3 ms·
The problem is that Blu-ray codecs stink. A 4K Blu-ray rip can be like 80gb, whereas a recode will fit on a dvd.
by bombcar 3y ago
The problem is that Blu-ray codecs stink. A 4K Blu-ray rip can be like 80gb, whereas a recode will fit on a dvd.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoI don't disagree, but at the same time - a 20tb HD is $300, and it can store 250 disks. Even with a 500 disk collection, and redundancy, I'm looking at only about $1200 in storage costs. Even assuming replacing one of those disks per year, the price of storage is only going down. Not that I'm not planning on re-encoding for everyday use, but I'll take the hit in storage costs to keep the "originals" around.
- bombcar 3y agoMy originals are the Blu-rays themselves; ready to be ripped again if needed.
- account42 3y agoIf you only have one backup copy of the originals then you'll have zero backup copies of the originals when you need them.
- account42 3y agoSomewhat agree. I do still re-encode most Blu-Rays to get rid of the black bars that are encoded in the video stream because apparently mandating players support arbitrary video aspect ratios would make too much sense.
- TheCoelacanth 3y ago4k Blu-rays are HEVC, which is one of the most efficient codecs available. They do use a much higher bitrate than streaming services tend to use, but the streaming versions are sacrificing some quality to save bandwidth.
- account42 3y agoCorrect, except that H.264 has multiple profiles so if you don't need to target cheap player hardware you can still egdge a bit more compression out of them without a noticeable sacrifice in quality. But yeah, the situation isn't nearly as ridiculous as it was with older 1080p Blu-Rays.
- account42 3y agoA DVD-sized reencode of a 4K movie will be shit quality. Even for 1080p you really want to allow for > 10 GiB depending on the movie content and length. 4K Blu-Rays are also usually already at least H.264 so it really is limited how much smaller you can make them without sacrificing image quality. Older 1080p Blu-Rays really do use stone-age codecs though and can easily be compressed to a fraction of the disk size without visible loss.