10 ms·
The funny thing is, as far as I can tell, these are the only two widespread uses of BitTorrent. 1) Pirating movies, music, etc... 2) Downloading Linux distrib
by whalesalad 15y ago
The funny thing is, as far as I can tell, these are the only two widespread uses of BitTorrent.
1) Pirating movies, music, etc...
2) Downloading Linux distributions.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- aphistic 15y agoMore and more games are using it as a patching tool these days. Blizzard has been using BitTorrent to distribute patches for years with WoW.
- whalesalad 15y agoIndeed I have noticed this. I think it's great technology and more services should be using it. The Blizzard case is a great example of it being used pretty transparently/behind-the-scenes. I'd love to hear more non-transparent cases though. I genuinely cannot think of a time i've used it aside from stealing an album or grabbing debian.
- cryptoz 15y ago> I genuinely cannot think of a time i've used it aside from stealing an album or grabbing debian. It's definitely not stealing. I'm not sure what the preferred legal term for "pirating" is right now, but it's something like "intellectual property infringement". Stealing implies that you removed the original from the owner and refuse to give it back. That is not the case.
- stinkytaco 15y agoEvery time someone makes this argument I feel like they're undermining the point they are trying to make. You sound like a politician trying to couch his corruption in some legal technicality ("depends on what the definition of "is" is"). There are lots of reasons to look at the content industry and say "You are screwing us over, taking our rights and laughing all the way to the bank while you cry to our faces, you suck" but making up bullshit only makes you seem like you’re pedaling it too. Instead of buying it, you took it. That's basically stealing.
- cryptoz 15y agoWait a minute, slow down. There's a real difference, a big one that seriously matters. I live in Canada. Stealing is a crime. You can face jail time, a permanent criminal record, and be removed from society for a very long time if you are found guilty of stealing. None of that can happen to you if you pirate an album. Framing the issue to make it sound like you can be a criminal facing time in jail for downloading an album is absurd. It's very far removed from reality and builds a culture of hatred and fear that is not actually present. Stealing and pirating music are very different things. It's wrong to talk about them as though they are the same. That's the only point I'm trying to make. Pirating digital content is wrong. It's an issue that urgently needs attention. I'm not trying to justify the actions or call out in support of pirates. I am trying to make sure everyone knows that "stealing" has an important legal definition that is irrelevant to pirating music.
- stinkytaco 15y agoIt's not the terminology per se that is the issue, but insisting on correcting everyone who uses it. In the minds of everyone who is not in the group that makes that distinction it sounds like you're trying to justify something. It's essentially identical to the argument college kids make to me all the time: "I'm not stealing anything, I'm pirating it." Of course you are, but if I explained this issue to, say, a Senator, they would say it's stealing. At that point, yes, correct said Senator, then you're in a real discussion about a real issue. Swooping in and correcting some guy who casually uses the term "stealing" on an Internet form just grates on me because you sound like those college kids trying to justify themselves.
- moe 15y agobut insisting on correcting everyone who uses it. We correct you because you're using misleading terminology, as cryptoz explained. Language matters and it's hard to have a useful discussion when either side keeps on falling back to prejudiced terminology.
- 15y ago
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoIs the big sticking point about using the word "stealing" is that piracy does not involve a physical item being removed from the owner? If so then maybe we're talking more along the lines of "theft of services"[1]. Theft and stealing are often used interchangeably but I believe they do have subtle differences in their definitions. However, we do not have as many different forms of the word "theft" as we do for "stealing". It does become a bit more awkward to work the word theft into some sentences. Rather than saying "I committed theft of three albums", it is easier and (in this context) nearly as accurate to say "I stole three albums". [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theft_of_services http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theft_of_services
- masklinn 15y agoCompanies also use it to deploy servers, although that's internal so it's not hampered by ISP blocks.
- bithive123 15y agoInterestingly, Blizzard's implementation is so bad that I actually get better throughput by disabling P2P. It makes no sense but I had several hours to play with it while waiting for SC2. I found similar complaints on their forums so hopefully they'll fix it someday.
- Smudge 15y agoI recall getting Blizzard's implementation working pretty well after going through a maze of help topics and finding particular ports that I needed to enable forwarding for.
- mjwalshe 15y agoyeh but the PTP dowload for wow sucks I get faster speeds turning it off
- sp332 15y agoIt's used for a lot of legal videos as well, like Sita Sings the Blues http://www.sitasingstheblues.com/wiki/index.php?title=SitaSites#bittorrent http://www.sitasingstheblues.com/wiki/index.php?title=SitaSi... also Vodo uses BT to distribute their movies. http://vodo.net/ http://vodo.net/ Revision3 used to run their own tracker with only their own videos listed, but there was some legal trouble so they shut it down. I'm seeding Geocities from http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=GeoCities http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=GeoCities but that's pretty niche :) I'm also seeding a bunch of videos from a hacker conference (CC licensed).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nsmartt 15y agoIt doesn't matter what the common use-case is. BitTorrent is better than traditional server->client downloads. "Oh, pirates are the most common users of BitTorrent? But BitTorrent is better than traditional server->client downloads. More companies/people/whatever should be providing BitTorrent alternatives for downloading." "Oh, pirates are the most common users of BitTorrent? But BitTorrent is better than traditional server->client downloads. It's a shame, but I guess we have to hinder BitTorrent traffic. Oh, what could have been!"
