4 ms·
It sort of makes seems reasonable in some vague and non-scientific sense that we’d be optimized for walking across slightly rough terrain (with logs, little str
by bee_rider 3y ago
It sort of makes seems reasonable in some vague and non-scientific sense that we’d be optimized for walking across slightly rough terrain (with logs, little streams, and rocks to amble across), rather than perfectly flat roads.
Dirt paths look nicer than sidewalks anyway, so I guess we’re just going to have to tear up the streets and stroads all together, rather than trying to staple on walkability!
- dieselgate 3y agoCheck out the book “Born to Run”
- BeetleB 3y agoBe a bit wary of that book. While I can't speak to its main thesis, people have found serious faults with claims about various cultures/groups having great health outcomes due to their walking. Apparently some of them have very poor health outcomes (perhaps unrelated to walking, but you get my point).
- mvdtnz 3y agoThe book is widely discredited and thankfully the barefoot running trend is behind us.
- nytesky 3y agoIs it having a resurgence or just never died? https://time.com/6284245/walking-barefoot-health-risks/ https://time.com/6284245/walking-barefoot-health-risks/
- emseetech 3y agoThat article seems entirely centered around the dangerous around cuts and bacteria, with no indication it's bad for muscle or bone. While some fundamentalists might go completely barefoot, I've always heard people talk about that book in terms of using light sole shoes instead of heavy shoes, not ditching protective footwear entirely. Even the subject of that book often wear thin moccasins during long distance runs.
- ghaff 3y agoNot really about thin soles, but from what I can tell, there's been a general shift among a lot of even hardcore hikers to trail shoes from boots. I have a delightful pair of custom-made leather boots that I basically don't wear any longer because they're so heavy.
- cam_l 3y agoI used to always go barefoot when bush walking as a kid in qld. Looking out for snakes and spiders (literally) keeps you on your toes. I remember once bushwalking with a group and there was a sudden torrential rainstorm, and you could see all the little leeches sticking their heads up from the mud. By the time we got back to the van, I was the only one without a single leech on me. I only ever had issues with cuts etc in town on the bitumen or gravel (but I suppose it could be quite dangerous in some parts of the world).
- ildjarn 3y agoIf the podiatrist in the article is to be believed, humanity never would have made it out of the Stone Age.
- ildjarn 3y agoBorn To Run is an adventure/travel book. I don’t know why people read it as pop sci.
- voisin 3y agoThe barefoot running trend is decidedly not behind us. There are more barefoot shoes (zero drop, wide toe box) from major shoe makers than ever, and you see them way more at races than in the past. What’s behind us, maybe, is the vibram 5 finger (each toe in its own slot) which seems to have waned in popularity significantly.
- fsloth 3y agoThe vibram ”5 finger” watersport model is brilliant shoe for swimming in natural lakes summer & winter (works even for ice swimming) but running in such a shoe is not something I would consider.
- malfist 3y agoFor what its worth, I ran many many many miles in my fivefingers and loved them. But I was a lot younger then, I prefer more cushioning on the balls of my feet, and I mostly walk anymore. My cardio of choice has moved to biking, it's just more fun (for me, YMMV)
- coldtea 3y ago>There are more barefoot shoes Now that's an oxymoron if I ever saw one! Though, in a certain way, shoes can be said to be barefoot from the start: they aren't wearing any shoes themselves.
- voisin 3y agoBarefoot Shoes is a common reference to shoes that have zero drop (flat between heel and forefoot), a wide toe box (there are a variety of benefits here) and relatively thin soles to enhance proprioception. So yes, while it sounds like an oxymoron, it is actually just an industry term of art (you’ll see major companies advertise certain of their shoes as barefoot - Merrell comes to mind with their VaporGlove and Trail Glove, both of which are fantastic shoes). The other nice thing about barefoot shoes (since I find myself in full on sales mode) is that due to the lack of padding, they last significantly longer than traditional mass market shoes. My trail runners (the Merrell’s) are in season 5 now, when my old trail shoes by Saucony lasted one season Max, and my mileage has increased substantially from when I used to wear the Saucony’s.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- npalli 3y agoA good rule of thumb is anything in social sciences that was very popular 15 years ago has been debunked (as others are claiming here). Is there a definitive takedown somewhere that someone can link please? Curious which portions don't hold up.
- pitherpather 3y agoGiven the current style, if the book were published today would it be titled BAREFOOT?
- agumonkey 3y agoI have to walk daily, and purely flat is nice at first but after some time your blood flow (depending on your condition) might be a bit stuck compared to walking in the wild where you have to lift your feet more, have different mechanics, this seems to reduce blood stuck in lower limbs and helps flushing this. It also feels nicer mentally because it's a bit more diverse. ps: all in all it's just another point in the fact that modern life is really mediocre
- corobo 3y agoThat last point about it feeling nicer mentally rings true for sure. I much prefer to walk over uneven terrain such as through a field rather than the super flat (former railway line) path to the side of it. Every so often I do hit a wonky patch that I'm surprised didn't cause an injury or sprain but so far so good. That's mostly on me for combining the enjoyment of uneven terrain with an enjoyment of nighttime walks haha, but does happen during the day too now and then. Good to hear it might be a little bit beneficial too! Yay for eccentric walking!
- agumonkey 3y agoI think our brains have internal rewards for balancing your body, it's always a little bit fun to try and find a path along a weird hill.
- corobo 3y agoMy best walk for hills is (sort of) literally storming a castle haha. Infinite dopamine when I trek up that way, fully agree with that hypothesis! A little bit deadly if it's been raining but if it's dry out it's a heck of a workout going directly up/down the pictured desire path rather than following the proper path round and up. Usually I'll go up the steep and down the regular path rather than risk breaking my neck in public, that would be embarrassing. Loads of steep but this-side-of-possible hills around the local castle ruins - built on a hill as pictured, plus where the former moat was, and plenty of hills and valleys around the immediate area :D http://share.cohan.dev/1rRbH.jpg http://share.cohan.dev/1rRbH.jpg
- araes 3y agoSome construction company with actual resources get on making "wavy sidewalks". I'll consult as a former hiker. Honestly, probably wouldn't be that hard to make matching tile edge sidewalks with semi-randomized central wave patterns. Games do it all the time.
- Tyr42 3y agoI do want to push a stroller sometimes, hopefully it isn't too bumpy.
- reaperman 3y agoWheelchair users likely agree.
- red-iron-pine 3y agodoesn't even need to be a wheelchair, my father has a bad hip and walks with a cane. "flat sidewalks are too flat and not enough fun to walk so lets make erratic sidewalks instead" has got to be one of the dumbest takes I've seen on HN.
- jerlam 3y agoJust go to any city that planted a lot of trees and ignored them until the roots pushed up all the surrounding sidewalk. It lulls you into a false sense of security until you wipe out on a random two-inch drop.