6 ms·
Neorg – organize your life in Neovim
- ashton314 3y agoAre there docs that I can read? Seems like several links are broken on the README.
- b33j0r 3y agoOh the projects we wouldn’t share until they were perfect. I’m going to give this one some chance. Aren’t we all dreaming of this? (No offense emacs, love you). But I do have the same question. Docs. Can we help?
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoSharing anything is better than sharing nothing, but it is worth keeping in mind that how useful other people will find it is directly based on how quickly they can figure it out and use it.
- cogman10 3y agoIt's not a terribly young project (~2 years old) so you might expect a bit more maturity around the docs. I installed it prior to this hn post and it works, but is a bit hard to discover what you can do with it.
- tinycombinator 3y agoI tried clicking on "Usage Modules" but it seems like it's not in there yet. The documentation seems to be an incomplete item on their roadmap: "Develop and ship a Neorg landing page with documentation, presumably with docasaurus." https://github.com/nvim-neorg/neorg/blob/main/ROADMAP.md https://github.com/nvim-neorg/neorg/blob/main/ROADMAP.md
- jasonjmcghee 3y agoThis seems like what they have https://github.com/nvim-neorg/neorg/wiki https://github.com/nvim-neorg/neorg/wiki
- draxil 3y agoSo org-mode for vim I think? I expect that's nice if you don't like emacs for some strange reason :D (and indeed object to setting up evil mode). My curiosity is dampened by it not really explaining on the wiki very well and trying to force me to watch a video.
- Zambyte 3y agoIt seems to be heavily inspired by Org, but not exactly the same. I skimmed through the first video (that seems to be the only documentation they have?) and at least the hyperlinking was different.
- happy-dude 3y agonvim-orgmode [1] is also available. Knowledge from emacs orgmode should carry over without much issue. I didn't feel like there was a need to reinvent the wheel like neorg does when there were powerful notetaking solutions available; does anyone have a comparison breakdown of features and capabilities? [1] https://github.com/nvim-orgmode/orgmode https://github.com/nvim-orgmode/orgmode
- lawn 3y agoI started using Neorg for my personal notes, but I found it really difficult to adapt to the markup language. It's silly I know, but I vastly prefer writing in markdown and it's relatives than in Neorg (or org mode for that matter). It was also weird that they chose to be incompatible with org mode, ditching all tooling around it in the process.
- fileeditview 3y agoSame for me. I just use vimwiki with markdown as doc format. Works great for me. If you have simple needs I can recommend
- rwdf 3y agoSame, but I use wiki.vim. Great for daily journalling.
- BeetleB 3y agoI find the org mode keybindings fairly ergonomic in Emacs, which is one reason I prefer org mode. Did they not migrate the keybindings to Neorg? Especially the use of Alt-Ret and TAB cycling...
- fwip 3y agoI've been using zk-nvim[0], it works well enough for me and uses Markdown. [0]: https://github.com/zk-org/zk-nvim https://github.com/zk-org/zk-nvim
- packetlost 3y agoThe fact that the markup language isn't even remotely similar to Markdown is a non-starter for me.
- iLemming 3y agoEven though I use Vim I never used Neorg. I suppose they use the same markup as in Org-mode. Org-mode is far more superior than Markdown. Again, I don't know about Neorg, but Org-mode in Emacs supports tons of interesting things that don't exist in Markdown, - things like "smart" datetime stamps where you can calculate the difference between dates, change the date and it would automatically adjust the day of week, or pick a date using the calendar UI; - it supports time clocking - you can for example use pomodoro to automatically clock you in and out for each task, and then later build a time report, showing you how much time you spent on each task; - priorities and tags; habit tracking and task management; - tables that you can use like spreadsheets in Excel - can you do calculations in your Markdown tables?; - embedded LaTeX snippets - indispensable if you need formulas and stuff; - exporting to many different formats - e.g., you can easily turn your notes into a reveal.js presentation; And of course code blocks. But not just static code blocks, you can run them and see the results. Moreover, you can for instance run some curl command, pipe the results into a javascript code block, then results of that calculation pipe into a python block and finally into some other backend that generates a graph. In addition, there are tons of plugins you can use for example to automatically git commit your notes. Or have Zettelkasten system like in Roamresearch, Loqseq or Obsidian. You can keep your pdf annotations that automatically sync with the book, or keep notes to a codebase, where each note correlates to specific file, line or function in your code. Or you can manage your Anki cards to help you retain information - your notes and the anki cards would be the same, you wouldn't have to store and maintain the same info in two different places. So, my suggestion is that before dismissing any tool that doesn't look very familiar to you or the majority of your peers, maybe first try to understand why some people choose to use that tool, even though it seems to contradict more popular choice.
