3 ms·
You'll need to pick holes in: A 2015 report, “Land Requirements for Carbon-Free Technologies,” compared the land area that various types of electricity gen
by defrost 3y ago
You'll need to pick holes in:
A 2015 report, “Land Requirements for Carbon-Free Technologies,” compared the land area that various types of electricity generation facilities would require to produce the same amount of electricity as a 1,000-megawatt nuclear power plant in a year. The results highlight the exemplary performance reliability of nuclear energy facilities as well as the very high energy density of nuclear fuel.
A nuclear energy facility has a small area footprint, requiring about 1.3 square miles per 1,000 megawatts of installed capacity. This figure is based on the median land area of the 59 nuclear plant sites in the United States. In addition, nuclear energy facilities have an average capacity factor of 90 percent, much higher than intermittent sources like wind and solar.
https://www.nei.org/news/2015/land-needs-for-wind-solar-dwarf-nuclear-plants https://www.nei.org/news/2015/land-needs-for-wind-solar-dwar...
which also asserts that:
Wind farms require up to 360 times as much land area to produce the same amount of electricity as a nuclear energy facility, a Nuclear Energy Institute analysis has found. Solar photovoltaic (PV) facilities require up to 75 times the land area.
and other claims.
- Retric 3y ago> Wind farms require up to 360 times as much land area to produce the same amount of electricity Sure, look at this picture of corn growing between windmills. https://www.gasworld.com/story/wind-turbines-and-corn-fields-new-technology-for-carbon-to-fuel/ https://www.gasworld.com/story/wind-turbines-and-corn-fields... Gee I wonder how much land they are actually occupying. Or wowzers let’s talk about offshore wind farms… They’re using a definition that makes sense in one context and then applying it in a different context where it’s meaningless. Grid operators dislike base load power, the term is actually referring to a downside that it’s pricey to turn off. Now outside of that context it sure sounds great to pair with unreliable renewable energy. Except the downside still exists and you lose lots of money when you turn it off making it a terrible option when paired with renewable energy.
- defrost 3y ago> They’re using a definition that makes sense in one context and then applying it in a different context where it’s meaningless. Much as you yourself have down above where the amount of land owned by a company surrounding a nuclear plant is conflated to be the amount of land required by a nuclear plant. To be clear, I picture a hybrid energy future and can easily link to pictures of sheep grazing under solar panels - I can also link to pictures of large scale solar farms that directly place solar panels on the ground, and others that elevate the panels but have no dual use of the land. All in all area used is a bit of a side show.
- Retric 3y ago> Much as you yourself have down above where the amount of land owned by a company surrounding a nuclear plant is conflated to be the amount of land required by a nuclear plant. No, they own/control more land, this is specifically the amount used by the nuclear power plant. “It occupies 9,818 acres (39.73 km2) of the total 11,800 acres (4,800 ha) controlled by the owner.” The fenced off area patrolled by armed guards isn’t freely available for other uses. Believe me if they could sell off 5,000 acres to build a subdivision the company would happily pocket that money but no the land really is being used.
- defrost 3y ago> It occupies 9,818 acres is not the same as "it requires" ... One might ask why a 1977 nuclear plant that produces relatively low power has such a large security perimeter ... that is orthogonal to power production.
- Retric 3y agoRequired is a weasel word in infrastructure, there’s often more expensive alternatives but what matters is what’s actually built not what in theory could be. Build a nuclear submarine and the land use drops, except the costs go up it isn’t a viable option. In this case walls cost more money than an empty field, both give you time to shoot someone trying to cross them and they went with the cheapest option. Thus the land is in use and cannot be used for a city park or whatnot.
- defrost 3y agoOrthogonal to power generation. Why is that specific plant so far outside the norm and above the median for others? Why do other nuclear power generation plants 'require' so much less land? What makes Wolf so atypical? Why do you insist on using it as a "typical" case when it clearly isn't? Tell us more about weasel arguments.
- 3y ago