2 ms·
Is this going to become like that thing about airplanes on treadmills that move backward at the same speed as the plane, where everyone is 100% sure they have i
by ars 18y ago
Is this going to become like that thing about airplanes on treadmills that move backward at the same speed as the plane, where everyone is 100% sure they have it right?
I see the reasoning that if you walk on the treadmill you enjoy it's speed for less time - but that's not what you care about. You care about how long it takes you to get from the start of the treadmill to the end, and if you walk you get to the end faster.
So if you can walk 100 meters in 1 minute, and that's what you do on the treadmill, you will have covered an extra 100 meters in 1 minute.
Or you could cover that 100 meters on the ground, and it will also take you 1 minute.
The speed of the conveyor makes no difference - that is totally fixed, the only difference is do you cover that 100 meters on the conveyor or off of it.
I typed and rejected many examples to give you, but none were intuitive. So if it's this hard to explain then I'm 100% sure this is going to become like that airplane on a conveyor belt.
People are going to argue about this forever.
What is it about conveyor belts that makes it hard for people?
- ars 18y agoOK, the post below made it easier to me to explain: You can NOT add miles per hour to miles per hour. So you can not add the speed to walking to the speed of the belt. You need to do hours per mile + hours per mile. So the conveyor takes a certain number of hours for each mile, and you walking takes a certain number of hours for each mile. The length of the conveyor is fixed. So the number of hours the conveyor supplies is fixed - nothing you can do will change that. You can add in your hours per mile on it or off of it, it doesn't matter - it's exactly the same in total.
- greendestiny 18y agoWell like the airplane on the conveyor belt thing, there really is a right answer to this and you don't have it. This is a similar explanation to one of the comments on the blog: imagine one section of ground followed by one section of conveyor belt. Two people going exactly the same speed walk along the ground section and one stops just before the conveyor belt and one stops on the conveyor belt. They both stop for the same time. When they resume walking the one who stopped on the conveyor belt is ahead. No matter how many section of belt and ground follow this, the one behind will never catch up.
- ars 18y agoNo, that's not correct. You forgot that they both have to get off the conveyor belt at some point. The guy who got on first will then walk slowly, and the guy who got on second meanwhile will be both walking and being pulled forward by the conveyor belt, while the first guy is walking slowly. This will catch him up to the first guy. And if you tell me that the first guy is already walking so of course he's ahead, then you forgot that, for both of them to stop at the same time, and yet one be on the belt and one on the ground, the first guy must have had a head start. Better have two belts, one placed one meter ahead of the other. So, one guy will be walking for that meter, while the other will be riding the belt and walking, and both will reach the end at exactly the same time.
- greendestiny 18y agoIt's confusing alright. When the guy in the lead gets off the conveyor belt the distance between them will close. But the second guy won't catch up. The distance between them will vary according to speed but the time between them will stay the same.
- ars 18y agoI concede. You are right, it's better to pause on the belt. I thought about it all night, using edge cases, like a really slow walker, fast belt, etc.