7 ms·
Interview with Bluesky CEO Jay Graber
- scudsworth 3y agoanother beautiful confirmation that there's no reason at all for bluesky to exist that actually might matter to users
- jrm4 3y agoSo, I think Bluesky has it wrong and the Mastodon model is still better (theoretically, of course, I have no idea how to make this more popular) ; which is to say -- there are no huge advantages and probably tons of pitfalls when you try to do "one universal identifier that sticks forever" for people. We already have a better working model for this; it's HOW WE DO EMAIL. On one hand, email is a very strong "centralized identity" thing, and on the other it's not absolute. Yes, it has problems, but as twitter has shown -- deeply centralizing the thing has MORE problems.
- wilg 3y agoThe core problem with Mastodon and AT Protocol is that they are just codifying the user experience of Twitter and therefore locking in that design. We need to be exploring the space of what is possible in social media, not doubling down on a known broken design. Twitter was not particularly popular compared to other social media apps, and the core design has a ton of problems.
- halfmatthalfcat 3y agoI still think we haven’t seen the “what’s next” in social. I think all these completing protocols are barking up the right tree but they seem to be a bridge to the next thing, not the next thing in and of itself.
- jareklupinski 3y agoi still can't ping my friend and say 'hey check out this thing im watching on my screen right now', unless we're all on exactly the same ecosystems, and i send the correct link, and we're all logged in, and the engineer that day remembered to put the right meta headers in, and our credit cards haven't expired...
- zubairq 3y agoInteresting, maybe a system to send content to a friend instantly via text message is a product in its own right. I guess you mean a private link though?
- naravara 3y agoThe technical side of it is a solved problem. Everything you look at is hosted on a web page. You get a URL that points to it. You send the URL to another person and they can reach it, maybe with some additional stuff for time-stamping and chapter breaks and such. For bonus stuff you can include some account management for each user to be able to interact with the content but it’s not necessary and doesn’t need to gate you just being able to watch the thing. The problem emerges when companies need to monetize the hosting and delivery of the content. It’s 100% a business model challenge, not a technical one.
- jareklupinski 3y agoyup my current most common method of 'socializing' digitally is me taking a screenshot of something interesting on my screen and sending it over some chat service (depending on who i am sending it to) if i could open a screen share session with a similar easy shortcut, and broadcast whatever i have open on my screen with my friends, regardless of where the pixels originated, with a full duplex link i could talk over / see my friends with, i think i'd have much more meaningful evenings
- squigz 3y agoThis is... dramatic, when things like watchparty exist, or you can use something like Discord...
- jareklupinski 3y agoi can't even get discord working for what its supposed to be good at: chatting with one friend while we play a multiplayer game together "can you hear me? I can hear you but not the game? ok now i can hear the game but not you? ok now i can hear the game bleeding through your mic? did you set up a virtual audio cable? is your mic patched through correctly?" every single time. sometimes i just want to scroll reddit with friends, or watch a part of a dvd with friends, or play pubg mobile with friends, but i dont want to break out a display splitter and ask them to log in to a centralized service and accept an endless barrage of cookie banners and "Do you accept our new terms?" checkboxes and watch ads just to watch some memes with me (after i spend 30 minutes figuring out how their API changed so i can keep streaming the way i figured out how to already do it without issues just last week) why cant i just send my pixels to my friends via bittorrent or some other protocol
- thisislife2 3y agoFederation is the future because politics demands it. As more and more social media platform turn into an intelligence gathering and an information warfare tool, countries around the world will make stricter laws to restrict the current American and Chinese owned BigTech moats of social media platform. We are already seeing this with new data privacy laws or stringent restriction or even outright banning of the platform (as China has done). This is a huge headache for American and Chinese government because such restrictions impairs their current online intelligence programs. The obvious solution is to partly sacrifice the profits of the BigTech to keep the data flowing. We'll soon find inter-operability being forced on platforms (like iMessage or WhatsApp). More "open" protocols will be pushed and standardised slowly to make it difficult to impose political restrictions and weaken privacy laws (because the message will be that BigTech are no longer in control, but "the people" and every government wants to spy on its citizens). Just look at email to realise how these things eventually end up - how many of you run your own email servers, and successfully ensure that your mails aren't bocked by "spam" services? Federation is good and necessary. But we are now decades past from the idea of "controlling our data".
- ein0p 3y ago“Turn into”? They were explicitly invented for surveillance and personal data mining. That’s their entire raison d’être.
