3 ms·

> Wouldn’t it have been cheaper to do this with VFX? Yes but this seems much more fun

balls187 3y ago
From the write up, it’s hard to see that this was fun. It seems more like Chris Rock’s joke about driving a car with your feet.
- ok_dad 3y ago
  The fun is the sense of accomplishment for doing something difficult or extraordinary. Humans have been doing not-fun things forever for that reason alone sometimes.
  - jauntywundrkind 3y ago
    Something hackers repudely excel at, taking on difficult feats for the heck of it & because we humanity are great & we can.
    - balls187 3y ago
      Valve Software is hardly "hackers." They used a setup from TI, which I had the priveledge of attending this past year at CPA--one of the most stupidest overpriced venues in the US. This isn't a rag tag band of rebel filmmakers.
  - balls187 3y ago
    > The fun is the sense of accomplishment for doing something difficult or extraordinary. I think that was the issue--the write up did not go into the details, which makes it seem like what they did was neither difficult nor extraordinary, especially if you factor in that Valve has practically unlimited amount of money to spend, a deep pool of talented employees with nothing better to do, and no deadlines.
    - ok_dad 3y ago
      Yea the details were lacking but this is a cool project which took someone’s time and creativity. Whether or not it was an accomplishment for them or valve on a grand scale doesn’t matter, you folks don’t have to shit on it because it wasn’t mind blowing. I swear, nothing impresses hacker news commenters, Dropbox included.
- jeeva 3y ago
  It's possible that if you don't find it fun, it's not for you. I had fun reading about it; would probably have had fun doing it. No worries if that doesn't match up!
- numpad0 3y ago
  people are paid assembling cars all the time
- itishappy 3y ago
  The writeup explicitly states it was fun: > This seems fun enough — and dumb enough — to try, so we got to work. They then put it in their lobby because they thought it was cool.

From the write up, it’s hard to see that this was fun. It seems more like Chris Rock’s joke about driving a car with your feet.

ok_dad 3y ago
The fun is the sense of accomplishment for doing something difficult or extraordinary. Humans have been doing not-fun things forever for that reason alone sometimes.
- jauntywundrkind 3y ago
  Something hackers repudely excel at, taking on difficult feats for the heck of it & because we humanity are great & we can.
  - balls187 3y ago
    Valve Software is hardly "hackers." They used a setup from TI, which I had the priveledge of attending this past year at CPA--one of the most stupidest overpriced venues in the US. This isn't a rag tag band of rebel filmmakers.
- balls187 3y ago
  > The fun is the sense of accomplishment for doing something difficult or extraordinary. I think that was the issue--the write up did not go into the details, which makes it seem like what they did was neither difficult nor extraordinary, especially if you factor in that Valve has practically unlimited amount of money to spend, a deep pool of talented employees with nothing better to do, and no deadlines.
  - ok_dad 3y ago
    Yea the details were lacking but this is a cool project which took someone’s time and creativity. Whether or not it was an accomplishment for them or valve on a grand scale doesn’t matter, you folks don’t have to shit on it because it wasn’t mind blowing. I swear, nothing impresses hacker news commenters, Dropbox included.
jeeva 3y ago
It's possible that if you don't find it fun, it's not for you. I had fun reading about it; would probably have had fun doing it. No worries if that doesn't match up!
numpad0 3y ago
people are paid assembling cars all the time
itishappy 3y ago
The writeup explicitly states it was fun: > This seems fun enough — and dumb enough — to try, so we got to work. They then put it in their lobby because they thought it was cool.