4 ms·
Everyone with elderly parents needs to at some point sit down and have “The Talk” with them about online scams and ideally media literacy in general. The scams
by ryandrake 3y ago
Everyone with elderly parents needs to at some point sit down and have “The Talk” with them about online scams and ideally media literacy in general. The scams are getting more sophisticated (technically and socially) and the scammers are getting much more patient and long-term focused since they can rely on not getting shut down. With convincingly articulate LLMs on the horizon, the problem is only going to get worse and more accessible to would be scammers.
Yes, it’s not just the elderly who are victims of these, but a lot of people at that age are too trusting of strangers and of people who sound like authorities. And let’s face it: older people have all the wealth in the world anyway so they’re more likely to be fruitful targets.
- boringg 3y ago"And let’s face it: older people have all the wealth in the world anyway so they’re more likely to be fruitful targets." Your comment would have resonated without the unnecessary last line that I don't even believe - are they they the ones who built all the technology companies in the last two decades?
- kennywinker 3y agoIn a capitalist system, you don’t have to build anything to have all the wealth. Statistically I believe op is correct, wealth is more concentrated in older demographics, and it has been increasing in concentration for quite a while now.
- organsnyder 3y agoBaby boomers and Silent Generation people hold over 60% of the wealth in the United States. Gen X-ers have about 30%. https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/more-than-half-of-us-wealth-belongs-to-baby-boomers:-will-other-generations-catch-up https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/more-than-half-of-us-wealth-...
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Baby boomers and Silent Generation people hold over 60% of the wealth in the United States. Gen X-ers have about 30%. It would be more significant that the first two groups have twice as much aggregate wealth as the last if they didn't also have over a time and a half the population. (>30% vs. <20%.) https://www.statista.com/statistics/296974/us-population-share-by-generation/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/296974/us-population-sha...
- neilk 3y agoMillennials hold about 9%. Fun fact: Mark Zuckerberg personally holds over 1% of that 9%. (That is, he holds ~0.09% of all the wealth of US citizens, and happens to fall into the group of Millennials who as a group have ~9%. This from rough calculations and googling. There's an old reddit post that has about the same numbers. https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/nbqfvn/request_does_zuckerberg_hold_2_of_all_millennial/ https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/nbqfvn/requ...)
- radlad 3y agohttps://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/10/02/wealth-inequality-across-age-and-class-in-2019/ https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/10/02/wealth-inequ... Data comes from https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scfindex.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scfindex.htm
- ryandrake 3y agoIf you were a scammer, and your cold call console had three buttons: “20-40 year old”, “40-60 year old” and “60-80 year old”, which one would you push to optimize your chance of finding someone with the right combination of wealthy, trusting, and lonely? Even ignoring things like cognitive decline and loneliness, I’d hit the older button every time, despite the fact that yes some wealthy 20-60 year olds do exist.
- boringg 3y ago"And let’s face it: older people have all the wealth in the world anyway" My argument is that your comment is incorrect (hint: they don't have all the wealth in the world) and your tone. I don't disagree that they are the best target if you are a scammer its how you delivered the comment awfully close to blaming the prior generation for all our woes .. i.e. doesn't matter anyways because they "have all the wealth in the world anyways" flippancy.
- ryandrake 3y agoCome on. “All the wealth” is obviously a benign exaggeration, just like if I were to have said “I do this all the time” or “You always do that”.
- michaelt 3y agoYou haven't looked at the statistics on this, have you? Imagine vastly simplified world where people are in full time education (with no income and zero net worth) until age 20, then they start earning wealth at a constant rate. At age 30 they'd have 10 years of savings. At age 60 they'd have 40 years of savings, and that's 4x as much.
- animex 3y agoCognitive decline plays a big role in the susceptibility of elderly folks. An uncle of mine was a notoriously a ruthless businessman in his heyday and he fell prey to a gift-card scam where he was kept on the phone for 8 hours straight while he did their bidding. We were all shocked he fell for this but then realized the techniques that they use prey upon individuals with inability to deal with stress or trigger anxiety/panic causing them to act irrationally. As I age, I've noticed similar declines in ability to deal with multiple tasks, stress, etc. A better defence is to reduce the attack surface. While, I have legal financial control over mom's estate, suffering from moderate dementia, I've removed her ability to interact with her finances by removing her check book (she had loaned a large sum to an acquaintance without informing us), lowering her credit card limits, removed access to online banking, maintaining a low-balance checking account. All her expenses are on autopay. She doesn't even think about her finances anymore. Whenever she gets telemarketers, she always says "you have to talk to my son". Once in a blue moon she asks me "do I have money? I don't even know" -- and I reassure her she doesn't have to worry about money. I've done the same -- 2factor, using disposable credit card numbers, maintaining a separate PayPal-linked bank account separate from my main account etc, text notifications on all transactions etc. The sophistication and technology being used is also becoming problematic in detecting these scenarios even for highly aware/technical folk.
- bombcar 3y agoSetting the phone to not ring for unknown numbers is also powerful, but to make it work best you need a way to be able to "add" numbers remotely. I wish it was more intelligent; I'd love to tell it what area codes to permit; the advantage of having a phone from half way around the country is that I only care about a few area codes and the scammers don't know which ones those are.
- ryandrake 3y agoSadly, area codes are no longer a meaningful signal of anything. My family has three cell phones and one VOIP number; and those use four different area codes, hundreds of miles apart.
