4 ms·
4 Internal Apple Emails That Helped the DOJ Build Its Case
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agohttps://archive.ph/q9zL4 https://archive.ph/q9zL4
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dgreensp 3y agoI want the government to have a case, here. I want the DOJ to be able to push back against what companies like Apple are doing. However, in court, you have to compare what a company is doing to the letter of the law. It seems US anti-trust laws are vague enough that, if the way big tech companies operate today violates them, the enforcement over the years has been so little that it is hard to apply them now in the spirit they were intended. That’s my impression, anyway. Apple will, of course, argue they are not a monopoly (all their products have competitors, like iOS has Android—even if they tried to kill it). They will argue that having an ecosystem of products in different categories that work together is not illegal, and that executives wanting to entice users to use their products, or deter them from switching, is all the same thing and just good business, not anti-competitive behavior. If it’s already illegal for Apple to prefer and promote their own apps and products and extract exorbitant rent from everyone else, then please, DOJ, put a stop to it. Maybe it’s just all the articles about this that are really poor. As it stands, not having dug into the matter deeply, I’m on the DOJ’s side, but I’d rather be a lawyer for Apple.
- atomicnumber3 3y ago"you have to compare what a company is doing to the letter of the law" No, it is literally the court's job to interpret the law. They are the ones who take the letter of the law and figure out what that actually means, and if history has shown us anything, they have tremendous latitude in that regard.
- dgreensp 3y agoWhat I meant was, the case will be decided by applying the law to the situation, so in order to discuss from the sidelines what could, should, or might happen, we need to look at what it says and how it might be interpreted.
- Someone 3y ago> and that executives wanting to entice users to use their products, or deter them from switching, is all the same thing and just good business, not anti-competitive behavior. But lots of good business becomes anti-competitive behavior once you’re judged to be the subject to antitrust law. So, the main issue is whether antitrust law should apply to them. That, IMO, is a case won as less on the letter of the law (which, as I understand it, is fairly vague) than on what ‘the people’ want it to mean today.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI don't understand how people are so mixed on this. The prospect of leaving iOS to go to Android is simply a no-go for me because I would lose access to a bunch of family and friend group chats (besides other lock-in) It's ridiculous that apple can leverage my social connections as a tool to keep me on iOS. What am I supposed to do? "Dear friends and family, I need you all to download this app called Signal so we can restart all our group chats in a new app because I am getting an android phone."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maeil 3y agoKind of, yes. The other 96% of the world population has pretty much managed just that. No where else depends on iMessage and the idea of depending on such a single-platform app to keep in touch with people is baffling.
- heeen2 3y agoThe rest of the world has the analog problem of some people boycotting fb messenger or WhatsApp and trying to get their social circle to move tob signal or telegram
- maxcoder4 3y agoFortunately it's easy to migrate off Facebook and just keep using messenger to talk to people. Not so easy with Apple.
- snowwrestler 3y agoI don’t understand the complaint here. I am in several group chats that have a mix of iPhone, Android, and other messaging clients. I have not lost access to anything.
- __egb__ 3y ago
- 486sx33 3y agoOddly enough I like the lock in… and it’s not apples fault, blackberry did it first with PIN messages and then BBM. Heck their slogan for the priv phone was privacy and exclusivity You can still SMS anyone. But it’s much better on iPhone. They should not open iMessage to Android it’ll just turn into a big spammy dumpster fire.
- vmladenov 3y agoThe big killer app for BBM, iMessage, and WhatsApp was the ability to send text messages for cheap/free relative to expensive and limited carrier SMS, especially on prepaid SIMs, and later to make full phone calls over WiFi. Skype was never this integrated to people’s contact lists and missed the boat with smartphones.
- cyckl 3y agoThe issue is that iMessage is already a big spammy dumpster fire—in my experience. I get plenty of spam messages sent by email addresses essentially made up of random strings of characters