- cookiecaper 15y agoReally there's no reason Firefox and Chrome shouldn't support torrents as a normal download mechanism, default to 1.0 share ratio with a cap of 1/3 upload speed (obviously adjustable), and just let web sites start using it transparently for every file over 20 megs. BitTorrent is a GREAT content delivery mechanism. It decreases download time, decreases bandwidth costs (for everyone), ensures that file remain available as long as there are seeds (i.e. no way to censor a rogue file from a central point of control (assuming DHT is in use of course)), and checks every chunk and automatically redownloads if corruption is discovered. It's really pretty awesome.
- jedberg 15y agoIt's a privacy issue. Imagine I'm an Evil Doer(tm) and I decide to go to a porn site and download "Sick fetishes 3" just so I can publish the list of IP addresses that were part of my BT swarm. With BT right now, you as a user are probably savvy enough to know that risk and accept it, but if it was built right into the the browser, a lot of bad things could happen. It's too bad too, because I'd love to see a much bigger adoption of BT.
- fl3tch 15y agoWhile this is true, browsers could benefit from a "bittorrent-lite" implementation. You get the files from a server, but they come with metadata like a .torrent file, which includes hashes for small chunks of the file. Downloads are automatically checked and can resume anywhere. It could all be transparent to the user. Really, it's amazing this isn't the default way to download yet.
- premchai21 15y agoResuming fetching multiple unfetched fragments of a resource is already possible with HTTP range requests. Checking the entire file can be done if the server provides a Content-MD5 header (though I'm not sure actual client use of this is widespread), and checking parts of it is infrequently useful by itself to the processing application and would be highly application-dependent even if so. The big win of BitTorrent is the distribution of available channel capacity over the swarm of downloaders; if you're not going to use that part, HTTP does quite well by itself.
- jurjenh 15y agoI could imagine a very efficient and quick way for system updates could be built this way. Would reduce hosting and bandwidth costs for the system developers / maintainers and could improve the speed and availability of updates. The only immediate concern that springs to mind is that if you manage to crack into this channel, you could potentially gain access to millions of computers in next to no time. In fact, I believe botnets work similar to this (from what I can remember of the Reddit botnet AMA...
- riobard 15y agoIf I remembered correctly, Facebook uses this method to deliver their 1GB PHP-converted-to-C++-then-compiled binary to their server farms because that's the only way they can update without crashing some central servers.
- pyrhho 15y agoTwitter also: http://engineering.twitter.com/2010/07/murder-fast-datacenter-code-deploys.html http://engineering.twitter.com/2010/07/murder-fast-datacente...
- Drbble 15y agoKazaa already did it. That was their business model.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoBittorrent exists to make it easier to download large files or sets of files. Large files tend to fall into two major categories: media (video and audio), and large software distributions (.isos or other software updates). So, it doesn't seem at all surprising that bittorrent primarily gets used for downloading media files and software distributions. Both of those categories include many perfectly legitimate downloads, as well as some that infringe someone's copyright.
- _delirium 15y agoIt's used for distributing large data sets as well, though I suppose whether that's a widespread use is arguable.
- Freaky 15y agoIn the past 5 months I've downloaded via BitTorrent 35 music albums, 4 game patches, and 2 full games, all acquired legally.
- chc 15y agoWhat legal outlet distributes music via Bittorrent?
- spindritf 15y agohttp://www.jamendo.com/ http://www.jamendo.com/ probably others too.
- officemonkey 15y agoetree and the Live Music Archive.
- CrazedGeek 15y agoThe Humble Bundles and Game Music Bundles have nearly everything they offer as torrents.
- dfc 15y agohttp://bt.etree.org http://bt.etree.org
- kzrdude 15y agoMiro tried to make it popular, by using it to download periodical video episodes (like news) updated using RSS with .torrent attachments.
- PuercoPop 15y ago3) Downlading World of Warraft
- InclinedPlane 15y ago3) Game patching (Blizzard (WoW, Starcraft, Diablo), Wargaming.net (World of tanks)) 4) Distributing music and movies legally (Sub Pop, Nine Inch Nails, CBC) 5) Backend updates for distributed server systems (Facebook, Twitter) Etc.
- antidoh 15y agoLouis CK's non-DRM shows got some HN love the other day. I paid my $5 and proceeded to download, but I have a crappy connection and kept getting disconnected. LCK puts a 4 download limit on his shows. Easiest thing to do was to find a torrent. I'd already paid my $5, so I felt OK about it. Bonus: it downloaded faster than from his site, and he didn't have to serve all the bits.
- antidoh 15y ago"Downloading Linux distributions" Except at my work, where they monitor and squash torrent connections. Sigh. OK, so I'll tie up the work internet downloading one big file from one busy place.
- marquis 15y agoNine Inch Nails distributes their public remix material by BitTorrent. With session files getting into the many-megabytes I don't believe they'd be able to afford this without BitTorrent, given the number of fans downloading their raw material to remix.
- avbor 15y agoMaybe for the client, but another place you can see extensive use of P2P is in gaming. Quite a few game clients have the Peer to Peer downloading built in.