3 ms·
So, living in one of those cities (AMS) I have a few takes. I'm not ranting, just expressing my frustration: 1. Cars exists because they are more comfortable.
by notarant124e348 3y ago
So, living in one of those cities (AMS) I have a few takes. I'm not ranting, just expressing my frustration:
1. Cars exists because they are more comfortable. I don't care that biking should better, it's not when it rains sideways, it's cold and windy. Biking sucks. I would pay top money to not be in a bike, not be outside getting drenched, and usually do ubering everywhere to the dismay of Dutch people,
2. Cities designed around biking are uber tied to public transport. I'm a lefty, I think that's great, but it's not, because the first time there are cuts to public service you find yourself living in the middle of nowhere and can only bike, because cars are too expensive to own. This happened in the Netherlands with NS slashing intercity trips, and increasing prices. I had colleagues now that now to live several hours per day in a packed commuter train. I can't see how that's better.
3. Any type of DIY activity becomes a nightmare. Want to rent move a couch? Good luck! Back home, you could load the thing on a nice Volvo and be happy.
4. Electric bikes are effectively not policed because it's the new thing we need to incentivize, and it becomes immediately super dangerous. I know people that had serious injuries because of crashes. Cars are inherently safer, especially modern SUV like volvos or tesla,
5. Accessibility becomes a nightmare, especially if you are in a wheelchair, your commute times are going to skyrocket,
All this "bikes are amazing" just reeks of some bad degrowth ideology. There is a duality between cars are bad and hydrocarbons are bad. Except they are literally the engine of growth, and for some reasons we decided that we should phase out hydrocarbons and replace them with some silly not reliable energy alternative (solar, wind). I can't see how this ends in a different way than how it went in Europe with our energy policy.
Cities are meant to grow and drive the economy, not to be Disneyland parks. If I want to bike I can go to Italy on a seaside town, I don't need to bike 356 days a year.
- Ekaros 3y ago> 4. Electric bikes are effectively not policed because it's the new thing we need to incentivize, and it becomes immediately super dangerous. I know people that had serious injuries because of crashes. Cars are inherently safer, especially modern SUV like volvos or tesla, Starting to get interesting in Finland. Not yet bicycles, but scooters with weight over 25kg or speed over 25km/h or 1kw will soon require insurance... And likely any bike with specs over those will also be a moped and thus require both insurance and registration... I see no reason why those sort of limitations won't come more prevevalent.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI think I agree with all your points, but I also think we should be doing all we can to encourage all those people who can and want to cycle to do so, and to make it as safe and convenient as possible. That's regardless of whether you "allow" cars to still be used. Improving cycling infrastructure is an action that causes benefits and very little in the way of disadvantages. Any journey that someone makes on a bicycle means one less car clogging up the road. That's an argument that people make who are militantly against cars, but I think it's completely valid even if you think cars are things that are here to stay and you're OK with that. Car drivers should be looking at the people cycling and silently thanking them for making their drive more pleasant because the roads are less busy. But for that to happen, the bicycles need to be able to go on dedicated cycle ways so that cars don't have to slow down to drive around them. My commute to work is about 45 minutes on the bus. Or 50 minutes walking - that's how much the buses suck, and they're actually fairly good buses as far as buses go. Or it's a 25 minute cycle. It'd be a 10-15 minute drive if there was no traffic and there was actually somewhere to park, which there isn't. I did spend about 15 years without a car, cycling everywhere I went. It was great. One time I bought a bulky item, and called a taxi for it. I dumped the item in the taxi, told the driver where to meet me, and cycled home. I made it there before the taxi did - the driver looked well annoyed. But I recognise the cars are useful - I have a car now, and it's great for heading out into the countryside in sparsely populated areas to do some hiking. It'd be unreasonable to expect any public transport out there, and the car will always have a place serving those areas. So, my argument is that we should be making things better for all, not pitting two views against each other.