7 ms·
Why isn't dental health considered primary medical care?
- JCM9 3y agoIt doesn’t make a whole lot of sense, but the US healthcare system has long viewed dentistry and optometry as some sort of secondary thing that’s not part of the primary medical and healthcare profession. It’s silly IMHO. It should all just be part of an overall healthcare plan instead of separate insurance.
- gustavus 3y agoCounterpoint against that. Because optometry isn't considered part of the "healthcare" umbrella when I went to get LASIK it was the easiest medical transaction that I've ever done. They explained what they would do, said this was the price, then said they could offer a discount and when I was still considering they said they could give me another discount. I got the upfront price paid for it got my surgery and went on my way. This wasn't some shady Nick Riveria place either it was one of the premier LASIK facilities in the world. By contrast trying to do something as simple as buying a new medical device for my wife has been a Kafkaesque nightmare with random charges, wrong billing codes, switching companies, fighting insurance, demonstrating need, etc, etc for something I am willing to purchase. The device is also marked up several thousand percent to boot. Part of the problem with the healthcare discussion is that we need to clarify what we mean by healthcare. When I hear people complain about healthcare they either are complaining about medicine, or hospital stays with crazy and confusing billing processes, and these 2 problems are completely different than each other and require a whole different set of discussions apporaches and solutions, but everyone just talks about "healthcare" with no nuance and it obscures any possible forward progress. As a final question for pondering how much healthcare does everyone deserve? I think we'd agree it probably isn't reasonable to say a 96 year old woman should get a multimillion dollar experimental cancer treatment that will extend her life by 6 months before dying, on the other hand simply having access to Ibeprofun and Antibiotics means you have access to better medical care than anyone else at any point in history longer than 40 or 50 years ago?
- unethical_ban 3y agoRight, when most people complain about health care, they aren't complaining about quality of care when they get it. They're complaining about not being able to afford it. Or, it being too confusing. That's a problem with health insurance, and not with money. That's why some think that a national health care system that is designed primarily around effectiveness of distribution of payment, rather than extracting maximum profit from the flow of money between patient and provider, is the moral and effective solution. To your last point, rationing low availability health care is nothing new. Alcoholics can't get liver transplants for example. There's a whole field of bioethics that can surely answer some of those questions.
- 2devnull 3y agoOh I think most people who complain are upset by the attitude of medical workers and overall hubris inherent in the profession. It’s very correlated with wealth of the patient. Wealthy people can afford well paid happy doctors and nurses, nor stressed out overworked cynical disgruntled cogs in the hmo machine. Ymmv
- Gormo 3y ago> That's why some think that a national health care system that is designed primarily around effectiveness of distribution of payment, rather than extracting maximum profit from the flow of money between patient and provider, is the moral and effective solution. Why would we expect the incentives inherent in putting health care under the monopolistic control of those who seek political power to be any more favorable than those manifest in the current situation of apparent oligopolistic control by both profit-seekers and political-power-seekers? Where would this solution leave those who just want to obtain services directly from service providers, without any political or financial middlemen either taking a cut, usurping their agency, or homogenizing the market?
- tayo42 3y ago> they aren't complaining about quality of care when they get it. This isn't true. Plenty complaints about long waits for appointments, rushed appointments, not getting proper medicine. My wife recently couldn't get a specific potentially more effective medicine covered (it was in the end) because the insurance company wanted the dr to give her something cheaper.
- gushogg-blake 3y agoSame in the UK. You get GP stuff on the NHS for free, but dental and optical is only subsidised if you're on state benefits. If you go to the GP with a health issue that's related to the mouth in some way, you'll be told to see a dentist. I've never understood it.
- lol768 3y ago> You get GP stuff on the NHS for free, but dental and optical is only subsidised if you're on state benefits This isn't really the whole picture though, is it? I pay £25.80 for a dental check-up thanks to the NHS. If I wanted to do that on a private basis I'd probably be paying double.
- fy20 3y agoFillings and crowns are also subsidised by the NHS: https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/how-much-will-i-pay-for-nhs-dental-treatment/ https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/how-much-will-i-pay... I live in an EU country where this is not covered by the state health service, so everything is done privately. A filling is around the same price as the NHS, but a crown starts at €500 and dentures are even more.
- gushogg-blake 3y agoYou're right, I'm not sure why I said that. Still, I've definitely felt more "on my own" with dentistry as I've not always been able to register with an NHS dentist and in general they seem like they can do what they want, whereas we have GP surgeries that are there for the sole purpose of treating patients for free, and they don't unregister you if you miss checkups or whatever.
