3 ms·
Can someone please explain why this is bad to me or my company, who don't offer a paid, hosted Redis installation? As far as I can see, this license means that
by stavros 3y ago
Can someone please explain why this is bad to me or my company, who don't offer a paid, hosted Redis installation? As far as I can see, this license means that Redis the company gets some exclusivity on who can run a hosted version of their product, and everybody else gets it for gratis, with source we can change libre.
- bawolff 3y agoIts no longer open source, if being open source isn't one of your requirements then it probably doesn't directly effect you. It might indirectly effect you as some free labour from the open source community might dry up. E.g. your linux distro might no longer package it and you might have to rely on packages maintained by redis which might not be as well integrated into your distro (although lots of users probably don't care about that)
- ForHackernews 3y ago"open source" has always been a marketing term. It doesn't mean anything because it's never meant anything. The GNU people fought the good fight on free/libre software, but they lost because companies are greedy and devs are lazy at their day jobs.
- bawolff 3y agoThe people who coined the term (OSI) gave a definition when they coined the term. That definition is almost universally accepted in the software world. Redis no longer meets that definition. Just because something is a marketing term doesn't mean its meaningless. You can't sell non free range eggs as "free range" simply because its a marketing term. Etc
- jen20 3y agoThe term “free range” is almost meaningless when buying eggs - even the opening paragraph of Wikipedia explains this: “Free-range eggs are eggs produced from birds that may be permitted outdoors. The term "free-range" may be used differently depending on the country and the relevant laws, and is not regulated in many areas.” Bad choice of example!
- JackSlateur 3y agoIt is far from a marketing term : opensources products can be used without talking to legal departements. For big compagnies, this a game-changer because you can spare yourself months of "work".
- kelnos 3y ago> opensources products can be used without talking to legal departements. Pretty much every company I've worked at has wanted legal signoff for use of any open source project. Granted, compliance with that directive was often spotty. But some did have a tool to scan our repositories for dependencies, and flag things that had licenses not on an approved list (which, no, was not the entirety of OSI-approved licenses).
- jen20 3y agoAGPL is an “open source” license per OSI - I assure you if you use code licensed under it at many big companies, you might avoid a meeting with legal but will instead get one with HR…
- ForHackernews 3y ago> For big compagnies, this a game-changer because you can spare yourself months of "work". I believe I already stipulated that companies are greedy and devs are lazy. I hope you don't consider your comment a counterargument.
- piaste 3y ago> E.g. your linux distro might no longer package it and you might have to rely on packages maintained by redis which might not be as well integrated into your distro (although lots of users probably don't care about that) This might be me living in a bubble, but OS packages for this kind of server software really feel like a relic the past. Containers have been around for a decade and we now have tools like podman that run without privileges or daemons. I run my freakin' Raspberry Pi 4GB as a pure container host, just because it makes the system cleaner and more reliable at almost no cost. Now I'm sure some people still want to `apt install redis`, for example to squeeze every last ounce of performance out of hardware, and more power to them if that's what gives them the best results. But Debian maintainers have to do a lot of dull, unfun work to update, test, and bugfix native packages for Redis and Mongo and RabbitMQ and... is that really a good use of their precious, unpaid time? To make the UX and performance only slightly better than 'podman run redis'?
- vineyardmike 3y agoIt’s not “open source” now. Your view on its impact is orthogonal to this reality. People’s view on this reality is orthogonal to its impact Personally, I’ve grown tired of this debate. Redis is clearly commercial software. None of my “freedoms” rely on redis, the way they might on more core or primitive softwares like Linux, Bash, or a browser. The real (but non-exclusive) value of the invention lies in commercial applications. I’ll bring out my “it’s not OSS” pitchfork when VI or eMacs changes their licenses. I care deeply about open source software, but not all source code matters. Contributing is a thankless task that benefits people’s profit driven interests. It’s understandable that contributors would like to try for some of that profit, and this doesn’t seem to be too aggressive either. Yea, the relationship changed, because they were “giving it away” prior. But so what, life is full of changes. There is only a handful of organizations this will impact and they’re all rich corporations that don’t need my pity. The project is mature, so most remaining work is likely feature adds required by mega-scale and niche commercial uses cases, that’s just not work people usually do for fun. Pardon my aggression - it’s rhetorical- but redis doesn’t need to exist in this world. It certainly doesn’t need anyone’s emotions.
- stavros 3y agoWell, if you've grown tired of this debate, maybe I shouldn't reply, but maybe someone else wants to have it: Sure, it's not OSI-OSS, but what does that mean for the world, in practical terms? OSI-defined OSS means "comes with no restrictions, except maybe redistribution", whereas this license adds another restriction (you can't run the software as a service without offering the source, as I understand it). How does this restriction affect us? It surely can't be that OSS as defined by the OSI is the only good thing, and anything else is horrible, it has to be a continuum. Why is this license so bad, when it only affects AWS? How are my liberties being restricted? It doesn't really answer anything to say "it's not open source", because that just implies that we already agree on why that's bad.
- jeltz 3y agoThat Redis cannot be included in many Linux distributions anymore. Is that enough of a practical impact?
- sakjur 3y agoIt opens you up to a larger litigation surface. Previously, you didn’t risk having to explain to a court that you’re really not offering Redis as a service even though your service is using Redis. Copyleft licenses are limited to the software itself, but SSPL expands this to ”including, without limitation, management software, user interfaces, application program interfaces, automation software, monitoring software, backup software, storage software and hosting software”. If there’s even the tiniest risk of having to comply with that, I’d stay clear of anything SSPL licensed.
- stavros 3y agoThat makes sense, thank you.