6 ms·
Biden administration to forgive $5.8B student debt for 78,000 borrowers
- ninja3925 3y agoThe ability for the government to spend money it doesn’t have doesn’t cease to amaze. The deficit was $1.6T last year (over 5% of the GDP) but 2024 is starting strong.
- anon373839 3y agoThis is a different issue. This is a fix for the borrowers who were scammed by the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program, which although enshrined in law, was implemented as a massive fraud.
- nameless912 3y agoA not-insignificant part of that deficit though was programs and tax cuts from the previous administration. I agree, our government probably shouldn't be allowed to spend money it doesn't have, but the obvious solution (higher taxes, especially on the wealthy) isn't politically palatable, so every president is locked into the same pattern: start a bunch of spending, but back-load the actual expenses so the next administration has to deal with it. The deficit has gone down over the last few years, which means that we're getting more revenue and saving some money, but because deficit is an easier number to digest than change-in-deficit, we keep whinging about it rather than changing anything. And then the next administration comes in and points fingers at the previous while continuing the cycle of overspending. FWIW the current administration and Congress have done a historically slightly-above-average job of reducing the deficit, I won't call it good but it's at least not terrible. The current spending isn't the problem, it's stuff from a few years ago coming to bite us in the ass.
- ihalip 3y agoHow do tax changes from a few years back affect the current deficit? Shouldn't they be already "priced in" the budget?
- willcipriano 3y agoThe deficit is down from the highs of the pandemic spending. That's like saying the deficit is down post WW2 and taking credit for it.
- piva00 3y agoLooking at the graphs for US Budget deficit since 1980 there's a clear pattern to it, Republican administrations tend to increase it (or maintain in percentage-to-GDP), Democrats tend to lower it: Carter: year|deficit|increase|deficit-to-GDP 1977 $54 $78 2.6% 1978 $59 $73 2.5% 1979 $41 $55 1.6% 1980 $74 $81 2.6% 1981 $79 $90 2.5% Reagan + Bush Sr.: 1981 $79 $90 2.5% 1982 $128 $144 3.8% 1983 $208 $235 5.7% 1984 $185 $195 4.6% 1985 $212 $251 4.9% 1986 $221 $302 4.8% 1987 $150 $225 3.1% 1988 $155 $252 3.0% 1989 $153 $255 2.7% 1990 $221 $376 3.7% 1991 $269 $432 4.4% 1992 $290 $399 4.5% Clinton: 1992 $290 $399 4.5% 1993 $255 $347 3.7% 1994 $203 $281 2.8% 1995 $164 $281 2.1% 1996 $107 $251 1.3% 1997 $22 $188 0.3% 1998 ($69) $113 (0.8%) 1999 ($126) $130 (1.3%) 2000 ($236) $18 (2.3%) Bush Jr.: 2000 ($236) $18 (2.3%) 2001 ($128) $133 (1.2%) 2002 $158 $421 1.4% 2003 $378 $555 3.3% 2004 $413 $596 3.4% 2005 $318 $554 2.4% 2006 $248 $574 1.8% 2007 $161 $501 1.1% 2008 $459 $1,017 3.1% 2009 $1,413 $1,885 9.8% Obama: 2009 $1,413 $1,885 9.8% 2010 $1,294 $1,652 8.6% 2011 $1,300 $1,229 8.3% 2012 $1,077 $1,276 6.6% 2013 $680 $672 4.0% 2014 $485 $1,086 2.8% 2015 $442 $327 2.4% 2016 $585 $1,423 3.1% Trump: 2017 $665 $671 3.4% 2018 $779 $1,271 3.8% 2019 $984 $1,203 4.6% 2020 $3,132 $4,226 15.0% 2021 $2,772 $1,484 12.1%
- willcipriano 3y agoThere was what? 5 years in the past 50 that there wasn't a deficit? Those 5 years were when the internet went mainstream and lifetime welfare was ended. The rest of the time is occupied by bipartisan wars that we couldn't afford and lost anyway.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoI think when they made that comment they were talking about the rate of change, ie, whether % of GDP is trending upwards or downwards, not specifically looking at the Clinton administration.
- silverquiet 3y agoAmaze isn't the word I'd use, but Keynes did say something rather profound - "anything we can actually do we can afford". I think of the economy a bit like the power grid; it's really a just-in-time system that can only deliver productive capacity in real-time (though this analogy is changing with grid-scale power storage). In some sense, money is just an abstraction on top of that. Or I have no idea what I'm talking about, but also I don't think economists really have that good of a handle on things either.
- thelastparadise 3y ago> it's really a just-in-time system that can only deliver productive capacity in real-time It's a sophisticated game of monopoly where select few players can coopt the productive capacity of the labor class.
