4 ms·
"There is nothing preventing Facebook from being the next Myspace when something newer, cooler and hipper comes along and the users move on." I would argue tha
by untog 15y ago
"There is nothing preventing Facebook from being the next Myspace when something newer, cooler and hipper comes along and the users move on."
I would argue that things like the massive photo collections people have made provide a large level of lock-in. I also suspect that Timeline is the first play in a "all your history, here" move that would make moving to another service very difficult.
- BrandonBT 15y agoIf something new comes along that is worthy of competing with Facebook, I would imagine that it would be fairly trivial for them to have an "Import Your Photos from Facebook!" button that you'd click to simply move all of that data over.
- slipperyp 15y agoFacebook also has tremendously greater adoption, especially among the non-tech savvy, than MySpace ever had. Don't get me wrong, I don't think there is unalterable inertia here, but at its peak MySpace was constantly broken, had far less adoption, and had far less interesting and integrated ways to collaborate than Facebook has established today. Anyone could have looked at MySpace and said "a smart, driven undergrad could build a system that could beat this on one power-weekend with a bunch of redbull"
- joering2 15y agoI don't see a problem here. Most of folks here, including myself, over the span of one weekend could write a downloadable version of a Visual Basic application with a built-in Internet Explorer Window where you login to your facebook and then the app scrap (download) all data you ever had, all messages, photos, etc, everything within a couple of minutes, elegantly packet into zip, xml or whatever format you wish to have it! Zuck could do shit, because that downloadable app would use client local IP, so they would have to block _everyone_ in order to stop the app. Further, it would use built-in IE frame, so all request would look like coming from legitimate Internet Explorer user. You could also implement "wait(rand [sec 1-5])" between downloading requests, so it looks more messy, more like a human that is clicking, rather then robot pulling requests in miliseconds. Zuck once had hacked into school system. Who knows -- would be crazy to see an App that so easily ported out all your data out of Facebook, and see Zuck trying to stop it :)
- untog 15y agothen the app scrap (download) all data you ever had, all messages, photos, etc, everything within a couple of minutes If you think you could download people's entire photo collections in a "couple of minutes" then you underestimate the insane number of photos uploaded to Facebook every day.
- joering2 15y agono, you misunderstood or I haven't explained properly (mostly the latter). What I said is that the App would download all _your_ photos that you owe on your account. Given that it takes couple seconds max until I see a full photo from the moment I clicked it, it would take tens of minutes to download hundreds of photos: 5 sec per photo x 200 photos == 16 minutes of robot's work while you enjoy your drink. edit: so this "I would argue that things like the massive photo collections people have made provide a large level of lock-in" becomes an irrelevant problem.
- jvrossb 15y agoDon't think so. Your hypothetical app saves all of my photos, but I suspect people spend far more time browsing other peoples' photos. Those I don't get by being the first to migrate to a Facebook competitor. That's where the powerful lock-in lies.
- joering2 15y agono it doesnt. when something "better" shows up people will want to move on, but you are right there will be like "oh, all my photos and tags, I cant leave them". "But wait, there is that App that Joe programmed and Mary, Mike, John and Jennie already used it, I can use it too and all my photos will be re-linked and re-tagged on that new site. yay me!" is it really that hard to imagine??
- sirclueless 15y agoYou still lose the entire network of tags around each photo. The most valuable thing about Facebook photos over, say, Flickr photos, is knowing who is in them.
- angryasian 15y agoas Path, instagram and other photosharing networks are proving your social connections and photos aren't really a compelling enough reason to leave.
- D_Alex 15y agoYouTube has an unrivalled collection of videos. I used to listen to most of my music on YouTube, and built many hours of playlists. But I don't use YouTube any more. The level of advertising got to beyond tolerable. And that is the problem these sites have. I might spend four hours on the weekend with music videos on, but I just could not increase that, there is not enough hours in the day. To grow, the site has to increase the proportion of ads, and then it starts to lose users based on their level of tolerance for crappy, repetitive advertising. So anyone buying Facebook and suchlike for growth potential should also consider that there really is a practical upper limit to the revenue it can pull in before it becomes annoying and starts losing users. IMHO, YouTube is beyond that limit now, Google is pretty close, Facebook has a little room, but not that much.
- ay 15y agoThere is I think a very interesting idea here - that an excessive "greed" for growth, if unbalanced, actually pushes the service faster time-wise over the lifecycle than it'd go if it were exploited more carefully. This can be excessive ads, but this could be as well things like excessive features which make the service more bloated and unsuitable for the original audience.