11 ms·
My grandfather Paul Tillich, the unbelieving theologian
- zvmaz 3y ago> Among the most puzzling and paradoxical ideas in his Systematic Theology (1951) is his statement that ‘God does not exist’ and that ‘to argue that God exists is to deny him.’ Tillich goes on to state that the word ‘existence’ should never be used in conjunction with the word ‘God’. By reading this, I am tempted to imagine the intellectual atmosphere that prompted the logical positivists to insist on what constitutes meaningful statements to the point of being themselves incoherent [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logical_positivism#Cognitive_meaningfulness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logical_positivism#Cognitive_m...
- flenserboy 3y agoIt does bring that to mind, especially given the era he came out of. Likely, however, what he is trying to get at is the distinction between God/not God: existence is something a thing which is not God — a neutrino, a squirrel, a rock — is given, which makes speaking of God as having existence in the same way as those things a mistake, as if the highest thing is just one of those many things which could be enumerated that way. This helps maintain the distinction Tillich is likely aiming at, which is to avoid speaking of God as part of the universe, or in some panentheistic way.
- taion 3y agoAnd in that sense Tillich isn't that far from, say, Aquinas, who is consistent about asserting that existence is not a "real" predicate and that God's existence is outside of the world and outside of space and time. You don't even need to squint that hard to see a commonality between Tillich's notion of discussing God symbolically and Aquinas's notion of doing so analogically, not to mention the contrast between finite humans and an infinite God who is beyond understanding. And not to mention that apophaticism – the idea that positive knowledge about God is impossible – has been a feature of Christian theology since the beginning. So much of this can be taken in ways that not only aren't outside the bounds of Christian orthodoxy, but also align with more sophisticated Christian philosophical understandings of God. That much, of course, is not why Tillich is controversial!
- jiggawatts 3y agoSo… God is mathematics?
- knightoffaith 3y agoDon't know where you got that from.
- tivert 3y agoI'm guessing a sloppy equivalence due to the idea of "existence is outside of the world and outside of space and time" showing up in descriptions (e.g. "a platonist might assert that the number pi exists outside of space and time" from https://iep.utm.edu/mathplat/ https://iep.utm.edu/mathplat/).
- jiggawatts 3y agoYes! To be more specific: if the Universe (existence itself) can be described by mathematics, and mathematics is timeless (beyond mere physical existence), then essentially the physical Universe is inevitable and in some sense "created by" mathematics. In this view of creation, mathematics plays the role of God. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permutation_City https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permutation_City
- rjknight 3y agoIt's also worth bearing in mind that much theology is an attempt to explain what the experience of God is like. The experience of God is not (for Tillich, nor perhaps for very many moderns) about finding a literal place and time in which God-the-being can be directly observed. To seek God and expect to find a being who exists in the same manner as a tree or a building is to set oneself up for failure. When Tillich says "The courage to be is rooted in the God who appears when God has disappeared in the anxiety of doubt" he is describing the psychological process the seeker undergoes. In his case, he identifies God with the open, reflective cast of mind in which one engages with the unknowable, ineffable, combinatorally-explosive possibilities that are found at the horizons of our understanding. The "state of being grasped by an ultimate concern" is one in which we are trying - and necessarily failing - to see beyond the horizon. And yet, something sustains us in the effort, which is faith in God. Doubtless this really is a very different kind of faith than other self-described Christians might have, whose faith might be rooted in a different mode of being and engagement with the world. And, to be clear, Tillich's description is very much "what it's like" to have his variety of faith, and not a metaphysical claim about the workings of the universe. A different Christian might hold much stronger claims about God's precise nature and existence, but for Tillich those beliefs were unsustainable.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> To seek God and expect to find a being who exists in the same manner as a tree or a building is to set oneself up for failure. But isn’t that the whole point of Christianity, that Jesus was God in human flesh and actually existed like you or I exist while also being fully God?
- smeej 3y agoExisted like you or I exist, yes, but existed merely as you or I exist, or merely as a tree or building exists, no.
- scop 3y agoI think this is on point, but does point to the limits/faults in his work. I recall being very energized by Tillich in my youth and at the very beginnings of my religious exploration, but was very surprised that the sort of "ambiguity" he was trying to parse was much more well laid out in classical theologians (Aquinas, etc), i.e. "to define God, the limitless being, is to inherently apply limit" which is why theologians have traditionally pursued God via "what He is Not" as we can certainly say that God is not limited, time bound, etc. Tillich's "ambiguity" was very approachable in my youth, but today I find it extremely dangerous from a moral and philosophical perspective. There is truth in what is said, but unless you have the context in which it is said you can quickly spin it to your heart's delight. My primary takeaway as a youth was "this is great and very theological/intellectually stimulating while not morally demanding of me whatsoever, hooray!" which is why, as a stubborn young adult, certainly found it attractive. FWIW, if anybody wants a great challenge that seeks to bridge classical theology with modern/personalist/subjective thought, you should read Man and Woman He Created Them by John Paul II. It is as rewarding as it is dense and gave me the bridge between "old" and "new" philosophy/theology that I find lacking in many moderns.