- humanrebar 3y agoRoutine dental care is routine, so calling it "insurance" is really odd in my opinion. Insurance isn't mainly providing protection against tail risk when it comes to eye care, dental care, and even predictable routine checkups. Obvious exceptions exist for accidents that require surgery to eyes or the inside of the mouth, but a dental hygienist (for instance) wouldn't be the healthcare professional involved in those procedures. It could make sense for some categories of routine care to be included in insurance because they reduce risk or are cheap enough to be affordable perks of the insurance product. I just wouldn't call those features insurance. If you're unconcerned about health insurance compared to health care as such, that's also OK. But the US healthcare system is mostly not a single payer healthcare system, at least not right now.
- paholg 3y agoI would love dental insurance that covers that tail risk, but it doesn't seem to exist. Every dental plan I've had covers at most $1500 or $2000 per year. That's meaningless when something comes up that costs ten times as much.
- semiquaver 3y agoThe problem for insurers is adverse selection and the long timescale of dental problems. The only people likely to sign up for plans that cover $10,000+ dental bills are those who know they have such a bill coming up in their future, which would cause the market price for such a plan to be so high as to make self-insurance a better prospect. This is less of a problem with health insurance since the most expensive ailments can’t generally be put off for an extended period of time (and because of universal coverage requirements, such as they are)
- panarky 3y agoThis is market failure. Insurance works best when risk is spread out over a large pool. In private markets, insurers profit by excluding 'bad risks' which leads inevitably to coverage limitations, exclusions, and high costs for those with the greatest need. Universal healthcare systems remove this profit motive and market failure. Everyone contributes, and everyone is covered, regardless of pre-existing conditions. This eliminates adverse selection and allows for better preventative care, ultimately reducing costs and improving overall health outcomes. Markets are great for some use cases, but disastrous for healthcare.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoI just wish a higher percentage of dental procedures were actually covered by dental insurance.
- xnx 3y ago"It has been found that only 10% of dental care is based on validated research." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6375114/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6375114/
- iends 3y agoFunnily enough the paper you are citing has that quote but they cite another paper. The paper they cite says “It has been suggested that perhaps as little as 8% of dental care is justified…” and cites two more papers. How is this acceptable in academic research? Nobody is citing the primary source and everybody is citing interpretations of some source that I can’t find the text of (probably because I’m on mobile). tl;dr your citation is worthless through no fault of your own.
- cperciva 3y agoApproximately 0% of parachute-wearing is based on validated research. Doesn't mean it's not a good idea. While I agree that dentistry absolutely has an overtreatment problem, there's enough evidence that some procedures result in pain relief at a minimum that we don't need to insist on double-blind trials -- and in fact performing such trials would be unethical.
- Kranar 3y ago>Approximately 0% of parachute-wearing is based on validated research. But this is simply untrue and it undermines the rest of your point. The actual satirical statement is supposed to be about clinical trials (research studies involving humans), not validated research in general. The study linked is not simply about clinical trials but rather than dentistry lacks validated research in general.
- sjducb 3y agoPlease cite a double blind experiment for parachute wearing. One where some jumpers have parachutes and others do not have parachutes. But seriously you have inferred that parachutes are important from other high quality evidence… This is exactly what dentists are doing. Then they get criticised because the study was not double blind for the exact treatment they recommended.
- xiwenc 3y agoThe dutch healthcare system also doesn’t consider dental health to be primary. Not sure why exactly. It can be purchased as an add-on. I personally never pay the premium but instead pay for the cleaning and check up sessions separately. It’s slightly cheaper than the premium if there are no complications.
- dboreham 3y agoSame in the UK fwiw. Medicine is socialized, but not dentistry.
- dazc 3y agoAs a child, NHS dentists were paid per treatment, preventative measures were counter to the business model. Nostalgia for the days of great and free oral health care is far from the reality of my lived experience.
- juitpykyk 3y agoBecause you can't really die from it? I know you can actually die, but for those situations it will be handled by the emergency room. Not saying I agree with the policy.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoAlthough less common, if you let a tooth infection get bad enough it could potentially lead to other issues and even death.
- jstarfish 3y agoIt's not that uncommon. Root canals are unaffordable. The ER will at least give you antibiotics for an abcess. But few can afford to actually deal with it.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoThey’re certainly not cheap not sure I’d call them unaffordable though. I’ve had 2 root canals in the last few years and they were probably $200-400 a pop with insurance. I’ve also had an extraction, bone graft, and implant and that was probably a few grand.
- 20after4 3y agoMy last root canal was $1500 and insurance paid 50% of that. I don't even live in an expensive region of the US.
- mcbutterbunz 3y agoIs your argument that diseases that you can’t die from shouldn’t be covered by primary medical care?