- ChilledTonic 3y agoNo, Neorg does not use the same markup as Org-mode. They use their own specification that is specifically designed to be different from Org-mode spec. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nvim-neorg/norg-specs/main/1.0-specification.norg https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nvim-neorg/norg-specs/main... Furthermore, each item you have listed as a benefit to Org-mode is in fact capable of being done in Markdown via plugins for neovim, and probably other markdown editors, like Loqseq, Roamresearch, or Obisidian, much in the same way you speak of plugins that interface with .org docs. https://github.com/wthollingsworth/pomodoro.nvim https://github.com/wthollingsworth/pomodoro.nvim https://github.com/Myzel394/easytables.nvim https://github.com/Myzel394/easytables.nvim https://github.com/vimwiki/vimwiki https://github.com/vimwiki/vimwiki So, my suggestion is that before dismissing a comment regarding a plugin that is unfamiliar to you, is to read its spec, and then try to understand why people would be perhaps dismissive of that tool, especially when it chooses to conflict with existing, more popular choices.
- VTimofeenko 3y agoI gave this project and nvim-orgmode honest tries about a year ago but ultimately went back to Emacs even though I only use it for org mode and email these days. There's just too many org-adjacent packages already written in elisp. Plus, terminal independent image rendering just works in Emacs.
- ChilledTonic 3y agoI appreciate the idea of having an org-mode equivalent in Vim, but man do the docs suck for this project. Lots of broken links, very hard to discover how to actually hit the ground running. I hate this trend of having video explainers before having actually functional docs. I have no interest in watching someone fumble around a Youtube video when I could alternatively just Ctrl+F a docs page and find the information I need. For anyone interested, there are alternatives that are more Markdown compatible. Vimwiki, as an example, is great. https://github.com/vimwiki/vimwiki https://github.com/vimwiki/vimwiki
- melodyogonna 3y agoI thank Neorg for making me learn about Obsidian.
- gxonatano 3y agoWait until you hear about org-roam.
- tmerse 3y agoThere also is obsidian.nvim [1] if you want to mix and match obsidian and neovim for using/editing obsidian vaults. 1: https://github.com/epwalsh/obsidian.nvim https://github.com/epwalsh/obsidian.nvim
- Ringz 3y agoI use this combination for months and can recommend it.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Neorg – Life Organization Tool Written in Lua for Neovim - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29330805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29330805 - Nov 2021 (5 comments) Neorg: Neovim 0.5’s answer to modern life organization - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27802153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27802153 - July 2021 (72 comments)
- lilboiluvr69 3y agoAnybody know how this compares to org-mode? Specifically in terms of a customizable agenda?
- Nijikokun 3y agoThink Obsidian for neovim It has it's own language (not markdown) and key bindings I find it harder to use than markdown with wiki link support
- ShitHNDorksSay 3y ago[flagged]
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoI'd really like to see what the value proposition is over org-mode first and foremost. Yes it runs on Neovim (is it exclusive to Neovim?), but vim-orgmode is a thing. From watching the videos, the guy mentions that a problem early on was that it was constantly compared to org-mode, which was confusing to people not familiar with org-mode, so I guess they're trying to get away from that? I watched a few videos and saw syntax and features almost identical to the most basic level of org-mode. The one feature it seems to have over org is that it uses a C++ based parser, which might be faster than the mostly elisp parser from org-mode? But even that means it relies on features of C++14, which isn't included with macOS, so I'm left feeling like this is half anti-feature compared to org-mode's highly portable parser: If Emacs works, org-mode will work, and Emacs is mostly elisp itself, so if the elisp interpreter works, Emacs will work. If I can run an executable I can run org-mode essentially, but this requires I'm allowed to install a whole new compiler on a machine before using it. I think it was Prot that put forward a strong case for building an org-mode specification with multiple compatibility levels, so that tools for other platforms could say they implement a certain subset of its features and syntax using a simple shorthand like "Org-Mode Level 3 Compatible". I'd like to see that effort go further.