3 ms·
> I can just pay No, you've mis-identified the problem as "the punishment is only a single sum of money." What actually makes it ineffective is "it's a fixed
by Terr_ 3y ago
> I can just pay
No, you've mis-identified the problem as "the punishment is only a single sum of money."
What actually makes it ineffective is "it's a fixed sum which some people (like me) are rich enough to casually ignore". Compounded by "infrequent enforcement."
The truth of this is easy to illustrate: Simply imagine that instead of a ~$100 fine every ~5 years, the missing plate was detected every week and the fine compounded by +5% each time until it reached 10% of your wages. It's technically still "just money"... but would your behavior be the same?
- Brian_K_White 3y agoJust raises the bar. It's still a penalty that doesn't relate to the misdeed, and hurts different people differently. The problem is we use money as a form of pain, because that is one facet of it, money can sure hurt, but taking money from one person is like taking away a finger or a leg, decimating their ability to function at all things in life, and then everyone punishes that person even more, now for not being a productive contributing member of society. Meanwhile another person can supply "fingers" all day and not be even inconvenienced let alone handicapped. But taking money as a form of pain appeals to assholes, and funds their organizations, win-win!
- Terr_ 3y ago> Just raises the bar. Uh, yeah, because you claimed it was a fundamentally weak bar people could walk though. I raised it to illustrate you were actually stepping over it instead. > It's still a penalty that doesn't relate to the misdeed They are literally related by cause and effect. Trying to force some broader poetic Hammurabi-style connection is a non-starter, since it means my overdue library book would require a local librarian to break into my home and seize one of my own books as a hostage. As amusing as that sounds, the abstraction of an overdue-book fine is wayyyy more practical and easier to do in a just and proportionate way. (Especially if all the books I have are from other libraries.) > hurts different people differently Which is why fines should be scaled better, like I said in my last post, rather than being fixed sums that some can ignore, like you described in yours. > The problem is we use money as a form of pain Anything the transgressor doesn't like is going to be a form of "pain", the least we can do is use something which is both (A) adjustable and (B) reversible.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoPerhaps the problem is that we us the same money for both necessities and luxuries. It allows assholes to decide to see everything as a luxury that someone they don't like doesn't deserve. There is nothing about a traffic infraction that requires money as the penalty, instead of say, an annoying class or community service, or limiting their use of a vehicle to work or school, which is a thing that is done sometimes. Money is just easy for the administrator at the (no pun) expense of the subjects. That's a shit reason to do something that way. But the majority of the rule-makers and system-designers are people that this setup doesn't harm. What a strange coincidense! That right there blows all these crybaby excuses how it would just be so hard to even try to think of anything else right out of the water.