11 ms·
If gravity isn't a force, then why does it "need" a boson?
- Xcelerate 3y agoGravity is a bit different than the other forces because it is the only mechanism by which all known particles interact with all other known particles (since all particles have an association with the stress-energy tensor).
- johncarlosbaez 3y agoIt's too bad the top-rated answer on Reddit says "GR does not say Gravity is not a force (or if you do say it’s not a force, then none of the other forces are forces either)" rather than explaining what people mean when they say gravity is not a force (basically, it affects the geometry of spacetime in such a way that an unaccelerated particle can still move along a path that's not a straight line in the traditional sense) and why nonetheless we can treat gravity approximately (that is, perturbatively) as if it were a force, and why this perturbative description when quantized predicts a spin-2 boson, the graviton. Oh well.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoHelp me with the last bit, where the perturbations when quantised predict spin-2 bosons.
- brylie 3y ago[flagged]
- krsrhe 3y ago[dead]
- CamperBob2 3y agoHonestly, the flagged/dead answer from ChatGPT makes a lot of sense to me. Can someone explain where it goes wrong, without resorting to the usual snide remarks about parrots and other whistling-past-the-graveyard rhetoric? Is it just making up BS regarding the attributes imparted by various spin values, or is that a reasonable explanation of why gravitons are presumed to be spin-2 particles?
- brylie 3y agoIndeed. I shared what I thought was a detailed and helpful generative response to further the discussion and hopefully receive feedback from those knowledgeable on the topic. It's disappointing to see it met with downvotes and flagging, rather than constructive conversation.
- CamperBob2 3y agoSame old story throughout history. People feel threatened by technology, and they lash out. It's disappointing here, for sure.
- codexb 3y agoI feel like it's easier to explain that gravity is a force between matter and space(time) and not necessarily between matter and matter, like we presume the other forces are.
- krsrhe 3y agoI recognize your name and believe you know what you are talking about, so please, please tell us the why! You or someone you know probable has a blog post or article you can link, maybe?
- morcus 3y agoWow I never look at usernames but maybe I should start. I believe I read his `Gauge Fields, Knots, and Gravity` back in college (or tried to, anyways. it was a touch above my level at the time)
- sandworm101 3y agoI had a prof explain it using basic analogy. Forces are things that can move other things. An electrical field can move a metal ball. So too can a metal bat. put a g-meter on the ball and it will register acceleration as force is applied to the ball. Gravity is different. Put a g-meter on a falling metal ball and it will detect zero acceleration. No force is acting upon a ball. Put that metal ball in an eccentric orbit around the earth and it will speed up and slow down during each orbit, but the g-meter will register zero acceleration. The ball falls but is no not accelerated. So gravity is not a force because it doesn't move things. Gravity is something different.
- gwd 3y agoBut the acceleration meter won't measure any force because gravity is acting on every part of it uniformly. If you had an acceleration meter entirely made out of the same magnetic substance, and you brought a magnet near it, would the acceleration meter register anything, or would it read zero acceleration, since all parts of it were being acted on uniformly (and thus didn't "notice" any acceleration)?
- gwd 3y ago(Replying to myself) I guess one answer to this is that particles which are (supposedly?) massless, like the photon, are affected by the space-time warping effects of gravity. A parallel construction wouldn't be true of magnetism or an electric field. Furthermore, when we detect gravity waves, they come at the same time as corresponding gamma ray bursts; since the gamma rays are affected by the space-time warping effects of gravity, this means that the gravity waves themselves are affected by the space-time warping effects of gravity. So gravity probably is something else. But who knows!
- lupire 3y agoThat could also be explained by light having momentum which is affected by (but does not generate) the force of gravity acts like mass.
- 3y ago
- gnramires 3y agoI've recently learned about Kaluza–Klein theories (just curious wiki browsing), do they unify electromagnetism and gravity in the sense that electromagnetism also "works by changing the geometry of spacetime" ? How does this relate to QFT?
