2 ms·
ELI5: Why does direct banking not work in America?
- al_borland 3y agoI’ve always found bank account numbers a bit odd. We treat them as private, but the account and routing numbers are on every check. While checks are less common now, they used to be a very common way to pay for nearly anything, including person to person. We just never got a good form of digital check in the US. I suppose that is what Zelle is supposed to be; a digital check with extra steps. I’m not sure what protections exist to prevent fraud related to using account and routing numbers, but they must be pretty decent, as the data is out there and I’ve never really heard about abuse (other than stories of Frank Abagnale Jr. forging checks long ago. I’m aware of some of the protections for physical checks as a result). ACH is used in the US for transfers like this. It uses the account and routing numbers. While it’s almost unheard of for person to person payment, it is usually a requirement for things like rent, mortgage, property taxes, and utilities (if a person plans to use auto-pay). All my utilities and my property tax are setup to auto-pay with ACH transfers. If a place like this offers a credit card option, they usually add on a very sizable fee, to a degree that no sane person would use it. Wiring money is another direct option, but it usually costs money, so it needs to be fairly important. It’s generally for time sensitive things, as it’s much faster than ACH. I needed to move some money fast between two of my own accounts and ended up wiring it to myself. This is also common for closing costs when buying a home.
- gregjor 3y agoEvery time this topic comes up the author either ignores or doesn’t know about the many solutions available in the US, and cites $35 wire transfer fees as if everyone had to do that. PayPal, Zelle, Wise, Venmo, Apple Pay, Google Pay, etc. all do person to person transfers quickly and either free or very cheap. We’ve had those for years. US banks have tended to partner with the third parties rather than push their own low-profit solution.
- simonblack 3y agoIn Australia, we have a system for figures under $30,000 which is practically instant. I can send money online from my bank to almost any other Australian bank account number by direct credit. Figures larger than $30,000 usually have to wait till the night-time batch-processing. For that reason, the most recent Australian cheque I wrote was about 10 years ago. Most people use their phones for online banking here. I prefer a nice big 4K TV screen as a monitor which can give me lots of information at a glance. The principle is the same though. OSKO or PayID: https://www.westpac.com.au/personal-banking/online-banking/making-the-most/payid/ https://www.westpac.com.au/personal-banking/online-banking/m...