3 ms·
In general there are two ways for companies to make money. 1) They make something that otherwise wouldn't have been made, or make it more efficiently than the c
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
In general there are two ways for companies to make money. 1) They make something that otherwise wouldn't have been made, or make it more efficiently than the competition and then capture volume with lower prices. 2) Rent seeking; they extract higher profits from the same activity, e.g. by buying their competitors and raising prices.
Traders do the work of finding the companies that can do one of these things and allocating resources to them so they can do them. When it's the first one, the societal gains are quite significant. When it's the second one, well, there are supposed to be laws against that and if it's happening then we need better laws or better enforcement.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI'd argue for a third category where the new thing addresses a problem that the company themselves is making more problematic (e.g. TurboTax) or where "more efficiently" involves cases where costs to the company are exchanged for costs to society (e.g. petroleum companies, cambridge analytica). I think this category represents the majority of economic activity today, which is why I'm skeptical of markets being zero sum. The result is the same though: find was to get more of (1) and less of (2) and (3).
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe third thing is just the second thing. TurboTax lobbying to avoid free tax filing is obviously rent-seeking. It might even be more accurate to call this category rent seeking through regulatory capture. Fossil fuels would have been trounced by nuclear except that they lobbied to require nuclear to internalize all of its costs (and then some) but not their own, extracting undue rents by handicapping the competition. The closest you get to a third category is Cambridge Analytica, in which case the third category would be criminal enterprises. But these rarely remain listed on the stock market; you won't find shares of the Guadalajara Cartel at your brokerage. It's the companies in the second category that do, because they're doing things that should be illegal but aren't.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI was going for extreme examples to make the point, but look at any modern advertiser: their products are used to target segments of society such that we can be encouraged to either turn against one another or to make some kind of decision which is bad for us and good for whoever is doing the advertising. The perspective you're describing doesn't seem to have a way to classify this activity as unhelpful without going so far as making it illegal. Without that ability, I don't see how we can ever expect the market's notion of value to find itself in line with society's values. The best we can hope for is a random walk within the bounds of "illegal".
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThere are only a finite number of possibilities here. If you're stuck with a machine you don't like that shows you harmful advertising because it has no viable competitors, the problem is with the law, because it's propping up that institution or otherwise failing to enforce anti-trust laws. If that machine exists, even though there are plenty of viable competitors that don't do that, and then you freely choose that one on purpose, it's not obvious that the company is doing anything wrong. You apparently like that kind of advertising. The exception would be for some kind of information asymmetry, like the advertiser is lying to you and you don't find out until it's too late. In which case we're back to needing a law, in that case against false advertising. Now I can tell why you're choosing this one, because it's a sticky one: What happens when they're lying about politics? We can't have the government enforcing a law against "lying" about political issues, because the very thing that makes them political is that people disagree and don't find the other side's evidence to be credible. We can't have whoever is in power at any given time censoring the opposition. The solution we use for this is to put the determination in the hands of the public. The marketplace of ideas. If someone is full of crap, you prove them wrong in front of everybody, and then they lose credibility. This isn't perfect but it works pretty well in the absence of the aforementioned anti-trust problem. Because then instead of a handful of megasites that people get siloed into and fed content like livestock, you'd have a million blogs that intersect like the web. There would be no walls between sites, no way to prevent someone you're trying to mislead from hearing from the other side just because you're in with the site's operators, because none of the sites would be big enough to exercise that kind of power when the average person is getting their information from hundreds of separate sources instead of only one or two. Sometimes companies have bad incentives. Those either get curbed by laws, or by free market competition, or... what's your alternative?