugenist, or whatever shallow delusion you're stuck with. I told you to pay more attention to details. This includes reading carefully what people say before you hit reply and blurt out some knee-jerk reaction. Find a better hobby, be useful to somebody for something. Time's short.
- zug_zug 3y agoThis is a garbage article, wtf am I reading. Is it saying that irrespective of your current age, your birth year can predict an 8% variation in the mass of your brain (with no effect on skull size)? Or is it saying that older people have less mass in their brains (loss of grey matter with aging has been known about for decades at this point right)? If the first one, that's way too much to explained by evolution within generations and there'd be no reason to presume it's benign at this point. It'd likely be either explained by some environmental issue either now or with past brains.
- greenhearth 3y agoBring on telepathy and telekinesis!
- olesya1979 3y ago[dead]
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoEvolution at work? morlocks and eloi? Are the morlocks the ones inside on the computers and devices not getting sunlight? And their brains get bigger? eloi are outside laying in the sun and watch a lot of reality TV?
- lkrubner 3y agoThis article, in part, overlaps with what we know about the Flynn Effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect I'm not saying that the larger brain definitely explains the increase in IQ, but that is certainly a possibility worth exploring.
- karaterobot 3y agoOne thing we know about the Flynn effect is that it plateaued in most places decades ago, and has been reversing in many places for a while. The same Wikipedia article you linked discusses it in a few places, including here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect#Possible_end_of_progression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect#Possible_end_of_p...
- legacynl 3y agoIf you account for differences in genetics and upbringing, then brain size has a correlation with intelligence. But it's only slight and other factors seem to be more predictive, like genetics and upbringing. Also it has not been established if bigger brains results in higher intelligence, or that higher intelligence results in a bigger brain. Although nobody fully can explain why the Flynn effect occurs, we do know that there is no single cause, and it's therefor not possible for an increase in brain size to explain the Flynn effect.
- tgv 3y agoNot even Flynn believed the effect was real.
- indigochill 3y agoThat's super correlation vs causation, but also the explanation there seems straightforward to me: regardless of what IQ is or if it even exists, if you produce a standardized test that those who succeed in will be given (all other things being equal) better soecioeconomic outcomes, and it becomes a cultural institution over generations, then it's hardly surprising that you'll produce generations that progressively score better on the standardized test than previous generations, because that's what the society has been optimizing for by way of what it's rewarding. It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with intelligence (and this seems to bear with decreasing IQ results in Finland since last I heard they're not big on standardized tests there even though their practical education output is strong relative to other countries). For comparison, ancient Jewish religious leaders memorized significant amounts of the Torah and culturally Torah memorization filled essentially the role that IQ does for modern western society (everyone wants to score favorably, and those who do extra well get special perks). Was it that their brains were physically wired for better memorization? Or was it that it became a cultural reward mechanism that promised socioeconomic rewards (status and wealth) which motivated generations upon generations to optimize for memorizing the Torah? Admittedly we haven't quite reached the point of singing geometry puzzles to each other, but give it another few hundred years (or read Anathem ;)).
- Amorymeltzer 3y agoThe actual study: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaneurology/fullarticle/2816798 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaneurology/fullarticle/2... It's a study of 3226 people born between the 1930s and 1970s, and the size difference holds up, they say, regardless of sex and height (height has increased over the generations as well). The theory for "healthier" is, to quote: >We hypothesize that larger brain volumes indicate larger brain development and potentially greater "brain reserve" that could explain the declining incidence of dementia as previously reported. As for why, they state: >While ICV and brain size are under substantial genetic influence, the timeline of effect found with our results indicates that early life environmental influences are more likely contributors. Life course perspectives emphasize the impact of early life experiences on brain health that also translate into larger brain structures and reduced risk for later-life dementia through improved reserve. Similarly, efforts to improve cardiovascular health during adulthood that occurred over the time duration of this study are associated with reduced incidence of cognitive impairment and dementia, indicating that modifying these factors could also serve to improve resistance to late-life dementia. No mentions of lead. ---- Interesting headline note: the UCD press release (<https://health.ucdavis.edu/welcome/news/headlines/human-brains-are-getting-larger-that-may-be-good-news-for-dementia-risk/2024/03 https://health.ucdavis.edu/welcome/news/headlines/human-brai...>) writes "That may be good news for dementia risk" whereas this write-up writes "Is That Healthier?"
- Amorymeltzer 3y agoThe really interesting thing to me from TFA was the reference to a 2020 study (<https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.0000000000010022 https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.0000000000010022>) that showed that "[o]ver the past 30 years, the incidence of dementia has declined an average of 13% every decade in people of European ancestry living in the U.S. or Europe..." (<https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/dementia-incidence-declined-every-decade-for-past-thirty-years/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/dementia-in...>). I didn't know that! Of course: >Currently, 47 million people worldwide live with dementia. Due to the rapidly aging population, the number of people living with the disease is expected to triple over the next 30 years, as is the expected socioeconomic burden associated with dementia. Astoundingly terrible, but I had no idea it was decreasing in incidence. That's at least some light in the dark.
- melling 3y agoI would hope that within 30 years (2055), we’ll have effective treatments. Of course, 25 years ago, I would have thought modern medicine would have advanced more by now It would be cheaper to cure the disease than treat the symptoms in all the people who are going to suffer from the disease.
- lebuffon 3y ago"It would be cheaper to cure the disease..." <pessimist> Cheaper would also mean less revenue generated by ongoing symptom control medication. (Asthma inhalers for example: ~$13.4B global 2021, CAGR=20% !!) There is less business incentive these days to prevent or cure disease from what I can see. We have prevented a lot of the really big diseases that scared the hell out of people in history. (with some notable exceptions) Today a cured person is a lost consumer to a pharmaceutical company. The only solution to that issue, that I know of, is some form of government incentive to artificially subvert the natural market pressure but that is distasteful in free-market countries and money "invested" in political campaigns can "motivate" politicians to steer clear of those waters. </pessimist>
- 3y ago
- causi 3y agoIsn't this just reflective of the fact babies with larger heads are less likely to die in childbirth now than they were in the past? Due to increasing use of c-sections?
- forinti 3y agoCould be that plus better nutrition and overall better childcare.
- dhosek 3y agoI suspect that we probably reached the peak of that effect decades ago though. With increased environmental degradation (ubiquitous microplastics, more processed food in the diet, etc.) I suspect we’ve begun a long downward slide decades ago.