- pookha 3y ago[flagged]
- mindslight 3y agoGood luck getting them to listen and take you seriously rather than engaging the standard ego defense of "I would never fall for that". And in general "don't give out money or information to anyone calling on the phone" is good advice, but thinking it's a complete solution is a bit fanciful. I'll admit to personally finding myself on the receiving end of a call from $bank, and in a moment of weakness having supplied various bits of low-stakes personal information for their "verification". I had called them earlier and was expecting a response, but it could have just as easily been a scam calling at the perfect time. After the mental gears started turning and I realized how little I actually knew about the incoming call and how the requests were escalating, I stopped the conversation and asked where I could call them back. The point is it took a realization on my part, because these banks utilize highly deficient security procedures that make people comfortable with insecure behavior (starting with the use of effectively public information for "identity verification"), and the scammers only need a very tiny sliver of success rate to make it profitable. Also many of these scams are legitimate-business adjacent (medicare billing, medicare advantage, save money on electricity/tv, political campaigns, etc). Old people just want someone to talk to, effect their own fading agency, and really do believe the spiel of a friendly sounding person promising to help them. The potential damage there is lower than accounts being drained, but the continuum makes it hard to draw an absolute line when the "helpful" quasi-scammers blow right through it.
- karaterobot 3y agoI had "The Talk" with my parents, 82 and 79 respectively. They were surprised to learn about it, but they seemed to basically get it. They nodded. I said "what happens if you get a text message from your bank with a link to a webpage?" and they said "never click the link, go to the bank website and look for an alert, then call up the bank if I can't find it there". And so on. Great, that's that worry taken care of. Not even one month later my mom spent an hour on the phone with a scammer before my dad finally got suspicious and made her hang up. I still have no idea what all they had her do, and she doesn't remember either. We had to basically treat it as a successful identify theft and potential intrusion into her device, even though she didn't actually give them any money, thankfully. So, I don't know if The Talk actually does it. For her, it was the fact that there was another person on the line (people wouldn't lie to you, obviously) and that this person was telling her they'd get in trouble if she didn't go through these steps with them. The scammers are cynical experts, they're way more sophisticated than the median elderly person they're fucking with. This all made me very scared for them, because I don't even know if this single incident will be enough to make them sufficiently canny.
- ryandrake 3y agoYea it’s not perfect but it’s at least one step. Sadly, older people maybe just grew up in a more trusting US society, and are therefore more trusting themselves. If someone calls them up and says “hi, I’m Jim, from the County courthouse, and I wanted to discuss a matter with you,” heck they might by default believe him! It sounds ludicrous to you or I but their minds are from a different era. “Telephone calls are an expensive, special thing” their 1950s mind thinks, “surely he wouldn’t call unless it was a real thing and important!” I don’t even answer the phone to begin with. Everything goes to voicemail. If it’s important, they will leave a message, and I can determine later whether they are to be believed.
- vundercind 3y ago> Sadly, older people maybe just grew up in a more trusting US society, and are therefore more trusting themselves > It sounds ludicrous to you or I but their minds are from a different era. “Telephone calls are an expensive, special thing” their 1950s mind thinks This is the key—grew up in a world where people often weren't around their phone to answer it immediately (the older ones, maybe a world in which not everyone even had a phone!) and it cost money to make long distance calls, so mass-call scams had trouble being profitable. I mean, hell, that's only not been the state of things for a relatively short time. I was still paying connection and per-minute fees for long distance calls until at least the mid '00s. I think it's seriously worth considering whether we need some more cost-friction on long distance connections. That'd be a pretty elegant way to curb this, since nobody seems willing to just force the telecoms to fix it directly.
- suzzer99 3y agoMy Dad is the most paranoid online person in the world, and still almost fell for a scam. He won't even open an online banking account because he assumes that means he can't get hacked. But then he got an email from my mom (they're divorced but still friends) that was so obviously a hack, not addressing him by name, and asking him to "help me purchases some stuffs on Amazon," and he was about to go through with it. I got the same email, and almost didn't contact my dad because I thought no way he'd fall for it. But he was just about to offer to help her buy some "stuffs" on Amazon. I'm not sure there's anything you can do, including the talk, to stop this.
- swatcoder 3y ago> a lot of people at that age are too trusting of strangers and of people who sound like authorities Barely yesterday, and probably again tomorrow, throngs of people in their twenties and thirties were borrowing money to buy digital tulips whenever some dude on Twitter posted a graph with a line going up and a stock photo of a Lamborghini. The threat of being scammed is not age-specific, although the ways people are approached and coached by scammers are sometimes different. > and let’s face it: older people have all the wealth in the world I know this is just a popular and divisive trope that pits one bunch of struggling people against another, but you must know different "older people' than I do if it rings true for you.
- rightbyte 3y agoThe best scammers are those who convince their victims that they also are scammers.
- neilk 3y agoFor my aging relatives I have set up code words to be used for actual emergencies, in case I'm impersonated over text.
- t_mann 3y agoHow did you approach this, and how successful do you think it was? Do you have any tips?
- dylan604 3y ago> With convincingly articulate LLMs on the horizon, the problem is only going to get worse and more accessible to would be scammers. Eventually, maybe we can just run any email, text, or even phone calls through our own LLM driven assistant that detects and notifies about the scam.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dhosek 3y agoMy 80+-year-old mother, being 80+ years old, still has a landline, which she still answers when there’s an unfamiliar number. However, she’s also alert enough that she apparently enjoys toying with the scammers. She got a call from someone who addressed her as “grandma” and said that he needed money because he was stuck overseas. “O⸻?” she asked using the name of my son who was in kindergarten at the time. “Yes!” the scammer asked. “Why aren’t you at your kindergarten?” she asked. The scammer hung up. I learned about the above story when I sat down to have the “the talk” with her.