- elashri 3y ago> do they unify electromagnetism and gravity in the sense that electromagnetism also "works by changing the geometry of spacetime" ? Yes, somehow actually. KK theories introduce an extra spatial dimension beyond our usual (3+1) which is postulated to be "compactified". This just means that it's curled up on itself at such a tiny scale that we don't directly perceive it. The way this extra dimension is curled and shaped affects the geometry of the overall 5-D spacetime. How it is connected to EM is that now these geometrical variations in the 5-D spacetime, when viewed from our 4-D perspective, manifest as the EM force and its associated field. So you can say like in GR which have gravity arises as consequence of geometry, it is in KK that EM is consequence of geometry. However, the geometry and details are different. > How does this relate to QFT? Not much in the sense that they can provide useful information to each other. QFT describes forces in terms of interactions mediated by particles (e.g., photons for EM). KK, while primarily geometrical, give hints that perhaps these force-carrying particles can be associated with specific vibrational modes of the extra dimension. Of course KK theory only include EM and gravity. So we know for sure that we need to go beyond KK. This was the actual motivation for people to think about string theory to expand the original KK work.
- Karellen 3y ago> KK theories introduce an extra spatial dimension beyond our usual (3+1) which is postulated to be "compactified". This just means that it's curled up on itself You've just explained "compactified" in terms of being "curled up", but that doesn't really help (for me, at least). What does it mean for a dimension to be "curled up"?
- elashri 3y agoI'm sorry if I'm confusing. That's the term I use, usually assuming that it is obvious (like referring to C++ templates to a python developer without explaining what is that). To be honest, it is hard to visualize, as it is counterintuitive of what we think of space. While I know many people would disagree, I really like the garden hose analogy [1]. The idea is to simply imagine a very long garden hose. From a great distance, it looks like a one-dimensional line. Now you get closer, and realize it has a second dimension, which is its circumference curled around that seemingly 1-D line. An ant walking on the hose can move along its length, but also in a circle around it. The extra dimension in KK is like this circumference. It is tiny, curled up so we don't directly notice it, but still potentially there. [1] https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2004/06/30/extra-dimensions/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2004/06/30/extra-d...
- lubesGordi 3y agoWhat does it mean to 'treat gravity approximately (that is, perturbatively)'? That sounds like something we do to model, which only approximates reality. That model sounds like it shouldn't be used to predict anything else? Or at least whatever is predicted shouldn't be expected to exist in 'reality'.
- canjobear 3y agoIt’s models all the way down.
- nyrikki 3y agoJohn von Neumann: "... the sciences do not try to explain, they hardly even try to interpret, they mainly make models. By a model is meant a mathematical construct which, with the addition of certain verbal interpretations, describes observed phenomena. The justification of such a mathematical construct is solely and precisely that it is expected to work—that is, correctly to describe phenomena from a reasonably wide area." Both GR and QFT are insanely accurate models, but they are just models. The N-body problem is undecidable, and Gödel, Turing, Church and other s proved that is the best we can do. https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/13175/1/parker2003.pdf https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/13175/1/parker2003.pdf Western reductionism or Laplacian determinism is a good framework for practical, computable models. QFT actually is actually one of the counterexamples to Western reductionism. But models are reductive and scientific models are just models. Don't confuse the map for the territory. All models are wrong, some are useful; is another way of saying the same thing.
- arter 3y agoCould you elaborate or share some articles on why QFT is a counterexample to western reductionism ? In laymans terms that is.
- nyrikki 3y agoThe oversimplified version is Laplac's deamon can't split quantum superposition. Superposition being inseparable is a large part on why the many words concept is popular with some people. It is about regaining a form of determinism.
- pdonis 3y agoI think that more generally the answer is not responsive to the actual question, which is: why do GR and QM need to be unified? To be fair, the question itself wrongly conflates "gravity needs a gauge boson" with the question about GR and QM being unified. Not all theories of quantum gravity involve a "gauge boson" for gravity along the lines of the other Standard Model interactions. Nor does the basic rationale for why we think gravity needs to be quantized involve a "gauge boson". It involves simple reasoning about how QM works. Say we have an experiment which puts an object with non-negligible stress-energy into a superposition of being in two different positions (for example, we make its position depend on the outcome of a spin measurement on a qubit). QM would say that spacetime would then need to also be in a superposition of two different geometries. But GR, as a classical theory, has no way to handle that. We would need a quantum theory of gravity, i.e., a quantum theory that can handle superpositions of different spacetime geometries.