- gushogg-blake 3y agoI get the sense that in some ways dentistry and optometry are also kept separate because of how complex they are, and that even something like eye cancer/mouth cancer wouldn't be something a GP would look at. Not sure where they'd draw the line, but I've definitely been to the GP for things I've thought were genuine, general health issues and been sent away because they happened to be in the mouth or somehow related to vision.
- jmugan 3y agoFunny though, if it was considered primary medical in the US I bet it would be a lot more expensive. I'm always surprised that dental care prices seem justifiable based on the services I received.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- randerson 3y agoThere would also be more checks and balances against the many unethical dentists out there.
- thriftwy 3y agoThis is because for some reason human teeth are just so bad / unfit for the current use profile. I've probably went to a dentist 30 times or so, whereas I've only been to all other kinds of health care 5-10 times over the same time range, combined. So putting them in the same basket would be untenable for one or the other. Like if you had to go to your car dealership for gas refill. Or if you expected your warranty to also cover gas. Another disastrous area is eyesight, but since you cannot really fix it, you go to doctors about it just as much. I've also been living for almost 40 years now and the science has yield surprisingly few fruit in those two areas.
- tredre3 3y agoI've probably went to a dentist 30 times or so, whereas I've only been to all other kinds of health care 5-10 times over the same time range, combined. So putting them in the same basket would be untenable for one or the other. A cleanup + checkup + radiography is about $250. This is once a year (notwithstanding that some dentists recommend 2-3x). Health insurance costs Americans 250-1000/month. So, in a year, if you see a dentist once and no MDs then you've cost your insurer $250 and paid them at least $3000. How is it untenable?
- Kranar 3y agoOne major issue is that the biggest money maker for dentists, cleaning/scaling, is basically nothing more than a cosmetic procedure that has little to no medical value. Getting your teeth cleaned by a dentist is something many adults with health coverage do on a yearly basis, and yet it serves little to no purpose. So how do you integrate that into the health care system as a whole? Do you just continue having people see the dentist every year and get their teeth cleaned to continue the tradition so that dentists can continue to get paid? Do you eliminate it and then put a large number of dentists out of business? A great deal of common dental care as a whole is not actually based on any kind of science or research. Certainly some of it is legitimate and the article points out the few cases where there is a strong connection, but that makes up an absolute tiny minority of dentistry as a profession in terms of the money. https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD004346.pub4/full https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD...
- y-c-o-m-b 3y agoYour link doesn't disprove the need for cleaning, just that the studies examined were generally of poor quality. Anecdotally - I have issues with receding gums - and teeth cleaning (even though I hate it and only go once every 3 years or so) seems to be one way to quickly alleviate it for a while. For me there appears to be some benefit at least to going regularly if one does have dental problems.
- Kranar 3y agoGenerally that's what studies do; you can't really disprove things like naturopathy or chiropractic care, all you can do is show that they do not have any evidence to support them. I can't speak to your particular medical condition, but I can say I know people who say the exact same thing about acupuncture; they absolutely swear that it helps treat their pain and they are sincere in their belief just as I am sure you are sincere about your belief. Thankfully science is not about sincerity in one's own beliefs.
- 2devnull 3y agoSinusitis has odontogenic origins like 20% of the time iirc. I suspect a lot of heart disease results from the bifurcation of dental from general practice, eg periodontal disease being seen as a dental problem not a cardiovascular risk factor that doctors should be on the watch for.
- tonymet 3y agoMost dental care is cosmetic. Much of the remainder are unnecessary treatments. Twice yearly cleanings remove significant tooth material and are just an opportunity for dentists to sell more cosmetic and unneeded treatments. In short it’s a scam industry with a sliver of good health mixed in. It’s definitely not primary medical care.
- tonymet 3y agoOk down voters prove me wrong
- torlok 3y agoAnybody interested in dental health will be happy to hear that Vermin Supreme will be running for president this year. https://youtube.com/watch?v=4d_FvgQ1csE&pp=ygUgcHJlc2lkZW50IGNhbmRpZGF0ZSBib290IG9uIGhlYWQ%3D https://youtube.com/watch?v=4d_FvgQ1csE&pp=ygUgcHJlc2lkZW50I...
- matt3210 3y agoNothing in US health care makes sense
- asow92 3y agoThis is sort of embarrassing to admit publicly, but I had a fear of going to the dentist for several years and decided to go recently. After a 10 year hiatus, I was shocked to learn that I didn't have a single cavity or any other apparent issue! The dentist and hygienists were as astonished as I was. In my hiatus, I would brush every single day and occasionally pick plaque off myself with a tool similar to what the hygienists use at the dentist office. Needless to say, I bucked my irrational fear of the dentist and I'll be going back in a few months for another regular cleaning. This isn't to say that going to the dentist for regular cleanings isn't worth it, but maybe it isn't as required for some people as we think granted they keep up with a regular at home regimen?