- freedomben 3y agoI actually think it's exactly politics that will make federation impossible, with the exception of a few big players who have the deep pockets to fund major moderation. For those people (big tech), you're right interop will be mandatory. There's no way government are going to give up the control they have with big tech and companies that can be regulated and served warrants and stuff. The last thing they want is for individual decentralized citizens to be able to stand up their own systems and discuss dangerous ideas[1] without oversight. On top of that, big tech will be eager to push things like Web Environment Integrity[2] and Private Access Tokens[3] that can ensure that unapproved (or semi or fully anonymous) actors with dangerous operating systems like linux aren't allowed to participate, at least on a first-class level. It will be packaged as "anti-spam" or "a better user experience for our users" but the fact that it massively empowers the tech companies and enables them to further entrench you into their walled gardens will absolutely not be an opportunity they want to miss. [1]: The definition of dangerous ideas will depend on who and which party is in power. Unless the corporate overlords end up in control, in which case it will be what their managers consider dangerous. [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Environment_Integrity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Environment_Integrity [3]: https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=huqjyh7k https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=huqjyh7k
- mrweiner 3y ago$technology is the future of $industry, says CEO implementing $technology in $industry.
- dang 3y ago"Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- r14c 3y agoI honestly hope so. Having organizations like Meta or Twitter et al control massive sections of the social media landscape is not healthy. Any organization, group, or individual that wants to have an online presence should be able to spin up their own service and publish to any constellation of servers that want to hear what they have to say. I hope the EU efforts to push common standards are also applied to US companies in US markets to make all of the coms services federate like we were promised over a decade ago.
- luqtas 3y agoisn't better to have legal regulations on big servers? as i can see some abuse from hosts (that entered early it the game) & now hold multi-thousand users instance...
- ein0p 3y agoWho do you think writes the regulations in the US? The lobbyists. They are written mostly with the intent of creating regulatory capture and making life difficult for smaller players.
- r14c 3y agowhy not both? i recognize that large decentralized networks create some challenges, but imo that's still preferable to giving a small number of large (even heavily regulated) operators total control over the network.
- threeseed 3y agoMeta enabled ActivityPub based fediverse support this week for US Threads users. So today you can spin up your own Mastodon server and have anyone follow you from Threads and vice versa.
- zizee 3y agoWill they extend this to Instagram? Until then (and even after) I'd be suspicious of their intentions. Embrace, Extend, Extinguish. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extingu...
- stalfosknight 3y agoI'd like to see them actually make it so the common person can understand federation and see it as a plus rather than a confusing onboarding roadblock.
- Nextgrid 3y agoThey won't, because federation doesn't actually solve any of the problems the average social media user has, while introducing its own, (sometimes very hard/impossible) problems. The main driver behind current social media's shittiness is the user-hostile business model that means the incentives of the user and the platform are opposed. Federation doesn't actually address any of this, and currently the federated social media world "runs" on effectively charity. "Runs" in quotes because we've already seen instance shutdowns which caused a fair bit of trouble. It only currently "runs" because the scale is small enough that it can indeed be sustained by charitable efforts, and hasn't devolved into a unusable spam-fest because it's too small to actually be worth spamming. If your "solution" to social media shittiness is effectively turn it into something ran by charities, that's fine but you can achieve this much easier (and more efficiently) by just having one charity run one centralized service with an open API (since the business incentives around lock-in are no longer applicable).
- tiptup300 3y agoBack in jr high school we had halo modding forums that were hosted on free hosts until we had someone with money to pay for a server, until that ran out and we moved again. Some of those communities might go on and last a while and accumulate knowledge. Ah maybe not, sounds like a path the gamergate stuff. But the concept certainly feels nostalgic. And besides now I have a job and a small amount of extra cash to pay for a small community website. Would be nice to have federated reddits instead of reddit.
- DoItToMe81 3y agoWhat? What does Gamergate have to do with any of that? That's absolutely deranged and obsessed.