- trhway 3y ago>Say we have an experiment which puts an object with non-negligible stress-energy into a superposition of being in two different positions (for example, we make its position depend on the outcome of a spin measurement on a qubit). QM would say that spacetime would then need to also be in a superposition of two different geometries. The energy to move the object into a given position is an additional element here unaccounted for in your model. 2 different positions to move object into - 2 different energies (more specifically 2 different changes to the starting, before the experiment, stress energy distribution of the Universe). When corresponding moving energies (ie. their GR effects) are accounted for in those 2 cases it may as well be that those 2 cases are indistinguishable from the GR point of view, ie. those 2 supposedly different spacetime geometries happen to be the same. The superposition of 2 indistinguishable cases - it doesn't really matter is it superposition or not.
- qnleigh 3y agoThere is an entire sub-field of experimental science that involves putting ever larger objects in superpositions of different locations. These experiments are no closer to testing quantum gravity, but they falsify whatever it is you're trying to say here. See https://www.nature.com/articles/srep13884 https://www.nature.com/articles/srep13884 for a random example.
- me_me_me 3y agoit would be so much easier to visualize it if we could imagine 4th dimension.
- layer8 3y agoYou can say similar things about the field of the other forces too, though. The path of a charged particle in the EM field could be described as that particle experiencing a different space-time geometry, arising from the EM and gravitational field combined, and thus EM could also be seen as a geometry and not a force. In fact, the impulse of photons, which are vibrations in the EM field, does affect the curvature of space-time, similar to how particles with mass do.
- pdonis 3y ago> The path of a charged particle in the EM field could be described as that particle experiencing a different space-time geometry No, it can't, because the EM interaction does not obey the equivalence principle, as gravity does. The geometric interpretation of gravity relies on the equivalence principle. To state this another way: if I put two objects with different masses at a given point in spacetime and give them both the same initial velocity in the same direction, their paths through spacetime under gravity will be the same. But if I put two objects with different charges at a given point in the same electromagnetic field and give them both the same initial velocity in the same direction, their paths through spacetime will not be the same. And this remains true even if I add "extra dimensions" to "spacetime" along the lines of Kaluza-Klein theory, to represent the EM field.
- Biganon 3y agoWoaw, a top comment by John Carlos Baez himself!
- machina_ex_deus 3y agoNon gravity forces are quite linear and simple, the coupling with fermions is only through covariant derivative. Gravity is extremely non linear, when you look at the expression for Ricci tensor, it is much more complicated than other forces.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pizzafeelsright 3y agoI like to think of gravity as displacement of the "ether ". I suppose negative mass would have a type of repelling effect on mass which I figure is energy of various negative mass. Radio waves are relatively low in negative mass along with photons.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoI didn't think there was such a thing as negative mass. That is, you can hypothetically have gravity that is repulsive, but you cannot have negative mass because mass is a property of matter conveyed by the Higgs field. All matter has some positive value for mass; the measure of the matter's resistance to acceleration. Photons (a.k.a energy, including radio waves) do not interact with the Higgs field and so have zero mass. There is no negative Higgs field, and no negative mass. There's also no ether either as originally constructed (it was ruled out by experiment) but you could be speaking metaphorically.
- scotty79 3y agoSo is it really the energy of coupling between particles and Higgs field (along with other kinds of energy and momentum) that reshapes the spacetime?
- slowmovintarget 3y agoI don't think I know the math well enough to answer the question definitively, but given my surface understanding of the Standard Model and GR... I think so (though I suspect "energy of coupling" is the wrong way to put it).
- andrewflnr 3y agoMost mass of massive objects doesn't come from the higgs mechanism. It's mostly the relativistic mass (?) of binding energy in protons and neutrons. So, I'm not sure the Higgs field needs to be involved at all.
- 3y ago
- Zambyte 3y agoI have no background in physics beyond my highschool class, but how I understand gravity is this: matter has inertia, the universe is expanding "up" (into the future, away from the Big Bang) and out (stretching the surface), the inertia of the matter causes a depression in the spacetime, and the normal force of that curved spacetime causes objects to "attract" each other. This also seems to explain the relationship between gravity and the rate at which time passes (time dilation). Is this understanding wrong by generally accepted science?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 3y ago> Is this understanding wrong by generally accepted science? Yes. It's also not relevant to the discussion in this thread. The properties of gravity under discussion here have nothing whatever to do with expansion of the universe.
- Zambyte 3y ago> Yes. I was hoping for some elaboration. > The properties of gravity under discussion here have nothing whatever to do with expansion of the universe. At least part of the discussion is about gravity being (caused by? understood as?) the curvature of spacetime. Why would matter curve spacetime, if not for the accelerated expansion of spacetime + matter resisting acceleration due to inertia? I'm also OOTL on the boson part (remember, high school physics). I'm asking to hope to understand the subject better.
