3 ms·
I tried it on one of my own tunes: https://lamucal.ai/songs/adrian-holovaty/adrian-holovaty-the-aching-waltz https://lamucal.ai/songs/adrian-holovaty/adrian-ho
by adrianh 3y ago
I tried it on one of my own tunes:
https://lamucal.ai/songs/adrian-holovaty/adrian-holovaty-the-aching-waltz https://lamucal.ai/songs/adrian-holovaty/adrian-holovaty-the...
The beats/chords were consistently a full beat off, and the chords were probably only 50% right. I chose this tune because (to my ears) the harmony is pretty clear.
Compare this to my own manually created transcription of the same tune, and it's night-and-day difference:
https://www.soundslice.com/slices/tpbwc/ https://www.soundslice.com/slices/tpbwc/
Beat detection and chord detection are hard problems, likely due to a lack of diverse training data. Chordify (another site that does this, which has been around for ages) has roughly similar performance.
Full disclosure: I run Soundslice, a website built around synced sheet music, in which there's no automatic transcription involved (maybe someday, but the tech isn't good enough yet!). I've been following these developments for 15+ years.
- rrherr 3y agoAdrian, I made a Google Colab notebook to try a different beat detection algorithm with your tune. The results sound pretty good to me! You can listen here: https://colab.research.google.com/drive/1Pqgc9s-nBKxU_3Ap6K0rXhkIwNviaZle?usp=sharing https://colab.research.google.com/drive/1Pqgc9s-nBKxU_3Ap6K0...
- herogary 3y agoThanks for your feedback. We're currently in the process of adjusting our dataset and model to address issues with chords and rhythm. We're looking forward to providing you with a better experience in the future.
- luckydata 3y agosounds like your site could be a great training set, someone should reach out to you sounds like a good business opportunity.