2 ms·
Re-running experiments is out of scope for any reviewer. You're supposed to trust their data, but review that their conclusion is actually supported by the data
by adastra22 3y ago
Re-running experiments is out of scope for any reviewer. You're supposed to trust their data, but review that their conclusion is actually supported by the data, as shown.
- abhgh 3y agoYeah, I agree. But I said what I did to make the larger point that empirical studies are hard to vouch for without some level of trust on both sides. For ex if someone selects favorable datasets, metrics, "random" seeds, p-hacking etc.