- smeej 3y agoStrong second for Man and Woman He Created Them. If you can get through it without coming to a deeper understanding of yourself (whether in agreement with its ideas or in opposition to them), you'll be the first person I've met who has.
- rhelz 3y ago> you can quickly spin it… It’s really hard for me to see how any theology—or any text—could be any less ambiguous than any other. E.g. quantum mechanics is arguably the least ambiguous theory ever devised, because it gives results of the most specific agreement with experiment. But nevertheless has an ever-increasing number of interpretations, none of which can be ruled out—to all appearances hopelessly ambiguous to what it actually means. When it comes decisions you have to make, either individually or as a society, even the most verbose and specific moral codes suddenly seem to be ambiguous. Some examples: 1. Are we morally obliged to either support or oppose Obamacare? 2. Is a 50% tax rate moral or immoral? What is the exact tax rate which is “most moral”? 3. Is it Moral to support a president who boinked an intern? Or a president who payed hush money to hookers? 4. Should it be illegal to smoke? Or sell fruit-flavored vapes? 5. How old should somebody be before they are allowed to (fill in the blank here…vote, have sex, drive a car, drink, drop out of school?) We certainly look to our cultural polestars—-religion, tradition, precident—to help us out with these sorts of questions, but by no means does any of them give us any definitive answers.
- cout 3y agoIt is a peculiar thing to say about someone who refers to oneself as "I am".
- flenserboy 3y agoIt kind of is — except the name given to Moses is closer to "I Am Who I Am", which is consonant with the rest of the OT/NT, where God is known by what he does & what he says (revealing the contours of his character) instead of through examination, deduction, or some sort of experience of the divine.
- cameron_b 3y agoThe pain evident in his life story seems to shatter the very assumptions of language even. I read in that sentence something of the nature of "Humans can't even plumb the depths of 'existence' with surety to understand how to bring that idea to a superseding and underlying ever-being of a God" Tillich would overload the semi-colon in C.
- anonymouse008 3y agoSounds like he would sure love the Abrahamic God - the one when inquired of “who should I tell them sent me” responds with “I AM”
- panosfilianos 3y agoI wonder if this refers to a central idea in Orthodox theology which is very clear to distinguish between: - God "υπάρχει" (Greek for existing under someone's authority, "υπ" under -"αρχή" authority) which is used in modern Greek for all things that simply exist and is false for God and, - God "είναι" (Greek for being, present tense) which is True of God and of nothing else.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago[flagged]
- SRasch 3y agoHis point is that we talk of existing, as existing in this universe. But God is outside of it. An analogy is: it would be wrong to say Tolkien exists in the Lord of the Rings universe, even though he made it, and so in a sense is a precondition for any of the characters in the lore existing. This is actually not unusual but is the standard theological view
- hackable_sand 3y agoDisagree because it implies intent, but I also find Sephirah to be a better wrapper for this angle of the discussion. A better analogy that comes to mind is that "God" - in this case - is a violin string, and the universe is the music.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- csours 3y agoInteresting that the word 'humility' does not appear in the article, but it seems to me that is what the article is about. No matter how you explain the world to yourself, I think you need some humility to recognize that you do not have a complete understanding. Humans also need faith to function, but not too much, or it's too easy to stay wrong and too easy to dismiss the idea that other people can have a valid point of view that disagrees with your own point of view.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wredue 3y agoHumans do not need “faith” to function. If you’re talking about “having faith” as in “I have faith my car will start with morning”, then yes, but that is not the same thing as theological faith. I have loads of evidence and experience that I can draw on to “have faith my car will start”, whereas “faith” in the context of religion means to “believe absent evidence”.
- csours 3y agoYou may notice that I did not specify theological faith.
- oaththrowaway 3y agoNo, that's a common misconception. Faith in the context of religion requires or enables action. It's taking your belief and acting on it.
- slothtrop 3y agoThat is just what follows from faith, not the definition of faith. That is just as true of anything someone really believes in; your actions would or ought not be incongruent with your beliefs. If you believed animals are sentient and ought not be harmed at all, then you wouldn't harm them. But those actions that follow have no bearing on the meaning of belief or faith (where the latter can be distinguished as being a "willful" belief).