- pdonis 3y ago> I was hoping for some elaboration. If you mean elaboration on how the expansion of the universe works, I can give that, but as I've said, it's irrelevant to this discussion. > At least part of the discussion is about gravity being (caused by? understood as?) the curvature of spacetime. More precisely, the curvature of spacetime around an isolated gravitating body. Which is a very different spacetime geometry from the spacetime geometry of the universe as a whole, which is what cosmologists use to account for the observations that lead us to say that the universe is expanding. > Why would matter curve spacetime, if not for the accelerated expansion of spacetime You have it backwards. What you are calling "the accelerated expansion of spacetime" is an effect of spacetime curvature, not a cause of it. Plus, as I said above, that spacetime curvature is the curvature of the universe as a whole, which is very different from the curvature around an isolated gravitating body, that we are discussing here. > matter resisting acceleration due to inertia? This has nothing to do with spacetime curvature at all. It would be present even if spacetime were flat.
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoThe top reddit answer in wrong in the most irritating way. And Higgs boson has nothing to do with gravity. And Higgs boson interaction only accounts for 1% of the mass of matter. According to relativity, energy IS mass and Higgs field gives non zero energy to Higgs boson.
- snarkconjecture 3y agoNeither the OP nor the top answer on Reddit mentioned the Higgs boson. You're right, but I'm not sure who you're rebutting.
- m3kw9 3y agoI would say gravity is a force, how the heck is this 100lb weight a 100lb weight?
- pdonis 3y ago> how the heck is this 100lb weight a 100lb weight? Because the scale that reads 100 lb is pushing up on the weight. The same would be true if the scale was inside a rocket accelerating at 1 g in deep space, far from all gravitating bodies. (This is called the equivalence principle.) In other words, the 100 lb of force you are calling "weight" is not a "force of gravity"; there is no such thing. It's a non-gravitational force exerted by the scale on the weight.
- lazide 3y agoThe force drawing the weight and the mass of the earth 'under' it together (with the scale in the middle) however clearly exists as much as the electromagnetic force though. Or stars, planets, etc. wouldn't (and couldn't) exist. As to the exact details of how we account for it is another matter. Calling gravity 'measured spacetime curvature' or 'gravitational force', or coming up with pseudo particles, or whatever, is an accounting method. Either way, it's still there. But it does clearly exist, as much as light (for example) does. All one needs to do to prove that is look out the window.
- pdonis 3y ago> The force drawing the weight and the mass of the earth 'under' it together There is no such force. Think of the accelerating rocket: there is no "force drawing the weight and the scale together". There is just the rocket pushing. The same is true standing on the Earth: there is just the ground pushing. One of the reasons we need "spacetime curvature" in GR is to explain how the ground can be pushing things in different directions in different parts of the Earth, while all those things still remain stationary relative to the Earth's center and each other. But the whole point is that, even with all that factored in, there is still no "force drawing the weight and the Earth together". There is just the ground pushing up, plus spacetime geometry to account for the global configuration. That's it.
- Jun8 3y agoThe top answer given here is highly reductionist to the point of misleading. This question comes up regularly in Physics SE, if you’re interested I suggest you check out the answers to the following: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/219306/if-gravity-isnt-a-force-then-why-do-we-learn-in-school-that-it-is/219307#219307 https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/219306/if-gravit... https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/61899/why-do-we-still-need-to-think-of-gravity-as-a-force?noredirect=1&lq=1 https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/61899/why-do-we-... Second one has a highly upvoted but controversial answer by Lubos Motl. This question is similar, I think, to others like “why is there a speed limit in the universe” and “does light slow down in a material” that are I doubly muddled for science enthusiasts because (1) they are concepts that require deep domain knowledge, (2) even for some who have (1) they’ve been biased by decades of well meaning but harmful educational aides.
- slingnow 3y ago> The top answer given here is highly reductionist to the point of misleading This is my expectation for every single "expert" answer on Reddit. Confidence without substance.
