3 ms·
Inflation is entirely a monetary phenomenon. It is the result of the government creating money to fund the deficit. There's around a 13 month lag between the cr
by WalterBright 3y ago
Inflation is entirely a monetary phenomenon. It is the result of the government creating money to fund the deficit. There's around a 13 month lag between the creation of the money and the inflation.
It's the Law of Supply & Demand in action. More money representing the value of goods & services in the economy means each dollar is worth correspondingly less.
The 2% inflation being "good" for the economy is propaganda.
The propaganda around inflation is amazingly effective. How often do you hear from otherwise intelligent and education people that inflation is caused by:
1. speculators
2. profiteers
3. greedy business
4. greedy unions
5. Putin's price hike
6. supply chain shocks
7. oil companies
8. Arab cartels
9. savers
10. banks
11. wage-price spiral
12. cost-push
13. demand-pull
It's all disinformation, and rather easy to refute. For example, if oil price hikes cause inflation, why do we not have corresponding deflation when oil prices go down?
- maxerickson 3y agoIt is the result of the government creating money to fund the deficit. How does the inflation tell the difference between money created to fund the deficit and money created for other reasons?
- WalterBright 3y agoGreat question. When banks loan money, they create the money. But when the loan is paid back, the money is destroyed. The federal deficit is not paid back. (Oh, there's the fiction of it being paid back, but what actually happens is the government just issues more debt.)
- maxerickson 3y agoBut sometimes it takes much more than 13 months for the money to be destroyed. How does the inflation know the difference in those cases?
- WalterBright 3y agoIt all averages out among all the banks issuing loans and resolving them.
- maxerickson 3y agoHousehold debt has gone up by trillions of dollars. https://www.newyorkfed.org/microeconomics/hhdc https://www.newyorkfed.org/microeconomics/hhdc
- triceratops 3y ago> The federal deficit is not paid back You mean the federal debt. The federal deficit is funded by the federal debt. [1] If the federal debt were fully paid back, would any money be destroyed? Wouldn't it just go from taxpayers to bond holders? 1. https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/americas-finance-guide/national-deficit/#the-difference-between-the-national-deficit-and-the-national-debt https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/americas-finance-guide/natio...
- klodolph 3y ago> It's all disinformation, and rather easy to refute. For example, if oil price hikes cause inflation, why do we not have corresponding deflation when oil prices go down? What’s the logic here? Are you saying that if oil prices going up caused inflation, that oil prices going down would cause deflation? That a nice intuitive leap, but you haven’t actually provided the reasoning for why that would be true. It’s kind of like saying that sticking a knife in someone doesn’t kill them, because pulling the knife out doesn’t bring them back to life. Sometimes, the opposite action doesn’t have the opposite effect. Pulling a knife out of somebody doesn’t restore them to the original state before they got stabbed. Lowering oil prices does not restore the economy to the original state before oil prices were raised.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Are you saying that if oil prices going up caused inflation, that oil prices going down would cause deflation? That's right. Where does the extra money come from to keep prices high after the oil prices drop? In order to have a general price increase, there must be more money in the economy to sustain it.
- klodolph 3y ago> In order to have a general price increase, there must be more money in the economy to sustain it. I would describe this as “categorically incorrect”. The law of supply and demand normally has two sides—supply, and demand. It’s simplistic way of looking at it, but it’s enough to explain why prices of a product can increase even if there isn’t more money. If you focus narrowly on the supply on money, like it’s the only variable, you won’t end up with a satisfactory explanation of inflation. It’s like trying to understand the world by looking through a peephole.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe supply of money in excess of growth of the GDP is a satisfactory and reliable explanation of inflation.
- triceratops 3y agoInflation being due to a combination of all the factors you listed seems far more likely than it being due to exactly one thing.
- WalterBright 3y agoExcept if you look at history, inflation reliably corresponds with the increase in the national debt. The US had zero net inflation from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation afterwards. What happened in 1914? The Federal Reserve Act, which specifically empowered the Fed to issue money without restriction. Those other alleged causes all existed prior to 1914. Did you know that the US experienced inflation when on the gold standard when gold was being dug out of the ground in the California and Yukon gold rushes? Spain experience massive inflation when they were looting the New World of its gold and silver. The inflation was so bad during the American Revolution that the Founders did not empower the government to print money. The government found a way around the Constitutional prohibition with the Federal Reserve Act, and then, of course, inflation ensued. It's the same cause.
- triceratops 3y agoThe US national debt more than doubled between 2008 and 2018, but inflation was low. It's only up 50% in the 6 years since, but we've had crazy inflation. The only new factors have been the things you listed - supply shocks, war. A lot of things other things happened in 1914. For instance, World War 1. Why not blame that for inflation? I said inflation was due to all of the factors you listed. Debt and deficits was one of the factors. I just don't think it's the only factor, like you do.
- WalterBright 3y ago> The only new factors have been the things you listed - supply shocks, war You overlooked the incredible increase in government spending. > I just don't think it's the only factor, like you do. For the other factors, you'll need to account for where all the extra money comes from.