- idkdotcom 3y ago[dead]
- cafard 3y agoOne name I don't see here is "Heidegger". I remember hearing years ago that Tillich drew heavily on Heidegger, sometimes with little more alteration than swapping in "God" for "ground of being". Perhaps someone better acquainted with Tillich and Heidegger could weigh in?
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoThis quote has stuck with me: > Paul Tillich wrote that all institutions, including the church, are inherently demonic. Reinhold Niebuhr asserted that no institution could ever achieve the morality of the individual. Institutions, he warned, to extend their lives when confronted with collapse, will swiftly betray the stances that ostensibly define them. Only individual men and women have the strength to hold fast to virtue when faced with the threat of death. And decaying institutions, including the church, when consumed by fear, swiftly push those endowed with this moral courage and radicalism from their ranks, rendering themselves obsolete. https://libquotes.com/chris-hedges/quote/lbh3k8n https://libquotes.com/chris-hedges/quote/lbh3k8n
- oldgregg 3y ago^^^ you are here.
- fsckboy 3y agomany, even most, individuals do not hold fast to virtue even in their daily lives, and society has only crude solutions for dealing with that, but we must deal with it. organizations that consist of individuals who do hold fast to principle we tend to label as "cults", and their chosen principles are not necessarily favored by any majority. we need organizations, as imperfect as they are--which is as imperfect as we are--and so we regulate them as best we can. the Tillich quote you cite sounds Ayn Randian.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoWe do need organizations. And we also need to see them for how they behave sometimes. Both things can be true.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- photochemsyn 3y agoPerhaps all religious and metaphysical argument can be abstracted away into the simulation hypothesis - i.e. that we all live in a perfect simulation, running on a substrate somewhere else. The key point in this argument is that no experimental or observational evidence is capable of proving or disproving the existence of the simulation, since it is a perfect simulation. This is logically equivalent to the statement that a supernatural being is continually intervening in the world, but only when nobody is watching, and only such that no evidence of intervention is left behind. Similarly, nobody can prove that a person who claims to hear the voice of a supernatural being in their head (and that's the inspiration for writing a holy text which forms the basis of a religion) is actually just schizophrenic, rather than having had their neurons plucked like strings by said supernatural being. This view seems to upset atheists more than anyone else, since it places their certainty about the fundamentally mechanistic and non-simulated nature of reality in the same bin with religious evangelicals, but the religious people don't like it much either as there is no clear basis to choose one religion as superior to another, other than the purely utilitarian arguments about which one provides the optimal moral basis for a healthy society. Hence the mysterious unknowable nature of reality: some questions cannot be answered. Even the mathematicians agree on that these days.
- anonymouse008 3y agoWhat led you arrive at this? Would love to read these works
- NateEag 3y agoNot OP, but IIRC Jonathan Edwards held that the whole universe existed in the mind of God. This is functionally indistinguishable from the "perfect simulation" hypothesis. That was what leapt immediately to mind the first time I encountered the Simulation Hypothesis, as one raised on Christian theology.
- photochemsyn 3y agoA lot of the concepts about simulation and related things, are in Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter, although it doesn't go into theology much, though there are headings like "Articles of Reductionist Faith".
- swat535 3y agoPaul Tillich is definitely interesting, but I find his conclusions deeply unsatisfying and even somewhat "new agey." This is pretty typical of existentialists though. When you search for meaning and purpose, you tend to find it in reinforcing what it is you want in the first place. So for Nietzsche, it was ultimate freedom, for Kierkegaard it was Christianity, for Camus it was living contradiction, and for Tillich it is some sort of Christian-y/pantheist/new age hybrid. It doesn't help that unlike most existentialists, Tillich is a pretty dull writer. That doesn't mean he didn't have a number of insights and thought-provoking ideas, and really my criticism is more due to my feelings about existentialism than Tillich itself. I find a vigorous approach to seeking/knowing truth far more interesting and satisfying than seeking (or creating) meaning/purpose.
- knightoffaith 3y agoDoesn't the "rigorous approach to seeking/knowing truth" seem kind of detached from the reality of life to you? It seems to me that humans are not just disembodied thinking things but agents that actually live in the real world, that (in my view) must live to some end, some purpose.
- HKH2 3y agoOur purpose is pretty clear: to reproduce. What sets us apart from other animals is the way we structure our curiosity.
- knightoffaith 3y agoSure, in terms of evolutionary "purpose" (which is not really purpose, just the way we make sense of what evolution is doing---we know that evolution doesn't have some goal in the sense that it is an agent whose will is oriented towards that goal), our biology is (more or less) optimized to pass on genes. That says nothing about what our purpose in the sense of what we ought to do. I imagine most people would simply deny that things have purposes at all; they simply are the way they are.
- 3y ago
- carabiner 3y agoTheologians ~ They don't know nothin'