3 ms·
> Distracted parenting: Nearly half of teens (46%) say their parent is at least sometimes distracted by their phone when they’re trying to talk to them. This i
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Distracted parenting: Nearly half of teens (46%) say their parent is at least sometimes distracted by their phone when they’re trying to talk to them.
This is heartbreaking. How can parents guide their kids to not become addicted to smartphones when they themselves are addicted? We really need a taboo-reset. Sitting there zombied-out, neck crooked and hunched over your smartphone, dopamine-loading, should be considered as disgusting as sitting there with a heroin needle hanging out of your arm. Society needs to set a better example for the next generation.
- frankbreetz 3y agoMaybe they were taking a day off work made only possible by being available. Maybe they were reading a book. Maybe they were planning dinners for the week. Maybe they were scheduling a play date for their kids. We do everything on our phones. I think 46% of parents being distracted sometimes by any of those things is not at all problematic. Maybe kids can learn to wait 2 minutes.
- jjulius 3y ago>Maybe they were taking a day off work made only possible by being available. That's not a day off work, then. >I think 46% of parents being distracted sometimes by any of those things is not at all problematic. Maybe kids can learn to wait 2 minutes. If you read the article and not just the HN quote, the full sentence is, "teens who say their parent is distracted by their phone while having a conversation with them." This isn't a child approaching their parent and the waiting for them to stop reading or working on a grocery list before they start chatting, this is a parent losing focus in the middle of a conversation because of whatever is on their screen. I think we're all pretty aware, and have seen, this behavior firsthand and how distracted people are by their phones in such a scenario. You don't stop listening to your kid mid-convo just to read a sentence in a book, do you? No, you take that moment (the "two minutes" you alluded to) to come to a nice spot to pause and then give them your attention. Doesn't sound like that's what's happening here. >We do everything on our phones. We don't have to.
- frankbreetz 3y ago>We don't have to. I don't understand this. Should I carry around a backpack with a music player, several book, video camera, and planner? Would that be a better situation, then periodically looking at my phone?
- ryandrake 3y ago> Would that be a better situation, then periodically looking at my phone? Inconvenience aside, I think it would at least result in fewer of these distraction scenarios happening, since there are existing taboos against picking up a book, newspaper, music player, or camera mid-conversation and ignoring people to do these things, but somehow there is still no equivalent taboo about phone use.
- jjulius 3y agoYou're free to do what you want - if you want to do all of that in your phone, go for it! There's no judgement from me. I was just pointing out that we don't have to be doing that. For me (and this is just me), I actually like taking the time to write out and plan meals on a notepad that I schlep (though it doesn't really feel like schlepping to me) to the grocery store. I hold/read a thick, 500-page Pynchon novel at lunch every day. I have an older Canon DSLR that I take backpacking with me, and keep a smaller point-and-shoot in my pocket if I'm closer to home but feel like I'll want to take photos. I use my phone for streaming, but there's still a small stack of CDs that I keep in my car and rotate out because I collect those (to say nothing of the hundreds and hundreds of vinyl records that my CDs sit next to at home). I like those tangible things because the experience is focused on that task at hand. I like touching those things, manipulating them. I like tools that are designed to do "one" thing and do it well. I don't like staring at a small screen, and I find it much easier to devote adequate attention to things if I don't have my phone around. I can focus on thinking about the photo I'm taking, the music I'm listening to, or the recipe I'm trying to come up with without a ton of notifications about random bullshit that doesn't matter in that moment popping into my face. Hell, I like the smell of a book and the way that it's just me and the story when I read from one. None of that feels inconvenient to me and, honestly (and respectfully I should add), I struggle with the idea that it boggles peoples minds that such things seem so terribly cumbersome that they "don't understand" doing it that way when the reality is that's how things have always been done, and smartphones have only allowed us to do things differently for ~20-ish years. Regarding the backpack comment, that's really not that much weight in a pack, and if you're already carrying a bag with a laptop for work then no big deal IMO. But when you think about it, do you really need to bring "several" books, a video camera, a music player and a planner with you everywhere you go? Why not just leave the house with only what you need to do whatever it is you're setting out to do? But that's just me. The "better situation" will always be what works for you, though I certainly think there's truth to what another user[0] said as well. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39780496 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39780496
- nytesky 3y agoLet’s be honest, a lot of time with kids is quite boring. Dads reading the newspaper at the table has been a a thing forever. Moms reading a book, crocheting, or doing dishes/cooking while interacting with kids was common. In the 80s, the TV was ALWAYS on in the background. Maybe the radio or NPR in the 70s? I would say the phone is probably better than the background TV, but worse than the rest. But being a working parent is a slog, with very little personal time. 40 hours of a job, 3-5 hrs of commute, then picking up kids, making dinner, cleaning up after them or nagging them to clean up, driving around to activities. Sitting down and scrolling hacker news is a peaceful release. I’ve driven my kids for about 4 hours today, and my day ended at 930 when they finally got home and went to their room to finish homework. Kids are a lot of work for most of the 18 years, not just the baby years.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoThis is almost certainly overblown, or at least nothing new I can't think of how many times my parents would be reading a book or watching TV, or talking on the phone, or otherwise busy doing something when I walked up to them and tried to talk to them I learned pretty young that they weren't going to drop everything and give me their full attention at my every whim
- irjustin 3y agoNot sure if you have kids, but I am guilty of this. I used to think exactly like you, especially leading up to the birth of our first. You see in restaurants the parent glued to their phone and the child happily doing whatever. It is sad, even as I think about it now - it is sad. But, I've become more lenient/understanding over time after having children. It is simply unrealistic to be a the beck and call of your child(ren) 100% of the time. It's quite hard for me to want to play with my children for extended periods. Not sure why. It could be my mild ADHD; my desire for something more intellectual? I just get so tired when I'm with them, and after they go to sleep, I'm so awake. I finally understood why so many people say "work is easier than being with your kids". Don't get me wrong, I love my kids so much. It's just the idealism vs reality of parenting is very very far. I'm extremely thankful to my wife who reminds me to put my phone away, and it makes me extremely annoyed to be corrected. Obviously, I need it. Life isn't easy especially raising kids.
- 14 3y agoThis is a good take. I have also stayed single for a LONG time due to having children and separating from their mom and not wanting to not be available for them. I stayed single for over 4 years and gave all my time to my kids. But after a while I realized, as well as them getting older, that I too deserve to get out and have someone in my life to love me. Still working on the love life but do get out with friends a bit more often than I used to and my kids see how much healthier I am taking me time and being active and having a social life.
- mmmpetrichor 3y agoI think the study was talking about teens, which is actually ridiculous because I think most teens are on their phones 1000% more than adults, and a survey of teens saying their parents don't listen enough is hilarious. But I identify 100% with your post, that's the reality of every parent with younger kids. You connect with them at one level and its amazing, but they're children and you aren't. It's exhausting to stay on their level for long. If I'm forced to put it in terms most HN readers without real life adult experience will understand, there's an impedance mismatch.
- ryandrake 3y ago
- mmmpetrichor 3y agoAre you a parent? Do you know any parents? Do you know any drug addicted parents? Do you know any parents with smartphones? The analogy you made is just terrible hyperbole and counterproductive to any real conversation.