- js8 3y agoI think the best analogy for money is blood. From the perspective of a household (a cell), or a company (an organ), money (blood) are a limited resource, which constraints what you can do. If you don't have that resource, you will die. But from the perspective of the state (the organism) or the government (CNS), money (blood) is just an accounting and distribution mechanism for real resources, which are things like energy, raw materials and labor (oxygen, minerals and sugar). From this perspective, amount of money/blood can be adapted to conditions (for example in emergency, money/blood can be redirected to vital industries/organs), and it is created or destroyed internally, in any amount required. So the amount of money (blood) is not a constraint, resources (oxygen, food) are.
- skhunted 3y agoThe government isn’t spending money it doesn’t have. It does spend money it borrows from lenders. The lenders think it is a relatively safe investment since they keep lending money to the U.S. government. I’ve been hearing doom and gloom about the deficit for 50 years. It primarily occurs when a Democrat is President and subsides when a Republican is President. This not a reference to OP. I state this to try to give some perspective to those who read this.
- thelastparadise 3y agoDebt to GDP over 100% and growing exponentially is new (outside WWII).
- skhunted 3y agoThe debt to gdp ratio in Japan has been well over 100% for decades. In fact it is over 200%. What matters is the ability to service the debt. Those buying U.S. government securities are not as alarmed as you. Do you have reason to believe that they are lacking in knowledge/understanding of the situation and are wrong? They could be making huge mistakes with their willingness to lend but I don’t know enough about this stuff to decide if that is the case. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_Japan
- thelastparadise 3y agoYes and Japan's economy has been extremely stagnant in that time.
- TimMeade 3y agoThe government is borrowing the majority of the funds from the FED. From itself. They are printing it and loaning it to themselves.
- skhunted 3y agoYou don’t understand how these things work. The FED conducts auctions for securities that entities purchase. Without entities buying the securities there would be no money for the government to borrow.
- vmfunction 3y agoAs long as $ is the global reserve currency, these number are pretty much meaningless. Not to say it will be this way forever. We already can see other countries are doing everything they can to trade commodities in their own respective currencies (Russia, India, Japan, etc). It is actually a great effort to forgive student loans. In US it is one of most debilitating factor for people who went to college (especially the private ones). Why not do this earlier but wait for an election year? This just looks like a election campaign stunt to me.
- trust_bt_verify 3y agoYour final point feels poorly researched. I believe this administration has consistently focused on the student loan crisis outside of election years also.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoEven crazier is that Biden's spending is more fiscally balanced than Trump's proposals. Trump proposes to increase the deficit by $5.3 trillion. https://twitter.com/BrianCDeese/status/1768337427570061737 https://twitter.com/BrianCDeese/status/1768337427570061737
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AmVess 3y ago[flagged]
- anon373839 3y ago[flagged]
- AmVess 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 3y ago"Please don't comment on whether someone read an article." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- rayiner 3y ago> The Biden administration has worked to fix those issues. > Prior to Biden’s fixes to PSLF, just around 7,000 borrowers had received debt relief through the over 15-year-old program, according to the administration. Since 2021, it said, 871,000 borrowers have now had their debt canceled under the program. This is a weird comparison that overlooks that the 10-year period begins at repayment, which is typically at graduation. If you entered college in 2007, graduated in 2011, and made 10 years of payments to become eligible for forgiveness, your first year of eligibility would’ve been 2021. Also, Obama federalized student loans in 2010, vastly increasing the number of loans eligible for PLSF. Lots of people who got masters degrees or JDs starting in 2010 became eligible for PLSF since 2021.
- skhunted 3y agoYour analysis is missing two major things. PSLF started in 2007 but wasn’t just for new borrowers. The first year people could have qualified for forgiveness was in 2017. The vast majority of people who applied for forgiveness between 2017 and 2021 were denied. The reason so few people were qualifying before the program and rules were streamlined was because the rules were confusing and obtuse. Also servicers misled people by telling them they were in the program when they weren’t. The Dept of Ed under Trump’s secretary went out of the way to block loan forgiveness under another program. I say this to give an example of how bad things were run for some programs. Prior to the current secretary of Ed these things were a shitshow. They still are to some extent but much less so.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- franciscop 3y agoAs a non-American, the "loan forgiveness" seems crazy if you don't address the root issue, which is giving large loans for people who will never be able to repay them. By forgiving the loans you have basically the worst of both worlds; you have an unbounded education cost that just keeps rising like crazy (vs a gvmt-funded university where the gvmt sets the budget), a lot of people who won't qualify and have their lives ruined, AND crazy amounts of taxpayers money to pay those off (which is inflated, see first point). Feels a lot like the Cobra Effect [1]. All of this to avoid... free education for all with taxpayers money? Because that's socialism? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#The_original_cobra_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#The_origina...
- beej71 3y agoPSLF is the only thing that makes it economically viable to pursue several critical careers, such as teaching. From time to time, people call for its demise, but this would be a very bad idea. The only way we should ever get rid of it is if we return higher education to affordability.