3 ms·
Right, but then your argument goes from "nuclear isn't more space-efficient than solar" to "in some rare cases, it's almost as bad as solar". Anyway, we probab
by stavros 3y ago
Right, but then your argument goes from "nuclear isn't more space-efficient than solar" to "in some rare cases, it's almost as bad as solar".
Anyway, we probably need both, and we definitely need to stop burning fossil fuels, so let's not disparage one in favor of the other.
- Retric 3y ago“Wind and geothermal are more space efficient than nuclear” I never argued that nuclear always lost to solar, I even suggested it should be able to use less land than your examples. I am arguing it never beats wind.
- stavros 3y agoFrom the data I can see (e.g. https://www.ourworldofenergy.com/vignettes.php?type=wind-power&id=9 https://www.ourworldofenergy.com/vignettes.php?type=wind-pow...), wind needs at least 30,000 acres per GW, a far cry from the nuclear 1,000 acres for 7 GW above.
- Retric 3y agoYou’re looking at the distance between turbines as if that land was useless for anything else. It’s not. Put a turbine in the on a 10,000 acre farm and you’ll still have a 9,999 acre farm. Put a nuclear reactor on that same land and you’ll be doing a lot less farming.