7 ms·
Governor signs bills creating EV charging station network across Wisconsin
- superkuh 3y agoA good first step to the chicken and egg problem. Living in Wisconsin I have never seen an electrical charging station. >Local government entities and state agencies would not be allowed to operate public charging stations but could run their own stations to charge their vehicles. I'm confused at why this was included in the regulation. Would companies really refuse to build stations without this stipulation? It reminds me a lot of telecommunications companies lobbying hard against municipal and related telecommunications services.
- zdragnar 3y ago> in Wisconsin I have never seen an electrical charging station As per the article, in Wisconsin any company that did would be regulated as a utility company; the law makes exemptions so non-utilities can set them up. > Would companies really refuse to build stations without this stipulation? The funds that are freed up are federal funds. No idea if that's a result of the above deregulation, or if those funds can't be used directly by municipalities. Either way, as a business owner I'd be hard pressed to invest in putting chargers in my parking lot if the city came along and put in a bunch for street level parking.
- BooneJS 3y agoMG&E built one on the Madison isthmus[0], but they’re already a utility company. [0]: https://www.mge.com/lovev/charging/charge-go#/find/nearest?country=US&location=Madison,%20WI https://www.mge.com/lovev/charging/charge-go#/find/nearest?c...
- upheaval7276 3y agoI think I’ve seen them in Kohl’s parking lots… but that’s about it.
- iamjake648 3y agoEau Claire, WI - a pretty small town has at least three DCFC - EA, Tesla & a local electric company plus tons of level 2 all over. > I'm confused at why this was included in the regulation The WI GOP. At least you can pay by the kWh in WI now instead of by the minute with this law.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoEau Claire is the biggest settlement at the junction point where Minneapolis travelers either go to Wausau and the UP, or to Milwaukee/Chicago.
- iamjake648 3y agoYea I guess I'm just surprised OP hasn't seen any. The junction point explains the fast chargers, but the Level 2 would presumably be used primarily by locals. I mean even middle of nowhere cities like Ellsworth are getting DCFC - granted at a dealership, but still it's happening! https://www.plugshare.com/location/560842 https://www.plugshare.com/location/560842
- sib 3y ago>> A good first step to the chicken and egg problem. Living in Wisconsin I have never seen an electrical charging station. There are approximately 35 active Tesla Supercharger stations with almost 300 individual chargers in Wisconsin. (More than I would have guessed...)
- Tagbert 3y agoThey do not stand out as much as a whole gas station so it can be easy to miss charging stations. Once you start looking though, they are much more common than you might think. In any case, what matters, if you aren’t charging at home, is that you can find chargers using an app or the car’s navigation system.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoSmall towns have set up speed traps on highways passing nearby so much that many states have enacted laws to restrict the ability of such towns to annex land for this purpose. Since EV chargers aren't a natural monopoly, local governments could use their power of zoning and other regulations to create an artificial monopoly for themselves over EV charging. State enterprises also have a history of being inefficient when they can lock out non-state competitors or drive those competitors out of business through state power. State ownership of utilities are a mixed bag but at least they're generally answerable to those in their service area. Due to the transient nature of vehicles needing charging, it's not difficult to see some small towns that happen to be near road junctions setting themselves up as the only charging choice in the area. Maybe you have enough charge left to bypass pass the chargers that are 25% more expensive than the state average. Or maybe you just stop and pay it.
- Upvoter33 3y agoDoes this mean Tesla charging or ... ?
- Moto7451 3y agoEventually it’s all NACS/J3400 in North America, which is the “Tesla Charger” but the J1772 wire protocol and some additions to help adoption. For example, you can run two phases from commercial 480v three phase commercial power to charge at 270v. As a J1772 equipped driver, I don’t mind eventually needing an adapter since I don’t personally use DC fast charging very often.
- ortusdux 3y agoI'll note that this is part of FHWA and DOE's Alternate Fuel Corridors program, and many states applied for and got similar grants. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/alternative_fuel_corridors/ https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/alternative_fuel_corrid... https://afdc.energy.gov/corridors https://afdc.energy.gov/corridors Personally, I'm glad most of the money seems to be going to electric charging stations vs hydrogen and alternate hydrocarbon fueling stations. I would have preferred if the program had focused on installing charging stations at the ~1400 highway rest stations across the country vs giving grants to business to help them install stations.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLook where Tesla puts their Superchargers [1]. There’s a reason they go at businesses instead of rest areas. If you site them where they are at the whim of politics, your infra is in constant political/bureaucratic peril. Businesses are incentivized to keep customers coming. Tangentially, the EV chargers are always out of order at O’hare and Midway airport parking lots. The Superchargers at the nearby gas station (ORD) [2] and the Target (MDW) [3] are always available. Tesla is incentivized to offer a highly available charging network (they don’t move EVs or receive revenue from other automakers otherwise); you want folks with an incentive to provide high uptime to own and operate these stations. [1] https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map [2] https://www.tesla.com/findus/location/supercharger/chicagoiloharesupercharger https://www.tesla.com/findus/location/supercharger/chicagoil... [3] https://www.tesla.com/findus/location/supercharger/ChicagoILSupercharger https://www.tesla.com/findus/location/supercharger/ChicagoIL...