- CyberDildonics 3y agoAnd some people who smoke live to be 100 years old, but if you go by actual statistics and data and not just some random anecdote off the internet, people get cavities. If cavities are untreated the tooth rots, infections occur, teeth need to be pulled and there are lots of negative consequences.
- asow92 3y agoWe agree about all that, so what's your contribution to the conversation exactly?
- CyberDildonics 3y agoYou realize when people go in for cleanings they are getting checked for cavities right?
- asow92 3y agoNope, I didn't realize that. Thank you for informing me. You are so wise. Next time maybe try engaging with the actual topic of the conversation? Like how some people are more or less prone to cavities and why that might be biologically or something? Obviously we all know that dentists are checking for cavities and people should go. I had an irrational fear of going to the dentist and opened about up about that here and all you can think to do is berate a point everyone here already knows?
- thiagoharry 3y agoIt is not? The lack of healthcare in US is always astonishing. Here in Brazil, since about 2000, dentistry is supported by public healthcare. Sure, for some services it may take a lot of time to be attended and treated, so who can afford usually pay for private healthcare, but nonetheless the public and free service exists. It is common that US tourists, when became sick or if they suffer some accident here, they resist to being sent to the hospital arguing that they cannot pay. And for some of them, it takes some time to make them understand that they do not need to pay for such a basic human right.
- wenc 3y agoBrazil also has an interesting relationship with teeth. When I was there, I noticed people brushing teeth after lunch. This happens even at corporate offices -- the restrooms would be full of people brushing and flossing after meals. People brought toothbrushes to work. There was even a floss (fio dental) dispenser.
- bradgranath 3y agoIt's very simple. Obviously your teeth, eyes, ears and mind are not part of your body. Everyone knows this.
- aftbit 3y agoWhy do many car insurance companies offer free replacements for a cracked windshield but nobody is willing to pay for replacing my brakes?
- Schiendelman 3y agoHealth insurance does cover normal maintenance on the rest of your body. Mental health, sexual health. Regular check ups. Regular blood work.
- jhayward 3y agoI don't recall who first relayed this to me but I believe the answer to the question in the title is "path dependence". Modern (US) health insurance started off as hospitalization insurance and was originated by hospitals themselves. It covered hospital procedures such as surgery etc. We should note that dentists and opthomalogists do not typically operate from a hospital setting, at least not in the early (1920-1950) era. Over time it was spun out of hospitals and extended to more medical procedures. The tax advantage of having employers pay for coverage began to dominate the market and has led to the current state of the medical marketplace. But the original dichotomy remains. "Health" insurance covers things that doctors do, and mostly those things that happen in hospital settings. There is an interesting article [1] that has some of the history of group health coverage which I found just now. [1] https://www.peoplekeep.com/blog/the-complete-history-of-employer-provided-health-insurance https://www.peoplekeep.com/blog/the-complete-history-of-empl...
- atombender 3y agoIt's also because medicine and dentistry evolved separately. Dentistry started more as a kind of "mechanic"-type profession of rather crude surgery (of course, all surgery was quite crude before modern times), and was often a sideline of other professions (e.g. dentures were made by jewelers and other types of craftspeople). By the time dentistry started to turn into a serious medical discipline in the 1800s, the existing branches of medicine didn't want anything to do with it. So dentists founded their own medical schools, developed their own licensing boards, and so on. By the early 1900s, dentists were so used to being separate that they actually actively lobbied against any attempt at unifying medicine and dentistry. There's a good article in The Atlantic about it: "Why Dentistry Is Separate From Medicine" [1]. [1] https://archive.ph/4HIxk https://archive.ph/4HIxk
- jhayward 3y agoI should have said "dentists and optometrists", rather than " .. and opthamologists". Sorry to catch this so late.
- 1letterunixname 3y ago(In America.) Dental, vision, and mental healthcare are unsurprisingly trivialized as being "too uppity" when ordinary healthcare isn't secured as a universal human right. "Medicare for all" is also a joke because it's not universal healthcare since Medicare props-up the for-profit healthcare racket and imposes significant limitations and financial burdens on patients. America needs universal and complete healthcare, and to stop throwing shade on treating people with dignity.
- latchkey 3y agoWhen I moved to Vietnam, I also found out the "real" cost of dental. I went to a "western" dentist there, who charged me $40 for a cleaning instead of my San Francisco dentist who charged $250. Nothing at all was different in the experience.
- 6510 3y agoIll make a funny: let the medical cartel set some vat on goods and services they consider bad for public health and subsidies for things they consider good. For the price of expensive fast food you can have cheap gyms. That way politicians wont have to bring up the unpopular subject.
- clocot 3y ago[dead]