- malfist 3y agoThat's what finally broke by reddit addiction and relying on the Internet for advice. There's lots of people out there that mean well and have strong opinions and state things with confidence that they don't necessary know for truth. I recall thinking that I don't critically examine what appears to be expert input from redditors in a field I know little about, but those same voices in areas I am an expert in are almost always wrong, or nuanced in some way to make them useless. I finally drew the line and realized it wasn't just my field that had wrong "experts" it was every field. I think the final straw was when I asked a really complex question about a aberration in my telescope in the astrophotography subreddits and got very authoritative sounding responses that were far far off base, I realized it wasn't just software engineering. I wonder how much of it is teens and young adults without a lot of experience giving advice that's the problem here. Probably not, but something to think about. That person giving you advice on how to navigate your relationship with your spouse might be a 13 year old who's never dated anyone before.
- ck2 3y agoAs I understand it, Boson makes particles behave as if they had mass. Gravity doesn't work on things without mass (or pretend mass) so Boson is critical to gravity's behavior? Related PBS Space Time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0Q4UAiKacw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0Q4UAiKacw
- qnleigh 3y agoActually gravity does affect massless objects. It can bend the path of light, even though photons are massless. See 'gravitational lensing' for some cool photographic evidence :). The Higg's Boson gives mass to many particles; this might be part of what you're thinking of. Whether gravity is described by bosons at its deepest level is strictly speaking an open question, though many models of quantum gravity treat it this way.
- ck2 3y agoGravity does not bend light or move photons. Gravity changes the path light has to take, photons keep going where they were going in the first place. Light doesn't escape a black hole because it is being pulled by gravity, it is just being given an infinite path to travel so it never gets there.
- freddealmeida 3y agoIt doesn't. Modern cosmology is so full of holes. Nothing can be determined through experiment.
- cjfd 3y agoTo me it seems the equivalence principle is actually false. It was an inspiration to come up with general relativity but the resulting theory supports it kind of, but not really. To start out with, it only holds either looking at an infinitesimal extent of space or in a homogeneous gravitational field. As soon as the gravitational field cannot be seen as homogeneous, you are going to know that you are falling instead of floating through space. E.g., spaghettification near a black hole. Another case in point is the somewhat well-known question if a falling electron radiates. Yes, it should, but that violates the equivalence principle.
- SamBam 3y agoMy understanding is that the equivalence principle only applies to a specific, local region of space time, and this region could be arbitrarily small. Tidal forces are only measurable across something with size, by measuring a difference between one point and another. Even if your body is being spaghettified, an arbitrarily small region of your body still can't tell that it's under anything but freefall.
- garyrob 3y agoI was wondering exactly that same thing just yesterday!
- Razengan 3y agoGravity is a compression algorithm, for more efficient processing of matter in contiguous batches.
- devaiops9001 3y agoThere is a modern explanation for gravity that is actually rather simple and strongly cohesive. But it doesn't align with modern orthodoxy, so it's not worth mentioning here.
- silent_cal 3y agoCan someone please present the argument for why gravity is not a force? This makes no sense to me.
- itodd 3y agoScienceClic on Youtube has amazing videos on this topic as does Veritasium. Einstein's happiest thought helps with understanding this. He thought that there would be no discernible difference between what a man felt while falling off a ladder (let's not factor in air resistance) and what a person in 0g space felt. We are actually "accelerating" upwards at a constant rate that is equal to what we feel and many think of as gravity. This is because spacetime is curved by the mass of the earth. Think of a grid being distorted or squeezed / pinched. The distortion pinching is "gravity". Everything in the grid still travels in a straight path relative tot he lines on the grid but since the [spacetime] grid is pinched, it looks as if it is not on a straight path.
- silent_cal 3y agoThank you
- cthalupa 3y agoThere's quite a lot of arguments back and forth about it through this whole thread if you really want to dive into it. The cliff notes is effectively that gravity is not a force in GR. It is considered a force in newtonian physics, and might be a force again if we ever make a Theory of Everything. Gravity is fairly akin to a force in string theory, so if they do end up being right, gravity would be a force. If the Loop Quantum Gravity folks are right, gravity will remain not a force. If it's some other theory, who knows what it'll end up being.
- silent_cal 3y agoI'm not about to comb through threads on Hacker News and synthesize a theory from comments by people who may or may not know what they're talking about. But thanks.
- amai 3y agoGravity might not be a force, but it is described by a field theory. And field theories can/must be quantized. So the question is really just a different way of asking, if we need to quantize gravity: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/6980/what-are-the-reasons-to-expect-that-gravity-should-be-quantized https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/6980/what-are-th...