- gottorf 3y ago> where they are at the whim of politics, your infra is in constant political/bureaucratic peril Whims like this: https://apnews.com/article/new-york-rest-stops-chick-fil-a-17e5a44140f0cb383fa31429bf66184b https://apnews.com/article/new-york-rest-stops-chick-fil-a-1...
- toomuchtodo 3y ago
- Stealthisbook 3y agoYou have to wonder where they're finding contractors to competently build these and maintain them. Electrify America has a bad reputation for offline and broken stations, and Tesla might not bid on a contract like this. It would be cool if they built state capacity to just have charging stations.
- yieldcrv 3y ago[flagged]
- triceratops 3y agoYou mean the lack of one? Or the possibility of one?
- yieldcrv 3y agoThe currently undermaintained commercial ones that follow the federal standard are bad, I suspect it will be a steep bell curve down in quality for a state charging system that follows federal standards
- nunez 3y agoGOOD! I wish anti-EV states would follow suit. EV chargers are a landmine for business/income taxes. Unlike a gas station, people have to wait at least 15 minutes to charge their vehicle. You could have TikTok-theaters (theaters that show trending videos across TikTok), pop-ups, restaurants, etc.
- xyst 3y ago> You could have TikTok-theaters (theaters that show trending videos across TikTok), pop-ups, restaurants, etc. Thanks, I hate it. So you want to turn these ev charging spots into the equivalent of strip malls and billboards.
- sib 3y ago>> EV chargers are a landmine for business/income taxes I think you mean a goldmine for business & income taxes?
- nunez 3y agolol, i sure did.
- throwaway48476 3y agoMy city spent a stupid amount of money to build 13 slow chargers across the city based on public feedback. I have zero faith that this will fare any better. The best EV charger is the one installed in the home. If the government actually wanted to spur adoption it would be through easing permitting and creating boilerplate contract language for apartment and condo chargers.
- m463 3y agoI tried traveling with a nissan leaf ev (24kwh) a couple years ago, and it was COMPLETELY impractical. It was just a stupid leap of faith with giant portions of luck and silly time wasting. 3rd party charging services suck. They have few chargers, they have few stalls and terrible information about them. (The worst was blink, virtually always broken) And then I tried a couple years later with tesla, and it was a completely different experience. Telsas have large batteries, the chargers are very plentiful along most routes, have many stalls, and are dependable. I came to realize having a non-telsa ev is really a waste of time unless you can charge at home and stay in range. So anything to create a reliable network to travel I think is a good idea (for non-tesla cars)
- i80and 3y agoI traveled round trip between NJ and MI last year using Electrify America with my ID.4. It was fine, no real pain points -- EA's been improving pretty aggressively in my experience, and I think we're broadly in pretty good shape. I charge exclusively using public chargers.
- Tagbert 3y agoYour experience with a Leaf just showed you that old technology in a vehicle with a small battery and slow charging is best for local travel and not good for road tripping. There is a place for such vehicles but the highway is not it. Today, there are lots of much more advanced EVs from dozens of makers that have large range and faster charging. Over the next year, they are all switching over to a new standard charging connection (which was developed by Tesla. Props). The CCS charging network will also be switching over to j3400. Hopefully this increased competition will force more of them to properly maintain their networks or be replaced.
- xyst 3y agoI hate how we are doubling down on car centric transportation. Whether it’s an ICE or EV. At the end of the day, it’s another car on the road. We take one step further with reducing or zeroing out tail pipe emissions. But take 3 steps backwards because department of ~~~highway~~~ transportation engineers feel the need to expand the expensive highways to accommodate increased demand. Ignoring all historical evidence that widening interstate highways or state regional roads is not an efficient way to resolve the issue. Let’s not forget the increased amount of tire wear particles released into the environment, brake dust, and eventually the e-waste when lithium based battery packs need to be changed out. Also where are these vehicles going to be stored? More parking garages. Less walkable infrastructure. More subsidies for the suburban rat at the expense of cities. More heavier cars, trucks, and SUVs on the road means existing infrastructure breaks down must faster. Thus the need to replace more often or maintain more often. All of this at the expense of local cities and state budgets. Also most cities tend to ask voters to approve municipal bonds for such improvements. These are private financial instruments or loans that need to be paid back to private investors. Each new muni bond is one more step towards filing for bankruptcy (hello Detroit!) Instead of spending money on the people. We are spending it on stupid car centric infrastructure. Forget mental health, social support, universal basic income, housing for everyone, easily accessible public transportation, improved paramedic, fire and police response times. We wAnT mOrE eXpEnSiVe RoAdS aNd hIgHwAyS aNd fReE pArKiNg GaRaGeS!!111
- infamouscow 3y agoMassive changes to how most people think about anything in society are non-starters. Doubly-so with something as central to the American lifestyle like transportation. I don't understand why this is so difficult for some people to grasp.
- typewithrhythm 3y agoNot everyone is a socialist, or high density enthusiast. Personally I want the local government to only spend money in ways that result in people being more independent of a dense centre, that allows people to have more control over their immediate environment, and less impact from neibours. Roads and highways are worth the expense, I am not convinced when it comes to many other public infrastructure or services.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]