- s4mw1se 3y agoMaybe working in secuirty has screwed my vision because this stuff bounces around in my head all day. I think social media as we know it today is already at the end of the road. Our data has been obtained to make generative AI products and now we are entering a new phase of the internet. The social media we have has already been poisoned by assholes trying to make everyone addicted for money, or victims of non-kinetic warfare. There is going to be way to many self-managing sock puppets all with an agenda. Automated psyops agents left to their devices, all talking to each other and you. That’s not to say there won’t be sociable media, it’s just that regardless of how federated anything is we are all still going to constantly be in contact with AI. the next big social media platform will be the one that can guarantee the most authentic human connections. Until we get to that point, we will have what we have not and watch it get worse as smaller federated instances pop up that become selective or invite only. Not much different then private hidden services
- em-bee 3y agoisn't it possible to avoid all the problems by simply using these tools in a certain way? i am on whatsapp, wechat, telegram, matrix, signal, sms, irc, email, even discord... on each of these services i am mostly in contact with real humans that i met in person. i am in a few groups mostly made out of these same people, but also some groups where i never met anyone. i am not on facebook, mastodon or ex-twitter or any service that tries to feed me with stuff instead of just giving me a timeline of all messages shared. even on youtube i follow the channels of my choice and mostly ignore recommendations except to discover other interesting channels. i don't see any of that going away. therefore i don't see anything changing for me
- zizee 3y agoIt would be useful to categorise "social media" into "publish to strangers" vs "interact with individuals in private". Apparently these are both social media, but they are very different use-cases. Most of the apps you mentioned are focussed on that second category, whereas (I believe) the GP was talking about the first category.
- sandspar 3y agoI was wondering recently how much time I've spent arguing with bots online. Hours, surely. Dozens of hours? And it seems like it's going to get worse. The Reddit front page seems largely bot-run now. It's only a matter of time until it spreads.
- autonomousErwin 3y agoIf you could collate all these arguments and actually help you get better at debating then this could be turned into a positive where you shouldn't care about the person (AI or human) behind the argument but the argument itself.
- JohnFen 3y ago[dead]
- pests 3y ago> I was wondering recently how much time I've spent arguing [...] online. Probably all of it?
- resuresu 3y agoI got banned from the most popular mastadon server for simply correcting a guy about an indian tribe that he got wrong so yea doesn’t feel much different than the centralized web to me.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xnx 3y agoIf you don't control the url of your content (i.e. outsourcing it to a social network), you control nothing. All the other details of interface and interoperability can be worked out. If you can't redirect the traffic, you're out of luck.
- ashconnor 3y agoKept the site invite only during some turbulent times on Twitter. I think that strategy was a huge misfire.
- mattl 3y agoKept it up and operational and didn't make it immediately unpleasant or impossible to use during that time and allowed them to find a balance for moderation.
- dilyevsky 3y agoI think if there’s one thing that twitter proved decisively is that users dont actually care if the site is stable and bunch of things are jank
- CSSer 3y agoTheir user count and revenue has dropped like a rock. Obviously other factors are at play, but what decisive evidence is there? Even anecdotally I have to admit that I’ve clicked on Twitter links that unexpectedly failed to load and decided to hit the back button instead of trying to reload several times.
- dilyevsky 3y agoIm talking about the failwhale times mostly and there’s a bunch of bugs that go back a decade at this point
- mattl 3y agoBluesky has been refreshing better than Twitter in that respect
- evbogue 3y agoSecure-Scuttlebot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xcavier 3y agoI think the biggest issue with the decentralised crowd is they think their target market is their (technical) peers. Web publishing was a cul de sac until it went WYSIWYG. Dialup internet didn’t take off until the likes of AOL dumbed it down. Until the decentralisation experience becomes AOL simple, it will remain a backwater.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoFor decentralization to take off, I can absolutely see a company pushing it as a user-first, privacy-forward social media solution. Basically turning your own home computer (or a $100 device you keep plugged in at home), that operates as your server. You set up your profile and use a plugin and add-on store to basically build your own social network. Then share usernames with friends and family. The data stays in your own house and is accessible to those you grant access to. I'm not familiar with the ins and outs of decentralization yet, but I can totally see this being an angle companies to take. Especially as data privacy becomes even more important to people.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoFreedombox[0] has been a thing for 14 years, there are plenty of solutions for hosting services for yourself as someone technical, but they're not compelling to nontechnical folks who will have a fax machine with no one to fax. maybe it's a different story with activitypub and bluesky's AT protocol, but it's not as if decentralized social protocols are a new innovation, the market just isn't interested in "privacy" and "control" - those that do have already discovered they can get by without social media altogether (I say this as someone building a self hosted home server/appliance, but I think i'll promise more of a fireproof safe - not for keeping secrets, but for making sure you don't lose essential documents / family photos, and a home assistant that doesn't shout "I CANT CONNECT TO THE WIFI" when I ask it to switch a lamp off) [0] https://www.freedombox.org/ https://www.freedombox.org/
- notaustinpowers 3y agoI think the reason is because the technical is boring. It's gotta get wrapped up in pretty plug-and-play hardware, customization-forward (social feed that you design!), private (your data is stored right in your home!), etc. I think it could be aimed well at something like the livestreaming/Twitch/YT community, and build out from that base. Thanks for sharing Freedombox too, I've never heard of them before.